Koffmeyer's Old Fashioned
7 Brookline Blvd, Havertown
(484) 454-3526
Recent Reviews
Sort by
7 Brookline Blvd, Havertown
(484) 454-3526
Best chocolate fudge brownie ice cream I've ever had. Must get fresh cookies while you're here too. Take them to go.
Amazing ice-cream in reasonable price
If you see a line stay- it’s worth it and they’re quick! Fresh made waffle cones and the ice cream is amazing and I’m not even big on ice cream. Super nice people working and friendly family atmosphere.
It was pool day perfect treat for after a swim. Ice cream was delicious !
The ice cream here is excellent classic, old-school style that brings back nostalgic flavors. I highly recommend the banana split if you’re looking to satisfy your sweet tooth. Their waffle cones are also a standout—crispy, flavorful, and the perfect complement to any scoop.
Yum! Big fan of the hand-scooped ice cream. The fresh baked cookies are great too.
The addition of the ice cream sandwich is nice, but unfortunately the small cookies married with a huge scoop of ice cream isn't practical and easy to eat.
TIP for the owners: I'd suggest making a separate batch of large cookies that can be used specifically for the ice cream sandwiches. This would make it much easier to enjoy!
Great local shop. Always friendly.
We love their cookies
Great ice cream and service!!!
New owners took over few months ago but not much has changed which is good (besides new paint, menu TVs and large freezer in the middle of the sitting area, which is now shrunk even more). Ice cream is still coming from the Poconos and in-store baked cookies taste the same. They finally have a proper POS system! We've been coming here for 12+ years and have one suggestion: make a sign directing people where to order ice cream. Newer visitors have no idea how the ordering line flows and just stand there blocking everyone. The line starts where the big stainless freezer is (in the back) and it snakes around to the outside of the store (when it gets really busy). This allows multiple people to be served at the same time.
Restaurantji Recommends
Stop in before my nephew baseball game. I got butter pecan with hot fudge.
Cookie Dough Ice Cream was fire, no lie.
My favorite local ice cream spot! My favorite is black raspberry ice cream in a homemade waffle cone. Everyone works so hard there!
Our family’s go to ice cream parlor. Best butter pecan ice cream I’ve ever had. Workers are awesome too
Havertown staple! Great ice cream and charming atmosphere. Helpful service and affordable prices. Feel like a throwback to another era. Super kid friendly. Highly recommend!
Loading...