Godfather's Pizza Express

705 Buchanan Trail E, Greencastle
(717) 597-4713

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lori

Not of cheese lot of toping I got meat lovers lot of meat best pizza I ever tasted 😋 good 5 five stars chep good prices

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ted Lospinoso

Waited over 350 miles from Tennessee just to finally get here and didn’t even have the supplies to make the pizza. Epic fail.

Service: 1

Greg Gillie

Nothing was even turned on, no food,ordered ahead online and drove 30 minutes out of my way ! It was my fault for not checking my email because my order was cancelled and refunded before I got there.Does not look like most of the ones I've seen out west! This was at 2 pm on a Sunday

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pat Baye

Went for lunch on a Friday, was told the kitchen is closed. Unable to get any food!

Irene Fray

Godfathers has always been my favorite pizza since my childhood.

I have tried every pizza place in Hagerstown before starting to look in adjacent towns before discovering that this quaint lil gas station serves pizza as good as I remember it.

English is not the first language of the employees I spoke to, but they were incredibly kind and got the orders right over the phone and in person. That's what counts at the end of the day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deluxe Cheese Pizza, Large Specialty Pizza Large 1-Topping Pizza and a 2 Liter of Soda

William Johnson

Gvery good pizza and friendly service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt m

Thanks for the pies, ladies. Cheers!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Derek 303 Schick

Godfathers Pizza is delicious! It reminds me of how Pizza Hut tasted in the early 90’s before they messed up their recipe! The sauce and crust are great! I wish they had more locations throughout the country!

D O

Nothing special. Staff is unprofessional. I watched an off duty employee steal a bunch of food when his co-worker's back was turned. The "Hot n Readys" from Little Caesars are better, and a whole lot cheaper too.

Amber Nichols

Staff is very unprofessional and rude.

james moreau

Gas station with a pizza machine. Is good for gas station pizzA, but not what I was looking for.

J W

Such good pizza, shame they don't have any near me as I picked up a pizza on my way back from OBX

Mary Hamlet

Really busy. Can get crowded. Food is awsum!!!!!! I'm a vegetarian and loved the selection.cant wait to try he pizza

Blissgarden

I love their pizza! Very yummy deep dish style with lots of cheese. Very conveniently located off hwy 20. I enjoy the personal pizzas to go.

Reviews4youBW

Godfather’s pizza has excellent tangy pizza sauce! They put plenty of toppings and the pizza crust is delish! I had never had Godfather’s pizza and was needing a quick bite while traveling. Thankfully, they had ready made pizzas and I got a small one. I was pleasantly surprised. It was a little dry as you might expect with a ready made, but i was blown away by the great ROBUST flavor. Needless to say, I came back to try a freshly made pizza and was not disappointed! SO good. Godfather’s is now my go to pizza. So glad they’re in my area! The price is great, too!

Loading...