McBride's Pizza Shop

2274 W Sunbury Rd, Hilliards
(724) 735-4004

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Pat Manski

The food was good. Messed up the order and the price. My total bill should have been $29.47. I gave them $20.00 in cash. Asked him to take the remaining out of my checking which should have been $9.47. Well, they may of raised their prices, but when I went to write it in my checkbook, they charged my debit $42.53. I called and there was a minor adjustment on prices. Jason the owner called me back the next day. It was just an honest mistake. He corrected the error and I am extremely happy he did so. I really love their pizza and sauce. Ill be back...thank you Jason.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Colby Sykes

Ordered a gyro.. best one I've had in a very long time. For the price of the gyro I couldn't believe the how much you get. It was stuffed and the meat wasn't the cheap this sliced crap.. it was thick cut and cooked perfectly. I will definitely make it a point to come back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul W Macurak

$6.00 for a gallon of milk..... never again

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tina Bro

My pizza was so hot when it was delivered, I burnt my tongue. Excellent pizza, sweet chili wings were delicious. The delivery
driver was super, despite the rainy night.
Will be frequenting this menu for sure

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Lawson

Always a great pizza. Bacon pineapple with extra cheese. Trust me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Campbell Life

I've been ordering from here for a while, make sure you ask for extra shaker because it's awesome on the crust. Jason is always super nice and does a great job. They are my go to for parties and for dinner night

Katie Grossman

Best food in the area. Friendly staff, top notch delivery drivers and some of the kindest and nicest owners. Don't go to the chain shops for your pizza needs McBride's is the place to go.

Brian Diamond

Make sure to ask them to cut your pizza like a regular pizza!

Ben Boal

Really good pizza, fries are also fantastic. They've definitely turned into one of my favorite places to get pizza because of the quality of their food. Last time I got one, they were INSANELY busy and still somehow managed to get my order done in a timely manner with a good outcome. Don't plan on eating there, definitely get take out, seating is not really set up for eating in. There's 2 small tables but they seem more like they're there for waiting for your take out. (Not an issue whatsoever, just trying to inform the next person of what to expect.)

Nathan Colosimo

Don’t listen to these lunatic liberals, this place is great and I’m going to support more than ever now. Make Pizza Great Again! #MPGA

Brittany Clark

The owners are always polite and professional. We love the pepperoni balls they are a must order every time we go here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza

Heather Sullivan

Excellent wings. We ordered 50 to take to a bonfire. We do not live close. So we Googled and reviews were good so we went here. So happy we did.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Heather McGowen

We stopped ordering from here awhile ago ( a few years) because anything fried we got tasted like burnt grease and pizza was always under cooked and doughy.
2 or 3 months ago we thought we would try again. We ordered the Sweet Blue wings, fried banana pepper rings and a large pizza. It was fantastic. Pizza was cooked, wings were well cooked and sauced, banana peppers rings didn't taste burnt.
Last month placed another order. Wings and rings were done to perfection. The monster pizza the center was under cooked and doughy.
Tonight wings were barely sauced, banana pepper rings were burnt. The large pizza is cooked.
We had high hopes but apparently it is a crap shoot, no consistency. So disappointing.

Food: 1

Service: 4

Erin Faith

Best pizza place around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Mushrooms, Pepsi Products, Deep Fried Banana Peppers, Pizza

Wyatt EVERETTS

The best food in the area hands down! The owners are great people aswell!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...