They literally have the best jalapeño poppers I've ever had. My burger was cooked to perfection and their entrée salads are so big and delicious! Service was also great!
Delilah Mendez
Food wasn’t that good considering the higher prices. Drinks were good for St. Patrick’s day. No band even though it was listed on their website. Waitress seemed clueless. Small place. Won’t be back. Just eh ok. Wasn’t impressed
Shawn Harbeson
Did not eat here drinks and service was fantastic very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Trent Stumbaugh
We recently had a celebration of life for a friend and coworker at Fireside. Abbey, Grace and the rest of the team were extremely accommodating and provided a great experience, on short notice. The venue, food and service were all top notch. I would recommend checking them out for your next party or gathering. Thanks so much to staff at Fireside for helping the Negley’s Water team!
Ross
We had our wedding celebration at Fireside Pub and everything was perfect. The food and cocktails were great, the staff were friendly and accommodating. Abbey and Ben took care of every detail for us. Could not have asked for more.
HiroWasabi
The place seems barely able to manage. The menu describes food that is dramatically different than what is delivered. The modifications that are listed in the menu like swapping your protein or choosing your side is met with your server saying the “chef” doesn’t like when you make those changes and they can’t happen. And then when the food finally comes and the sides are wrong and the food is cold when the place is mostly empty, it makes for an underwhelming experience in a lovely setting with a high price tag.
Andrea Renner-Clark
Well, we tried this place again after a few years. Unfortunately, it was a disappointment. We waited for a very long time for our food, and when it arrived, my fries were cold. The manager was busy chatting at the bar, while the waitresses ran all over the place trying to serve all the tables. The food was ok otherwise. We won't be back again for a while, I guess.
Joham Castro
Was seated and attended to quickly, everyone order drinks, appetizers, and supper, the drink did not arrive until half way done eating supper, the drink were very bland the server was decent but could show improvement
Was here for a wedding. Food and drinks were great.
E8857GRbruces
I travel occasionally to Syracuse, New York on business and seized the opportunity to visit my dear mother in Greencastle, PA, for a belated Mother's Day brunch at this friendly and beautiful golf course restaurant. I made reservations the day before and requested a vase of fresh flower on the table to enhance Mom's day out. The restaurant has a limited menu, but the food they prepare is delicious, served promptly, and the staff is top notch. The entrance has a drive through and a small ramp for seniors. Mom navigated it like a pro and we were soon seated in a corner tale with a view of the 18th green. Mom loves cats and we even had a gray and white tabby who visited us, waiting politely for tidbits. Mom did not disappoint and made a new friend. Thanks to everyone for making a memorable and enjoyable experience. we shall return. Less I forget. The flowers were there as ordered and Mom loved it, We were the only table with flowers!
sandy bearden
First time! Very nice place. We went on Trivia night, so it was noisey. Fun was had by all!! Great food. Great service!!
Audra Bingaman
This is a great place to relax, talk to friends, laugh and enjoy the scenery. Great food! Staff is personable and always aims to please. Highly recommend.
Yummy food, great ambiance and view, and always friendly staff. Love the seasonal drinks also ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food. Nice people.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Quesadilla, Fireside Crab Cakes
They literally have the best jalapeño poppers I've ever had. My burger was cooked to perfection and their entrée salads are so big and delicious! Service was also great!
Food wasn’t that good considering the higher prices. Drinks were good for St. Patrick’s day. No band even though it was listed on their website. Waitress seemed clueless. Small place. Won’t be back. Just eh ok. Wasn’t impressed
Did not eat here drinks and service was fantastic very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
We recently had a celebration of life for a friend and coworker at Fireside. Abbey, Grace and the rest of the team were extremely accommodating and provided a great experience, on short notice. The venue, food and service were all top notch. I would recommend checking them out for your next party or gathering. Thanks so much to staff at Fireside for helping the Negley’s Water team!
We had our wedding celebration at Fireside Pub and everything was perfect. The food and cocktails were great, the staff were friendly and accommodating. Abbey and Ben took care of every detail for us. Could not have asked for more.
The place seems barely able to manage. The menu describes food that is dramatically different than what is delivered. The modifications that are listed in the menu like swapping your protein or choosing your side is met with your server saying the “chef” doesn’t like when you make those changes and they can’t happen. And then when the food finally comes and the sides are wrong and the food is cold when the place is mostly empty, it makes for an underwhelming experience in a lovely setting with a high price tag.
Well, we tried this place again after a few years. Unfortunately, it was a disappointment. We waited for a very long time for our food, and when it arrived, my fries were cold. The manager was busy chatting at the bar, while the waitresses ran all over the place trying to serve all the tables. The food was ok otherwise. We won't be back again for a while, I guess.
Was seated and attended to quickly, everyone order drinks, appetizers, and supper, the drink did not arrive until half way done eating supper, the drink were very bland the server was decent but could show improvement
Restaurantji Recommends
Was here for a wedding. Food and drinks were great.
I travel occasionally to Syracuse, New York on business and seized the opportunity to visit my dear mother in Greencastle, PA, for a belated Mother's Day brunch at this friendly and beautiful golf course restaurant. I made reservations the day before and requested a vase of fresh flower on the table to enhance Mom's day out. The restaurant has a limited menu, but the food they prepare is delicious, served promptly, and the staff is top notch. The entrance has a drive through and a small ramp for seniors. Mom navigated it like a pro and we were soon seated in a corner tale with a view of the 18th green. Mom loves cats and we even had a gray and white tabby who visited us, waiting politely for tidbits. Mom did not disappoint and made a new friend. Thanks to everyone for making a memorable and enjoyable experience. we shall return. Less I forget. The flowers were there as ordered and Mom loved it, We were the only table with flowers!
First time! Very nice place. We went on Trivia night, so it was noisey. Fun was had by all!! Great food. Great service!!
This is a great place to relax, talk to friends, laugh and enjoy the scenery. Great food! Staff is personable and always aims to please. Highly recommend.
Very good food and excellent service!