I have been ordering from Pellerito's for several years. Last night, I ordered 2 pizzas via Uber Eats. I called the restaurant to ask for several garlic powder and red pepper flakes packets. I spoke with a young girl, did not get her name. When my order arrived, the cups that the powder were in was a decent size. But when I opened it, there was only about half a tablespoon of garlic powder in there, if that. For me, that's not enough for even 4 slices of pizza, let alone 2 whole pizza pies! It was very skimpy. Not worth the extra fees I had to pay using the Uber Eats app. Other than that, the pizza was very delicious, as always!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mac1215
I bought a steak sandwich and it was medium. Wasn't good, it wasn't bad. There wasn't a whole lot of steak in it but the roll was very good. My only real complaint was that I ordered the steak special which was 1199 and I didn't get two of the ingredients and I was charged 1390 for the sandwich which I didn't really register what happened until after I left. It was a takeout. Not nearly as good as a couple of the reviews said, which was the only reason I went there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Valentina Valkyrie
They are very kind , make a really good Sicilian pizza. I order enough that they recognize me when I call.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy Melendez
Want a real good tasting pizza look no more! Hot crunchy cheese pizza like a real New York pizza. 🍕 And their cheese steaks OMG!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tania Bradkin
Pelleritos Pizza deserves more love! Family-owned and run with care, and it shows in every slice. Early in the week, you can get two pizzas for just $22—a great deal. My plain cheese slice was perfect: crisp crust, fresh ingredients, and rich sauce. The tiramisu was light and creamy. Friendly, fast service and a big menu. If you want to keep local spots thriving, share your good experiences. Pelleritos is a local favorite in the making.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Ladino
Seriously best pizza ever. Food is amazing ,Amazing staff amazing everything lol I’ll definitely coming back ! If I could give this place 10 stars or more i would ! I highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ollie Pinder
When I tell you this is one of the best pizzas I ever tried so far, I mean it!! Excellent customer service, food 10/10 The place is clean , very professional I love this place my first time here and I was NOT disappointed at all!! They fulfill all my expectations , listen good makes me happy and now a days some businesses they don't care anymore about the quality , but HERE they care about every single detail! Im definitely coming back ! You won my heart Pellerito's ❤️ lol
They must have changed ownership because this place has gone downhill BADLY. They never used to be this expensive, and the food got worse. And the fact that they charge you for using a credit or debit card something new and its ridiculous. They need to TELL PEOPLE OVER THE PHONE FOR PICKUP ANR DELIVERY YOU CHARGE CARDS!!!!! Stop this making extra money for nothing money. My friends and I will not be coming back here. The 2 first original owners were great. It's ashame I have to give this place a low rating now.
Jonny Abs
The workers are very nice and attentive. The food is bland but not bad by any means. We ordered a large pizza and cheese fries. The fries were cooked great, just needed a lot of salt and pepper added for taste. The pizza was nice and thin but was just pretty bland and needed a lot of seasoning added. Maybe that is by design and they provide a lot of seasoning on the tables. Pretty cool little place; the food just needs more taste.
Stephen Doerr
Guy who made my stromboli was very nice and food was good
Al LaTourette
We had take out pizza - meat lovers, this evening. Everything about it was delicious, from the perfectly cooked crust, to the four varieties of meat, the delicious cheese, and the tomato base with just the right herb touch. It was not overly moist either - just right. We hadn't had pizza from there in a while, instead we often go to a competitor, but I think we were all sold on the idea, this was tops.
Ali Luchino
Pelleritos has ALWAYS had great service even now. However ever since their ownership change the food has been lacking! Their pizza slices are definitely larger but the authentic taste of things just definitely isn’t there. They used to be the ONLY place I’d go for hot wings because of their sauce and the depth of flavor but now it seems more like some generic stuff and unappealing. I truly hope they succeed but our business with them will be very limited.
I have been ordering from Pellerito's for several years.
