Pizza was good. They put the cheese and pepperoni on after taking it out of the oven, which was different but it still tasted good. We ordered “cheese bread” as well and it WAS NOT the cheese bread I was expecting. I was so excited for it…but it was flavorless “Bosco Sticks” that you can buy at Walmart 12 for $4.94. We paid $8.15 for 4 breadsticks. $8.15 FOR 4!!! If you’re gonna have cheese bread, at least make it yourself. How hard is it to throw some cheese and seasonings on your dough and bake it? It was almost $50 for a sandwich, a medium pizza with pepperoni on half and mushrooms on the other half, and 4 breadsticks, which was a little outrageous as well. Will come back for the pizza and maybe the sandwich again, but I’m upset about the cheese bread. :(
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
hatter
Nice crispy crust with extra cold cheese sprinkled on top with pepperoni the cold or “raw” toppings the reviews mention bake in the box and if you don’t like that they’ll bake the toppings if you ask and you get to see how there cooking it. Good hoagies and strombolis as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Krista Edgar
Terrible - not fresh pizza- tasted like they reheated burnt bread.That's the problem today, nobody has any pride in the product they put out.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Fox Dawnstar
I always love their pizza, they cook their crust crunchy, just not doughy perfect. We love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vince Shirer
Finest slice anywhere. I live 2 1/2 hrs away.
SandinScoobi Doo
I am completely addicted to this place!!! The food, the customer service, the prices, the staff.....10 out of 10! As soon as you pull into Jimmy Z's parking lot this amazing smell of the best square pizza around! My boyfriend introduced me to this place and my first time walking in with him the kindest man (Andrew and his staff) greeted me as if I had been going there for years and we were friends! (Mind you it was my very first time ever stepping foot in this place) I can't believe I have never had their pizza before! It is delicious and I recommend this place to everyone I know now! Easiest 5 stars I've ever reviewed and well deserved! I am there almost every week now!!
Ken Miller
Lol. All that hype to pay 1.65 per slice for toasted bread with unmelted cheese and cold uncooked pepperoni. I don't get it. Less than average and it actually made my wife vomit. The took bread with sauce out of the oven sprinkled cheese on top and added some pepperoni and that's how I got it. I mean has that how they actually make it or did i just get screwed?
Carolyn Ramsey
We ordered here for the first time for a fundraiser and although the ordering process and customer service were fine, the pizza was not. We ordered a Sicilian with Pepperoni. The crust was thin and crispy instead of the usual thick crust. There was so much sauce that it was flopping off of the pieces as you picked it up. There was very little mozzarella cheese and what was on there was not melted. It looked like it wasn't cooked enough. It was very disappointing. Our kids hated it and they NEVER hate pizza. It's their favorite food group! 😉
This is awesome Pizza this is the very first time I've ever tried it! Great job! Smelled so good I had to eat three pieces before I even got home!
Brian Clark
The servers were disorganized. The pizza was made. Then, cold pepperoni and cold cheese were added while the pizza was in the box. The box was closed and handed to me just like that.
Insert Redletter Media Meme Here
I’ve had nearly all Ohio Valley Pizza from WV, OH and southwestern PA. Just went to this place today and I’d go as far to say that it’s better than DiCarlos, which is pretty amazing.
Excellent pizza! Just the way we like it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was good. They put the cheese and pepperoni on after taking it out of the oven, which was different but it still tasted good. We ordered “cheese bread” as well and it WAS NOT the cheese bread I was expecting. I was so excited for it…but it was flavorless “Bosco Sticks” that you can buy at Walmart 12 for $4.94. We paid $8.15 for 4 breadsticks. $8.15 FOR 4!!! If you’re gonna have cheese bread, at least make it yourself. How hard is it to throw some cheese and seasonings on your dough and bake it? It was almost $50 for a sandwich, a medium pizza with pepperoni on half and mushrooms on the other half, and 4 breadsticks, which was a little outrageous as well. Will come back for the pizza and maybe the sandwich again, but I’m upset about the cheese bread. :(
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Nice crispy crust with extra cold cheese sprinkled on top with pepperoni the cold or “raw” toppings the reviews mention bake in the box and if you don’t like that they’ll bake the toppings if you ask and you get to see how there cooking it. Good hoagies and strombolis as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrible - not fresh pizza- tasted like they reheated burnt bread.That's the problem today, nobody has any pride in the product they put out.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I always love their pizza, they cook their crust crunchy, just not doughy perfect. We love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finest slice anywhere.
I live 2 1/2 hrs away.
I am completely addicted to this place!!! The food, the customer service, the prices, the staff.....10 out of 10! As soon as you pull into Jimmy Z's parking lot this amazing smell of the best square pizza around! My boyfriend introduced me to this place and my first time walking in with him the kindest man (Andrew and his staff) greeted me as if I had been going there for years and we were friends! (Mind you it was my very first time ever stepping foot in this place) I can't believe I have never had their pizza before! It is delicious and I recommend this place to everyone I know now! Easiest 5 stars I've ever reviewed and well deserved! I am there almost every week now!!
Lol. All that hype to pay 1.65 per slice for toasted bread with unmelted cheese and cold uncooked pepperoni. I don't get it. Less than average and it actually made my wife vomit. The took bread with sauce out of the oven sprinkled cheese on top and added some pepperoni and that's how I got it. I mean has that how they actually make it or did i just get screwed?
We ordered here for the first time for a fundraiser and although the ordering process and customer service were fine, the pizza was not. We ordered a Sicilian with Pepperoni. The crust was thin and crispy instead of the usual thick crust. There was so much sauce that it was flopping off of the pieces as you picked it up. There was very little mozzarella cheese and what was on there was not melted. It looked like it wasn't cooked enough. It was very disappointing. Our kids hated it and they NEVER hate pizza. It's their favorite food group! 😉
Great food
Restaurantji Recommends
Very friendly good food n service
This is awesome Pizza this is the very first time I've ever tried it! Great job! Smelled so good I had to eat three pieces before I even got home!
The servers were disorganized. The pizza was made. Then, cold pepperoni and cold cheese were added while the pizza was in the box. The box was closed and handed to me just like that.
I’ve had nearly all Ohio Valley Pizza from WV, OH and southwestern PA. Just went to this place today and I’d go as far to say that it’s better than DiCarlos, which is pretty amazing.
Nice old fashion pizza that me and my wife enjoy!
Loading...