Mike N' Dangelo's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Do not waste your money this is the worst sub EVER I ordered a gourmet combo there was 1 piece of ham only for 12.dollars the should be ashamed if you want a bread and lettuce sandwich then go for it i will let everyone I know about this maybe they should close because this is not how you treat customers

Very good pizza. Absolutely would eat here again. Good quality for price for two large pizzas

Do you like gambling? Then this is the place for you! At Mike N' Dangelo's, you can spend $160 and they can still get your order wrong! Maybe you'll hit the jackpot and they won't mess your order up! Big maybe! My family and I weren't so lucky. Every time my family and I have eaten from here in the past three years our order has been wrong in one aspect or another. Foods always good, orders never right. Enjoy your edible slot machines!

Great food, good service! Pizza and Wings always on point. Thanks for being part of Girard!

Good food and good service! Thank you for making us feel like valued customers!

I ordered a calzone with extra ricotta, mushrooms, sausage and meatballs. I got an undercooked calzone just full of giant cubes of ham? This isn’t the first time we’ve gotten incorrect or subpar food. We thought we’d give them another try and waited an hour for an incorrect order and everything else was cold.

Service inside was horrible! Had all of our food in to go containers, Styrofoam plates and plastic silverware. Never came out to see how the meal was or if we needed anything else. Floors where dirty and some crumbs still left on most of the tables. The lights where also dimming and flickering. My family and I will never dine in again. Food was great as always though ?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Ravioli, Chicken Ranch Pizza, Stuffed Shells

Food was good. Had to wait a long time

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

My office got our lunch catered and everything was simply amazing! Food was delicious, fresh, and everyone raved about the cheesy potatoes and Stromboli! Excellent job! We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I normally don’t write reviews on Google, but this experience was bad. My husband and I came in knowing to be very clear about what we were ordering. My husband placed his order of a grilled chicken sub w/o mayo. I literally point to the sub I wanted which was the Club Sub with cheddar cheese . We left and came back, we were gone for like 20 minutes. And when we got back they had not even started out subs. And when they asked me what I order, they looked around like they didn’t have the order ticket. Both of your workers there had asked me what I order and I had the menu in front of me, and yet again I pointed to what we ordered. They still looked frazzled and didn’t know what was going on. The guy in the back then even said ‘I don’t know what is what.” Are you kidding me? Finally after waiting for what seemed like a half hour they come out with the family’s food and our food as well. But they were so confused that they were about to give my husbands sub to the other family. And the other family and I are trying to decipher what subs are who’s. Well they come out with 2 Italian Subs that the family ordered only 1. So then I’m like this is not my sub and I then again explain what sub I got the Club Sub with Cheddar with pointing again. She goes back and makes it, so I waited again for my sub to be made. She comes and hands it to me. She was like is everything ok, I said no, because of the long wait and I said because I’m not even sure if my sub is correct. I hand the subs off to my husband and then meet him out in the car. Well then I open my sub and it’s completely wrong, it’s the Italian sub again, not the Club sub. I was so frustrated that I just dealt with it and ripped the pepperoni and bacon off of it to just eat some of it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ordered online through Uber Eats for delivery. Just a pizza. After waiting an hour PAST the quoted delivery time, I called and they told me no one came to pick it up. They wouldn’t refund me the delivery fee, I had to go pick it up myself, and the pizza was tough and cold.
The people at the store just laughed when I told them I was there for the delivery and tossed the pizza box on the counter. Extremely unprofessional and rude staff. First and only experience I will have at this store.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ordered a meatball and cheese sub add- mushrooms and onions. They forgot the cheese and the meatballs are smashed up like a meat sauce? There are zero meatballs on the entire sub.

Good pizza. Good spaghetti, good fettuccine

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: The 54, Meatballs, Traditional Wings, Large Fresh Dough Cheese Pizza 8 Slices

We are from Harborcreek and we came camping at Camp Sherwin and we were looking for some place close to get some food. We were kinda late settling up our camper so we didn't have time to cook. I had Spaghetti and my wife had a sub. I got a large portion of Spaghetti witch was excellent. The sub was large and filled and tasty. Wil be back again. Highly recommend.

Hadn't been there for a while but wanted their spaghetti. It wasn't easy to place a take out order. No one seemed to know what was on the menu. Two different people had to come to the phone to talk to me. I was just ordering off of the menu that was posted on their website. Shouldn't have been any problem. Specifically asked for extra meatballs on the side. The people on the phone were snippy and didn't seem to want to be bothered with taking my order. When we picked up our order they basically threw the bag at my husband and rushed him out the door. We got home and the extra meatballs weren't in the bag. They gave us the wrong salad dressing. I didn't bother to call and complain because they'll likely just say they'll give me the meatballs free with my next order but I don't really want to place another order with this place after this unpleasant experience.