Last night, I ordered 2 pizzas via Uber Eats.
I called the restaurant to ask for several garlic powder and red pepper flakes packets.
I spoke with a young girl, did not get her name.
When my order arrived, the cups that the powder were in was a decent size. But when I opened it, there was only about half a tablespoon of garlic powder in there, if that.
For me, that's not enough for even 4 slices of pizza, let alone 2 whole pizza pies!
It was very skimpy.
Not worth the extra fees I had to pay using the Uber Eats app.
Other than that, the pizza was very delicious, as always!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I bought a steak sandwich and it was medium. Wasn't good, it wasn't bad. There wasn't a whole lot of steak in it but the roll was very good. My only real complaint was that I ordered the steak special which was 1199 and I didn't get two of the ingredients and I was charged 1390 for the sandwich which I didn't really register what happened until after I left. It was a takeout. Not nearly as good as a couple of the reviews said, which was the only reason I went there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
They are very kind , make a really good Sicilian pizza. I order enough that they recognize me when I call.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Want a real good tasting pizza look no more!
Hot crunchy cheese pizza like a real New York pizza. 🍕 And their cheese steaks OMG!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pelleritos Pizza deserves more love! Family-owned and run with care, and it shows in every slice. Early in the week, you can get two pizzas for just $22—a great deal. My plain cheese slice was perfect: crisp crust, fresh ingredients, and rich sauce. The tiramisu was light and creamy. Friendly, fast service and a big menu. If you want to keep local spots thriving, share your good experiences. Pelleritos is a local favorite in the making.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seriously best pizza ever. Food is amazing ,Amazing staff amazing everything lol I’ll definitely coming back ! If I could give this place 10 stars or more i would !
I highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
When I tell you this is one of the best pizzas I ever tried so far, I mean it!! Excellent customer service, food 10/10
The place is clean , very professional I love this place my first time here and I was NOT disappointed at all!!
They fulfill all my expectations , listen good makes me happy and now a days some businesses they don't care anymore about the quality , but HERE they care about every single detail!
Im definitely coming back ! You won my heart Pellerito's ❤️ lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Special, Pellerito's, Meat Lovers, French Fries, Italian, Sicilian, Cheese Pizza
The cheesesteak was great
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
The tortellini alfredo was freaking delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best meat lovers pizza around
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
They must have changed ownership because this place has gone downhill BADLY. They never used to be this expensive, and the food got worse. And the fact that they charge you for using a credit or debit card something new and its ridiculous. They need to TELL PEOPLE OVER THE PHONE FOR PICKUP ANR DELIVERY YOU CHARGE CARDS!!!!! Stop this making extra money for nothing money. My friends and I will not be coming back here. The 2 first original owners were great. It's ashame I have to give this place a low rating now.
The workers are very nice and attentive. The food is bland but not bad by any means. We ordered a large pizza and cheese fries. The fries were cooked great, just needed a lot of salt and pepper added for taste. The pizza was nice and thin but was just pretty bland and needed a lot of seasoning added. Maybe that is by design and they provide a lot of seasoning on the tables. Pretty cool little place; the food just needs more taste.
Guy who made my stromboli was very nice and food was good
We had take out pizza - meat lovers, this evening. Everything about it was delicious, from the perfectly cooked crust, to the four varieties of meat, the delicious cheese, and the tomato base with just the right herb touch. It was not overly moist either - just right. We hadn't had pizza from there in a while, instead we often go to a competitor, but I think we were all sold on the idea, this was tops.
Pelleritos has ALWAYS had great service even now. However ever since their ownership change the food has been lacking! Their pizza slices are definitely larger but the authentic taste of things just definitely isn’t there. They used to be the ONLY place I’d go for hot wings because of their sauce and the depth of flavor but now it seems more like some generic stuff and unappealing. I truly hope they succeed but our business with them will be very limited.
Loading...