Restaurants near Galeton

“Great food! Expanded menu, something for everyone. Awesome pies made locally. All the ambience you want in a mountain restaurant/ bar. Family friendly and new owner! Don't walk, run to this place if you love roast beef and gravy on your fries! Wholesome meals!! The staff is so accommodating I couldn't wait to get there to see what the new owner has done! You won't be disappointed! This place has a new owner, please see recent posts. Follow them on Facebook for daily specials! You won't be disappointed!”

“I was up at camp alone and decided to give the New Plaza Cafe a try... The place is clean, staff and patrons friendly, the price was right, and breakfast was excellent. But the side of sausage gravy gets the MVP. Also the coffee was hot, good, and endless. Thanks! I'll be back!”

“Potter County's little hidden treasure. The bar is a friendly environment with pleasant staff and great drinks. Saturdays they have karaoke (my guilty pleasure). Love the DJ! He has a large song selection and is always open to requests.”

“My son and I were there on November 15 2025. The food was great especially the godfather pizza. My favorite. Also was my birthday so got a dessert and it was the Carmel apple tart that was great. Our waitress was the best. Great place”

“GREAT STAFF, VERY GOOD SUBWAY FOOD ALWAYS, And At Subways Normal Prices...This Is a Small Subway, being in a smaller type convenience store, compared to the stores of today...BUT IT IS THE BEST QUALITY OF SUBWAY FOOD ANYWHERE IN POTTER !!!”

“we gave your Restaurant tonight, Friday night , 6/27/2025 another try. what a difference, the food was Really good ,had great flavor, cooked well, salad bar was fresh, and mostly your Waitresses were Awesome, kept checking to see if we needed anything .Keep up the good work and we will keep coming back.”

“Absolutely delicious food. And our waitress Jessica was fantastic. We already booked for next year October 8th 2026.”

“I can’t believe I live here for almost a decade and have never tried this place. Let me first say that the overall experience was fantastic! From the atmosphere to the customer service. But let me get to the food… so I am from Philadelphia originally, and not only the fact that I love the eagles stuff on the walls, they by far have the best cheesesteak in at-least 3 counties! There was no greater feeling eating that cheese steak it reminded me of Philly! Don’t be like me and sleep on this place, try it out as soon as you can you will not be disappointed.”