Was depressed, ordered a pepperoni Stromboli. No longer depressed. 5/5 would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Keith
Absolutely delicious! I was in the area for a night and Coffaros' Pizza was highly recommended.This is one of THE best pizzas I've had! The crust is chewy, crunchy, and flavorful. The cheese is buttery, silky, and obviously very fresh. The pepperoni is spicy (not hot), and very meaty. It is not your typical store bought sausage.The ONLY thing that I can suggest is to request some extra sauce on the pie, or on the side. (They have what is meant by "Awesome Sauce" ?)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Kasiorek
Subs were good. Pizza was good too but I think it needs more sauce, but that's me.Parking: Parking on street or on side street lot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tom Mugnano
It was getting late on a Saturday night & were from out of town looking for a pizza. Not only was Coffaros open late they have excellent Pizza
Beverly Bright
The Works was the best pizza I've had in a long time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hippiepox
I just moved to the area and I suffer from Gerd & celiac disease. 25% of the time they deliver the pizza non-gluten free and I have to drive over and return it and they replace it (thankfully), but mostly not even an apology even though it could have risked my life to consume.The other 75% is then forgetting to add pepperoni, even if we order 2 pepperoni pizzas - one will come with and one will come with none. How the hell does “two pepperoni pizzas” = one with and one without. Trust me, they aren’t out of pepperoni, they just say “we forgot”.Me and my partner order from there 2 times a month and it’s either A) Missing an item or B) Not Gluten Free.Dietary restrictions: Iffy, they have gluten free pizza but sometimes they forget and give you a gluten pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Steven FinGado
I was at a conference in Grove City on 8/2/23. I stopped in for lunch and ordered a large stromboli. I must say, it was probably one of (if not) the best strombolis I have ever eaten and the price was very good. The owner seemed very proud of his work and made us feel welcome. The next time I am in Grove City or passing through hungry, I am definitely stopping in for another large stromboli without ham.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jean Watson
Just tried this pizza and cheesy bread, it was amazing! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nena U.
Pepperoni Pizza was excellent. I didn't care much for the "hot" wings. I was in the mood for wings & they were disappointing .. not hot or much flavor to them. I look forward to getting other items on the menu next time. The menu looks amazing. We will visit again.
Ernie McMann
We were passing thru the area for the first time while camping. I ordered a pizza having never been there before and didn’t know what to expect. Pleasantly surprised, professional, friendly, on time and everyone liked the pizza. What else could you ask for. When camping in the area again or just passing thru we will stop at Coffaro’s Pizza again.
Love their pizza It's actual pizza not cardboard ?Parking: Parking is on the side of the street!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brock Sloan
Pizza and wings were great! Good special on the wings.
Maureen Salmen
I have ordered lunch on 2 different dates and the delivery has been late each time. I do not recommend. When I tried to contact them, I was put on hold and not able to speak to a live person.
Jessica Baker
Great food great delivery drivers friendly an respectful people I highly recommend
Rachel Hephner
This has been our go to pizza place for years; incredible food and very kind people. Highly recommend over any other establishment including the Dominos. If you're in town for any length of time you have to try their pizza!
Was depressed, ordered a pepperoni Stromboli. No longer depressed. 5/5 would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious! I was in the area for a night and Coffaros' Pizza was highly recommended.This is one of THE best pizzas I've had! The crust is chewy, crunchy, and flavorful. The cheese is buttery, silky, and obviously very fresh. The pepperoni is spicy (not hot), and very meaty. It is not your typical store bought sausage.The ONLY thing that I can suggest is to request some extra sauce on the pie, or on the side. (They have what is meant by "Awesome Sauce" ?)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Subs were good. Pizza was good too but I think it needs more sauce, but that's me.Parking: Parking on street or on side street lot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
It was getting late on a Saturday night & were from out of town looking for a pizza. Not only was Coffaros open late they have excellent Pizza
The Works was the best pizza I've had in a long time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just moved to the area and I suffer from Gerd & celiac disease. 25% of the time they deliver the pizza non-gluten free and I have to drive over and return it and they replace it (thankfully), but mostly not even an apology even though it could have risked my life to consume.The other 75% is then forgetting to add pepperoni, even if we order 2 pepperoni pizzas - one will come with and one will come with none. How the hell does “two pepperoni pizzas” = one with and one without. Trust me, they aren’t out of pepperoni, they just say “we forgot”.Me and my partner order from there 2 times a month and it’s either A) Missing an item or B) Not Gluten Free.Dietary restrictions: Iffy, they have gluten free pizza but sometimes they forget and give you a gluten pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
I was at a conference in Grove City on 8/2/23. I stopped in for lunch and ordered a large stromboli. I must say, it was probably one of (if not) the best strombolis I have ever eaten and the price was very good. The owner seemed very proud of his work and made us feel welcome. The next time I am in Grove City or passing through hungry, I am definitely stopping in for another large stromboli without ham.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just tried this pizza and cheesy bread, it was amazing! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pepperoni Pizza was excellent. I didn't care much for the "hot" wings. I was in the mood for wings & they were disappointing .. not hot or much flavor to them. I look forward to getting other items on the menu next time. The menu looks amazing. We will visit again.
We were passing thru the area for the first time while camping. I ordered a pizza having never been there before and didn’t know what to expect. Pleasantly surprised, professional, friendly, on time and everyone liked the pizza. What else could you ask for. When camping in the area again or just passing thru we will stop at Coffaro’s Pizza again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Love their pizza It's actual pizza not cardboard ?Parking: Parking is on the side of the street!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza and wings were great! Good special on the wings.
I have ordered lunch on 2 different dates and the delivery has been late each time. I do not recommend. When I tried to contact them, I was put on hold and not able to speak to a live person.
Great food great delivery drivers friendly an respectful people I highly recommend
This has been our go to pizza place for years; incredible food and very kind people. Highly recommend over any other establishment including the Dominos. If you're in town for any length of time you have to try their pizza!