Tony's New York Pizza

42 S Antrim Way, Greencastle
(717) 597-2152

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cammy Capri

46.58 for 2 large cheese pizzas and 1 Large pepperoni pizzas.. couldn’t eat a whole slice due to the sauce and cheese spilling over and the bottom of the pizzas being burnt.. Frozen pizzas are better than what we were served by this place.. I posted the pictures on Google review but it appears I can’t here..

Wes Free

We ordered a large cheese pizza that tastes awful an order of calamari rings half of the bowl was filled with LETTUCE! The rings were soggy and no marinara dipping sauce. Also ordered a Lg fountain birch beer that was half way full and soda is flat! Called in to tell them our discrepancies and they said they were not going to fix the problems and pretty much called us liars. This place has gone way down hill since new ownership has taken over. This place does not deserve to be in Greencastle.

Vince Martz

Best pizza ever ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brent Black

Great pizza with great prices. We go here often.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Erika Varga

I am new in town and want to support the local businesses. I have been ordering pizza from Tonys on a regular basis. I was happy with their delivery service, and even if the pizza was not always completely satisfactory, I continued to order from them. Tonight, I ordered a grilled chicken salad that I picked up myself. By the time I got home, the paper bag completely soaked through and left a puddle on my car seat. From a chicken salad? I wondered.
In the house I dumped the bag in the sink. From the clear plastic container, I drained another half cup of liquid: my chicken and the whole salad was soaked in water and was all soggy, completely unenjoyable. I called back, but my call was completely useless. This experience totally changed my 5 star review. I am looking for another local business to support.

Danielle Alegria

Disappointed. I’ve had their wings.. much smaller and buffalo sauce doesn’t compare to the old Tony’s. Also I just ordered a penne alavodka. No prosciutto!!! It advertised with deglazed prosciutto and not One morsel!! Only onions. The sauce was like water. Could’ve been a lil thicker. Very disappointing

Jessica Myers

I don’t know what’s causing Tony’s to go downhill. We’ve been ordering from them since we moved here in November 2023. Last time I ordered ravioli which is like $14. When it was delivered it was in a small container with like 3 raviolis in it. I called the store. The girl who answered had an attitude and told me I must have ordered it wrong…I’ve gotten the ravioli before and it always came in a big container. She told me the manager was not there and had no idea what to tell me. Told me the manager would call me back. Never heard from the manager. I just ordered pizza and got it delivered and it looks like someone dropped it on the ground. They have lost me business now.

Daniel Krocker

This place has fallen off a lot. Ordered two capicola subs with lettuce tomato and onion oil and vinegar peppers on the side. The came out no tomato very little oil and vinegar. Plus gobbs of mayo that shouldn't have been there at all. Our order of fries were good what there was of them, less than a small at mcdonalds. New owner has some major work to do

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gabe Hendrickson

Terrible pizza place. Management clearly has no idea what they are doing. Ordered a single Caesar salad, and waited 25 minutes. Don’t waste your time, if your in a rush. No to mention the salad was soggy. The cashiers customer service was terrible, and acted as if it was the customers fault for ordering food and then being behind.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Joshua Lynch

Fabulous. Always a family favorite and the food is on point.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabrielle Eliseo

I like their pizza and strombolis. I’m originally from NE PA where we have real NY pizza. Tony’s is the only local place that comes close.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jyesi knier

Absolute trash service, I can't tell you about their food because I couldn't get that far. I explained to your phone girl I wanted to know the price difference between the sizes of your special. You guys refuse to do that for me and then say I'm waisting your time. Good luck with that business motto.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jonny Test

You have an ego problem. You're upset because you can't answer my questions about your menu. That sounds like a you problem. If you don't want to do your job then close up shop and go home. Ok bye!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Preston Shaw

I've had a few problems with the service but I had to order again tonight ask 3 times for a LG fountain only for them to show up again without it driver raced up the drive way again then said we're busy so it would be hours to bring one then said just don't tip me smfh then just acted smug about it... worst dam restaurant in Greencastle from there food to there treatment of there customers 55 bucks for 2 cheese pizzas a lasagna dinner with a hot salad yuck... I wish domino's pizza would deliver!!!!

Michelle Ricker

Great food and quality service. The food was great and didn't break the bank. As always Tony's did an amazing job.

Loading...