John Allison Public House

Absolutely hands down one of the best if not the best restaurants in Greencastle, PA!! AJ has done a superb job with taking over ownership not to mention keeping the fantastic chefs and I am sure adding new chefs too!

Drinks, alcoholic or nonalcoholic are superb as well! The atmosphere is amazing, great customer service staff, with the choice to eat casual in the bar or restaurant side of the bar or enhance your evening with date night to enjoy the more formal dining experience.

Plus BONUS, for all your event needs you can also book their banquet room for special occasions. We held our daughter’s graduation party here years ago!

Check out these images

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Definitely my favorite eating place in greencastle PA

Stopped here on a long road trip. We had the French dip panini and fish sandwich. Very tasty and reasonably priced. Staff was friendly. Would definitely recommend

Excellent food, superior service. Would highly recommend the marinated ranch steak, crabcake sandwich with sweet potato fries, bacon cheese fries, and Maryland crab soup. Everything we had was fresh and delicious. Our waitress, Tabitha, was stellar. We never once had to ask for a refill or anything else, she was one step ahead the entire time and had a great personality. Highly recommend for lunch, dinner or anything in between.

The staff, atmosphere and food are amazing. We are having our wedding reception here and we can't wait

This burger was supposed to have bacon on it. I really do not like leaving negative feedback for establishments, but I am tired of them not getting orders right, and people should be aware. Will not be back.

The service was great and so was the food! We had a great time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Made reservations and ask for a 3:00 time and a TABLE. Was told that they were Soooo busy that the only time they had to accommodate us was 2:00. When we arrived showed us to a booth that my husband did not fit in. They ask if we would sit at a table for 6. I told they no they found a larger booth in another room for us. The restaurant wasn't busy. The food was cold and the drinks were in plastic cups. First time there and will be the last.

Half price burgers on Wednesday, make sure to make a reservation.

Good food, nice place 😄

This is a great restaurant, with good staff and great food. I recommend it to everyone.

I had the Ruben sandwich, and it was fantastic. Great service, I will be back for lunch!!

Dinner, I order the Salmon, it was Dry & mashed potatoes were way to salty & pasty.
However the Panini I had for lunch was EXCELLENT!

Great food and service. The young waitress was one of the most personable and attentive I've had in quite a while. The reuben sandwhich and French dip panini with au jus were great. I hope to try more here.

I ordered salmon mash potatoes and veggies. The salmon was so stiff like it was frozen and cooked. The veggies also tasted like they were frozen. The mash potatoes were the only thing that was good and seemed freshly made.