Original Italian Pizza and Restaurant

This place should be arrested for serving food.
Where do I even begin? This “restaurant” (if you can even call it that) looked like a horror movie set from the outside with caution tape and the steps were about to fall apart. And yet somehow it only got worse inside. I should have turned around the second I saw the sketchy parking lot and the caution tape , but curiosity (and hunger) got the best of me. Big mistake
The food? I’ve had gas station sandwiches that tasted better than this. It was nasty like the pasta was so sour tasting and watery that I couldn’t finish the first bite. The salad was warm and soggy. The bread was hard as a rock. The pizza tasted like just cheese no sauce or bread. The mozzarella sticks tasted like damn funnel cake. It’s like someone dared the cook to make this stuff blindfolded with expired ingredients. I wouldn’t feed it to a raccoon.
And let’s talk about the service. It wasn’t too bad other than the fact that it took 10 minutes to be seated and we had been walked by a million times like we were freaking invisible. It’s like we blended into the nasty walls.
As for the staff and the customers… yikes! It felt like we accidentally walked into a weird cult meeting where outsiders weren’t welcome. Everyone stared at us like we owed them money or something. It made us feel uncomfortable.
Oh, and the prices? Laughable. They had the audacity to charge us fine prices for food that looked and tasted like it came from a middle school cafeteria trash can.
SAVE YOUR MONEY, your stomach, and your soul. Just eat cereal at home. It will taste better and you won’t leave wondering if you have been cursed.

DONT GO HERE UNLESS THEY CHANGE SOME STUFF!!!!

Overall this place was ass

1. The menu prices were cheaper than the actual price and they didn't change it or warn us.

2. The mozzarella sticks's breading tasted like funnel cake meaning it was cooked in way too old oil.

3. The pizza was mid. You couldn't taste the sauce it was just cheese

4. The outside of the building was falling apart but at least they bothered to put caution tape around the front steps

5. The bread was as hard as a rock. Things were definitely pre made

All in all the staff was fast and the food came but the food was ass and I wouldn't go there again

There is one waitress who is always snarky, short, and just not pleasant. I ordered a fish sandwich which states it has tartar sauce on it. I asked for no tartar sauce and add mayo. She says that’s what comes on it when it’s in the garden. My husband had questions and she was so short and snippy with him. Next time we come if she is working I will ensure we do not get seated with her.

Been going to this restaurant for several years now only had one issue ever other than that I think they have great pizza and definitely love their hoagies their homemade fresh bread is definitely a must try I'm not positive if it's homemade fresh but I was told it is so don't take my word for it experience it for yourself.

Watched them take a pizza pie off a metal tray and sell it to me for a fresh one it was horrible they cut the slices real small like for a kid it was hard and crunchy next to burnt I had many pies from there I know the difference between a reheated and fresh made pizza I liked the place but won't stand for that kind of product I work to hard to throw away my moey

The boys and I go to OIP every Thursday, and our favorite waitress Lisa is always here ready for us, with all our orders memorized. Lisa is the MVP!!

It’s always a pleasure to have Amber as our waitress

Always a pleasure to have Amber as my waitress.

We just held a baby shower here on 11/20/2024. Amber did an excellent job handling all 22 of us. Food was excellent! Thank you for accomodating us!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The wings are great! The cheese pizza is so good and is definitely my go to order when I am watching Home Alone at Christmas time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The only reason for 3 stars is im not a huge fan of the sauce. Each to their own, i grew up in an area with a different type of sauce so naturally not my cup of tea. Still delicious pizza and well priced!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Host was extremely rude. Walked away and did not even take my drink order when she came back and seen I did not get a drink still did not get me a drink thank God our waitress was a sweetheart even though they where out of almost everything. Spent over 100$

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Lots of tvs for watching news and sports. Great service, friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very disappointed ?. Stromboli was two pieces of ham and 4 pepperoni and was so small . Cheese steak Stromboli was a joje as well very little meat in both but lots of cheese not what I ordered at all I ordered a Stromboli not a somewhat ham Stromboli had no taste either one was so blan ...I do not recommend this place at all since this is my 2nd time eating here thought I'd try it again thinking maybe first time was just a bad day for someone but nope. they cheat their customers as I see it absolutely horrible experience again ..take the time go to millville oip where u get your money worth and an actual what you order with meat inside ..should be ashamed of yourself for running a business this way the customer is what makes you don't cheat them out of money because you decided to be cheap what a waste of my time and hard earned money for a relaxing night of not having to cook ..I should have cooked how sad

Called in an order for lunch. One item was grilled chicken in the garden. I wanted the grilled chicken because it's more bland and easier on a stomach just getting over covid. We'll when I got it home it was NOT grilled but a breaded patty cut up like used for chicken parm. Very disappointed considering my first real food after covid recovery. I wanted grilled NOT breaded. I guess ill have to open my food before leaving with it from now on.

Food: 2