Tony's New York Pizza
42 S Antrim Way, Greencastle
(717) 597-2152
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Put my order in online and it got voided. Even though I have more then enough money.
spoiled me and my partner on my birthday w margs and cake on the house; haven’t tried the food yet but all the happy customers on the way out tells me all i need to know, thank you so much 🫶🏻🫶🏻🥰❤️❤️
I ordered pick up. I got there and they were friendly and professional. They were kind to my toddler (who has a lot of energy). They were punctual with their time stated, and the food was delicious.
Got cheeseburger sub last night got it home to eat it was raw not fried good at all
Ordered two chicken tender kids meals. The chicken was so hard and burnt. It looked like the oil hadn’t been changed in weeks and then it tasted like fried pickles also ordered jalapeño poppers and got breaded mushrooms so now both of my children cannot eat their chicken tenders . After a long night of ball games this was a terrible way to end the night . We ordered from them once before, and our food was not up to past quality so after several months, we decided to give them another try, and it was definitely disappointing to say the very least will never order from them again.
I swear the drivers must take turns at like 40mph since the pizzas always arrive with all toppings and cheese slid to one side. The taste and quality have gone super downhill recently. Very sad.
I ordered a large meatball sub from the Greencastle location along with a large fries. The service was excellent, the delivery was prompt, and the food was delicious!(02/24/25). They will definitely get more business from me!
My boyfriend ordered a large pizza yesterday and when we opened the box the pizza was all over the place. It was absolutely disgusting it looks like someone took the box and shook it. This place has went downhill severely.
Ordered spaghetti with meatballs. The meatballs were RAW inside 🤮
Would you feed this to ur family? Maaaan fuuuuuuuuccck this pizza. Still ate a slice cuz I'm hungry af but this is the worst pizza I've ever had the displeasure of eating
Restaurantji Recommends
Small calzone and an antipasto.....Everything was delicious. Delivered by Masa - the website delivery service. Very prompt, polite, hot food hot, salad wa cold. Would definitely order from Tony's and thru Masa again.!!! GREAT JOB!!
sorry to say this has lost its initial new ownership flair. the extra charges for every little thing, small portion sizes, and taste have made this place fall off my go to list.
46.58 for 2 large cheese pizzas and 1 Large pepperoni pizzas.. couldn’t eat a whole slice due to the sauce and cheese spilling over and the bottom of the pizzas being burnt.. Frozen pizzas are better than what we were served by this place.. I posted the pictures on Google review but it appears I can’t here..
Best pizza in the area
Got take out from here, second time they have forgotten something in the order. Would like to think I don’t have to open the bags and check everything when getting take out when spending 50+
Loading...