Ghost pepper wings had the perfect level of heat, sauce quantity, and crispiness. The bread was great, the chicken picatta was not.
Annie Harris
I absolutely LOVED eating here. I was on a group trip and they brought out our food, 20 people’s food so fast. I ordered the tortellini blush, hoping it would be similar to another dish I absolutely love, and it was everything I had hoped and more. I usually can’t eat an entire meal at a restaurant in one sitting. I have to take it to go and eat the rest later on. I finished that tortellini blush in maybe 5-10 minutes it was so good. Maybe I was starving from being on the road and running around all day with a huge group of people, but either way, it was absolutely delicious and the servers were super knowledgeable about the town!
lizly price
Waitress was rude. I asked if they could get dessert and sing for my friend for her birthday she responded “I can get you dessert and you can sing”. Which I found weird because out of the many times I have been to restaurants for a birthday dinner this was the first I had someone say that. Didn’t even bring us the food herself, had someone else do it. Asked if we needed anything else AS we were still getting the food, before we even touched it then didn’t see her for 15 minutes until we had to call for her. Food was also below average.
Sherry Hess
Beautiful restaurant with delicious food
Russ Shipp
Average italian food
Susan Gnoza
The service was amazing. That place was beautiful. I think it is more of a pizza place than high end Italian food. I had chicken Parm and my mom had some Mediterranean chicken and we both would give the food a one star. My dad had a stromboli, he said it was amazing. The waitress said pizza is her favorite. Should have listened to the waitress.
Scot Honer
Stromboli dough was raw in several places. Salad lettuce wilted and brown. Traditional pizza was solid.
David Goles
Very nice and comfortable place to dine at. Great food and great service.
Jo Blatt
the food is amazing here...
Joanna Robinson
Love the chicken parm and the meatballs. Great service good prices. Another local business that’s always giving back to their community.
I have always had great service and great food at Fenicci's. Its a neat looking local place with a great location and great food. They are not a chain and unique to Hershey PA, so if you are visiting, I would recommend stopping by for a meal.
Scott Deibler
We had a party of 11 on 11-9-24 for dinner. Our food was really good except for one steak that was undercooked but they made it right very quickly. Our waiter was fantastic but I didn't get his name. Very healthy portions too. On negative that I would bring up may seem a little petty to some but we didn't like it. The packets of butter that they serve with their rolls were frozen solid. Obviously it made the butter impossible to spread. Overall though, a really good experience. The staff was very attentive and even the owner checked in on us to make sure.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Chris Etzel
Have come in here on Sundays on a somewhat rotation only because we received good service, but something has definitely happened between now and this summer, first ones in the bar area, last ones to order after 3 couples sat at booths and the food unfortunately wasn’t the same actually sent a dish back and went somewhere else. Well out of rotation now and it’s unfortunate usually above 20% tip not this time!
Rupert White
Server was fast and attentatitve. Food selection was good. We're from NJ so we know good pizza and this pizza was not bad. Didn't get the upside down pie. The traditional pie was ok. Crust was not as thin as i had hoped and the sauce was a little over seasoned in my opinion. Everyone else was happy with their meals. Cute little place decorated with playbills from the hershey theatre. A lot to look at.
Ghost pepper wings had the perfect level of heat, sauce quantity, and crispiness. The bread was great, the chicken picatta was not.
I absolutely LOVED eating here. I was on a group trip and they brought out our food, 20 people’s food so fast. I ordered the tortellini blush, hoping it would be similar to another dish I absolutely love, and it was everything I had hoped and more. I usually can’t eat an entire meal at a restaurant in one sitting. I have to take it to go and eat the rest later on. I finished that tortellini blush in maybe 5-10 minutes it was so good. Maybe I was starving from being on the road and running around all day with a huge group of people, but either way, it was absolutely delicious and the servers were super knowledgeable about the town!
Waitress was rude. I asked if they could get dessert and sing for my friend for her birthday she responded “I can get you dessert and you can sing”. Which I found weird because out of the many times I have been to restaurants for a birthday dinner this was the first I had someone say that. Didn’t even bring us the food herself, had someone else do it. Asked if we needed anything else AS we were still getting the food, before we even touched it then didn’t see her for 15 minutes until we had to call for her. Food was also below average.
Beautiful restaurant with delicious food
Average italian food
The service was amazing. That place was beautiful. I think it is more of a pizza place than high end Italian food. I had chicken Parm and my mom had some Mediterranean chicken and we both would give the food a one star. My dad had a stromboli, he said it was amazing. The waitress said pizza is her favorite. Should have listened to the waitress.
Stromboli dough was raw in several places. Salad lettuce wilted and brown. Traditional pizza was solid.
Very nice and comfortable place to dine at. Great food and great service.
the food is amazing here...
Love the chicken parm and the meatballs. Great service good prices. Another local business that’s always giving back to their community.
Restaurantji Recommends
I have always had great service and great food at Fenicci's. Its a neat looking local place with a great location and great food. They are not a chain and unique to Hershey PA, so if you are visiting, I would recommend stopping by for a meal.
We had a party of 11 on 11-9-24 for dinner. Our food was really good except for one steak that was undercooked but they made it right very quickly. Our waiter was fantastic but I didn't get his name. Very healthy portions too. On negative that I would bring up may seem a little petty to some but we didn't like it. The packets of butter that they serve with their rolls were frozen solid. Obviously it made the butter impossible to spread. Overall though, a really good experience. The staff was very attentive and even the owner checked in on us to make sure.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Have come in here on Sundays on a somewhat rotation only because we received good service, but something has definitely happened between now and this summer, first ones in the bar area, last ones to order after 3 couples sat at booths and the food unfortunately wasn’t the same actually sent a dish back and went somewhere else. Well out of rotation now and it’s unfortunate usually above 20% tip not this time!
Server was fast and attentatitve. Food selection was good. We're from NJ so we know good pizza and this pizza was not bad. Didn't get the upside down pie. The traditional pie was ok. Crust was not as thin as i had hoped and the sauce was a little over seasoned in my opinion. Everyone else was happy with their meals. Cute little place decorated with playbills from the hershey theatre. A lot to look at.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Food was great! Jade was the best server ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm
Loading...