We got wings, slices, and cheesesteaks and everything was DELICIOUS. I haven’t had a great slice of pizza in what feels like forever and this place hit the spot. The cheesesteaks were also probably the best in the area! Will be our new go to spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry Mackenzie
Great food. Fresh and prepared well. Not a long wait at all. Just wish you had a restroom for the customers. It makes sense to wash hands before eating. My father wasn’t able to use a restroom so we may not return again because of this.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Murgidi
Cheese Steak was beautiful. Current average price. Friendly service. Pizza looks amazing. Will definitely get a Pie in addition to the steak next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak with Fried Onions
Joe D
I was in the area recently, and as tradition goes, I never pass up the chance to grab a cheesesteak. This time, my brother insisted I try a new spot (new for me) and brought me to Pop's Pizzeria.
We ordered our cheesesteaks to go, keeping things classic with grilled onions and Cooper Sharp. While we waited, we each grabbed a slice of pizza. It was a great warm-up, and before long our cheesesteaks arrived, neatly wrapped and ready to take with us.
Once we got back and dug in, the first thing I noticed was the generous amount of cheese. It made the sandwich wonderfully creamy and flavorful, a refreshing change, especially since some nearby places have been a little stingy with the cheese lately. This felt like a proper, full-flavored cheesesteak.
Overall, it was a satisfying meal from start to finish, and I am sure I will stop by again the next time I am in the area. Solid five stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda
The entire car ride back from picking up, all I could smell was the sauce on our pizza, thank God it was in the backseat or I may have opened the box at a light! I grabbed a slice the moment the box hit the counter and it did not disappoint. The sauce is amazing. Pizza was devoured. But the reason we stopped there was to try the cheese steak, which we thought fell short. The seeded roll wasn't toasted, the meat had more gristle than we prefer but what killed it was all the black pepper - it was hard to taste anything else. We ended up throwing out most of it. Definitely will come back again for pizza though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Scotty Scottoline
Based on past reviews, ordered a pizza there last night for the first time. I was sorely disappointed. I specifically ordered sliced Heirloom Tomatoes and instead they put on a couple of scrawny 1/2 cherry tomatoes. Also, there were large areas of the crust with no cheese, sauce or topping = NOTHING. How could this place get 4.5 rating?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
My Honest Opinion
They used to give more meat than this. $15 for a chicken cheesesteak, not much chicken in it.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Steven P.
The cheesesteaks at Pop's Pizzeria were definitely a highlight! They use high-quality meat with good seasonings, and the rolls were incredibly fresh even though we arrived towards the end of the night. The staff were also very friendly and helpful throughout our visit. My only critique, which prevents a 5-start reading, is the unfortunate smell inside Pop's. Since they are located next door to a cigar lounge, the smoke smell is noticeable, which detracted from the overall dining experience. We only ate half of it meal there then had the sandwiches wrapped to go and finish at home. Despite the smell, the delicious food and great service ensure we'll be back for another cheesesteak, but definitely to go!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak with Fried Onions, Sesame Seed Roll
Maya Centrella
Pop's Pizzeria in Glenn Mills is seriously the best food I have had in this area, and I have lived here my whole life. Nino knows how to cook!!!! Endless menu options and a ton of creative meals on the menu that are only available at Pop's---like a chicken caesar pizza. You must try their cheesesteaks as well-- so incredibly good and the most ordered item. Get the seeded roll!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DawnK
Ok so I’ve have had ur pizza and cheesesteaks and meatballs which are really good. Took a chance on your dinners and was a bit disappointed. The scampi, Marsala chicken and artichoke chicken was not good.
What a gem Pop’s Pizzeria is! I was killing time while my car was at David Dodge Chrysler Jeep for service, and decided to grab a bite here. Michael was manning the counter and went above and beyond when I asked for plastic silverware—he hooked me up right away with a friendly smile. It was exactly the kind of helpful service that turns a routine stop into a memorable one. The pizza itself was top-notch, with fresh ingredients and perfect crust. Thank you so much, Mike! If you’re nearby, do yourself a favor and check out Pop’s—five stars all the way for the food and hospitality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyle Hoffman
I felt like it was not nearly as good as I expected for their overall high star rating. I picked one of the most expensive pizzas with lots of toppings and it was OK, but not that flavorful. I also didn’t like that There was not an option to get a free glass of water. And there was no normal restroom. I appreciate that they let me go into the back and use the restroom, but it felt pretty awkward walking through the kitchen and using the restroom there which had a lot of storage stuff in it. Staff was nice though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Taylor Mackowsky
I have only ordered the chicken caesar crunch wrap so far, but I ordered it when it first came out before it was even officially on the menu & it was the best thing ever. Then I just had it again recently and they have perfected it even more than I could’ve imagined. 10/10. I ate it so fast because it was so delicious, therefore I don’t have a picture- I simply could not wait to take the first bite. They give a generous amount of each ingredient including a side of caesar dressing to really seal the deal. I can’t wait to go back to try the other crunch wraps & other menu items!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary Davis
First time going to Pops. I ordered the SofiaValentina and the S&P 16 slice Sicilian style pies. Both were amazing and delicious. I will be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jordan Gavin
The best quality, the best tasting, Pop’s never misses! Some of the freshest pizza I’ve ever had and fantastic catering. We’ve used Pop’s for many parties and occasions, at least 2-3 people ask for the catering information. Cannot recommend Pop’s enough!
We got wings, slices, and cheesesteaks and everything was DELICIOUS. I haven’t had a great slice of pizza in what feels like forever and this place hit the spot. The cheesesteaks were also probably the best in the area! Will be our new go to spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food. Fresh and prepared well. Not a long wait at all. Just wish you had a restroom for the customers. It makes sense to wash hands before eating. My father wasn’t able to use a restroom so we may not return again because of this.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheese Steak was beautiful. Current average price. Friendly service. Pizza looks amazing.
Will definitely get a Pie in addition to the steak next time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak with Fried Onions
I was in the area recently, and as tradition goes, I never pass up the chance to grab a cheesesteak. This time, my brother insisted I try a new spot (new for me) and brought me to Pop's Pizzeria.
We ordered our cheesesteaks to go, keeping things classic with grilled onions and Cooper Sharp. While we waited, we each grabbed a slice of pizza. It was a great warm-up, and before long our cheesesteaks arrived, neatly wrapped and ready to take with us.
Once we got back and dug in, the first thing I noticed was the generous amount of cheese. It made the sandwich wonderfully creamy and flavorful, a refreshing change, especially since some nearby places have been a little stingy with the cheese lately. This felt like a proper, full-flavored cheesesteak.
Overall, it was a satisfying meal from start to finish, and I am sure I will stop by again the next time I am in the area. Solid five stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The entire car ride back from picking up, all I could smell was the sauce on our pizza, thank God it was in the backseat or I may have opened the box at a light! I grabbed a slice the moment the box hit the counter and it did not disappoint. The sauce is amazing. Pizza was devoured. But the reason we stopped there was to try the cheese steak, which we thought fell short. The seeded roll wasn't toasted, the meat had more gristle than we prefer but what killed it was all the black pepper - it was hard to taste anything else. We ended up throwing out most of it. Definitely will come back again for pizza though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Based on past reviews, ordered a pizza there last night for the first time. I was sorely disappointed. I specifically ordered sliced Heirloom Tomatoes and instead they put on a couple of scrawny 1/2 cherry tomatoes. Also, there were large areas of the crust with no cheese, sauce or topping = NOTHING. How could this place get 4.5 rating?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
They used to give more meat than this. $15 for a chicken cheesesteak, not much chicken in it.
Food: 3
Service: 3
The cheesesteaks at Pop's Pizzeria were definitely a highlight! They use high-quality meat with good seasonings, and the rolls were incredibly fresh even though we arrived towards the end of the night. The staff were also very friendly and helpful throughout our visit.
My only critique, which prevents a 5-start reading, is the unfortunate smell inside Pop's. Since they are located next door to a cigar lounge, the smoke smell is noticeable, which detracted from the overall dining experience. We only ate half of it meal there then had the sandwiches wrapped to go and finish at home.
Despite the smell, the delicious food and great service ensure we'll be back for another cheesesteak, but definitely to go!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak with Fried Onions, Sesame Seed Roll
Pop's Pizzeria in Glenn Mills is seriously the best food I have had in this area, and I have lived here my whole life. Nino knows how to cook!!!! Endless menu options and a ton of creative meals on the menu that are only available at Pop's---like a chicken caesar pizza. You must try their cheesesteaks as well-- so incredibly good and the most ordered item. Get the seeded roll!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ok so I’ve have had ur pizza and cheesesteaks and meatballs which are really good. Took a chance on your dinners and was a bit disappointed. The scampi, Marsala chicken and artichoke chicken was not good.
Restaurantji Recommends
What a gem Pop’s Pizzeria is! I was killing time while my car was at David Dodge Chrysler Jeep for service, and decided to grab a bite here. Michael was manning the counter and went above and beyond when I asked for plastic silverware—he hooked me up right away with a friendly smile. It was exactly the kind of helpful service that turns a routine stop into a memorable one. The pizza itself was top-notch, with fresh ingredients and perfect crust. Thank you so much, Mike! If you’re nearby, do yourself a favor and check out Pop’s—five stars all the way for the food and hospitality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I felt like it was not nearly as good as I expected for their overall high star rating. I picked one of the most expensive pizzas with lots of toppings and it was OK, but not that flavorful. I also didn’t like that There was not an option to get a free glass of water. And there was no normal restroom. I appreciate that they let me go into the back and use the restroom, but it felt pretty awkward walking through the kitchen and using the restroom there which had a lot of storage stuff in it.
Staff was nice though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
I have only ordered the chicken caesar crunch wrap so far, but I ordered it when it first came out before it was even officially on the menu & it was the best thing ever. Then I just had it again recently and they have perfected it even more than I could’ve imagined. 10/10. I ate it so fast because it was so delicious, therefore I don’t have a picture- I simply could not wait to take the first bite. They give a generous amount of each ingredient including a side of caesar dressing to really seal the deal. I can’t wait to go back to try the other crunch wraps & other menu items!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time going to Pops. I ordered the SofiaValentina and the S&P 16 slice Sicilian style pies. Both were amazing and delicious. I will be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best quality, the best tasting, Pop’s never misses! Some of the freshest pizza I’ve ever had and fantastic catering. We’ve used Pop’s for many parties and occasions, at least 2-3 people ask for the catering information. Cannot recommend Pop’s enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...