Garden of Eating Pizzeria

Always good

Best pizza in the area. So good

The traditional pizza is extremely thin. Doesn't taste bad but I personally like thicker crust. They also don't have homemade ranch, it's literally room temp packet ranch which was very disappointing. The French fries in their salads aren't cooked fully either. Not sure if this was just a bad night for them but being my first time, I wouldn't eat here again or recommend it.

Always fresh, on time and great pizza. My all time favorite, and I'm Italiano and always cook Garden of Eating is my go to. BRAVO

Down home traditional Mom and Pop Pizza!!!...
This establishment has been there for close to 30 yrs!!!
The white pizza, garlic and tomatoes is so delicious!!! oozing with buttery garlic white sauce on a thin crispy crust where it counts!! Tomatoes sweet and soft melting into cheesy goodness!!
Delicious!!!
Also wanted to try their hot sausage hoagie!!!...
They buy their ingredients local...
right down road, persay....
and that payoff of freshness comes out in this hot sausage flavor with a punch of real authentic spice!!!...love everything about this!!!
Bread was just right!!!...
Sauce was bangin!!
I used to live in this area, came to pay a visit, and I must say...this establishment hasn't parted ways with their original ingredients!!!!...like most eateries do over the years!!!
When I pass thru again, I will definitely stop here!!!!
Thank You!!!!
For staying 'faithful' to your name!!!!

I

I’ve been to pretty much every pizza shop in Robinson and the surrounding area. This place always has some of the best pizza in town. Their pepperoni is excellent and totally makes the pizza stand out from others in the area. Easily one of the best pizzas in the area. I haven’t tried anything else yet, but I always find myself going back for another slice of pepperoni.

This is one of our favorite neighborhood spots for pizza. We usually get pepperoni lovers with sausage and a chicken bacon ranch pizza.

EDIT: the food remains excellent & they have corrected the inconsistency. It’s Great!

The food, when it’s correct, is excellent! Problem is the shop cannot seem get an order right consistently. I order the same thing every time, specific toppings on a pizza. It’s been right 1 time in the last 5 orders. Maybe I’m an idiot to keep trying... but the food is genuinely good. It’s slow, (generally an hour+) which would be worth it if it was correct. I’m done trying. Moving on to decent pizza that’s consistently correct & great delivery time, instead of the crap shoot it is to order from here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza. Friendly folks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Food is always fresh & hot upon arrival!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Pizza

Our favorite pizza and hoagie spot in the area. Can't be beat!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Steak, Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Ordered my pizza online, it said 45 mins for delivery which is completely fine. Called at 1 hour after ordering. Person said my order was "on the way" then promptly hung up on me. received my order 20 mins later. Btw i am LITERALLY 6 mins from GOE! I used to love GOE, but after being hung up on, won't be ordering again. Gianni's, here I come!

Food: 2

Service: 1

Called at 5:18 was told over 1 hour had to wait over 2 hours. Good pizza been customer for over 10 years will never order again. Driver was very rude said there was traffic on Steubenville pike but I can see that road there was no traffic. Good pizza but not worth waiting over 2 hours for a pizza. At this point can't eat so waste of money

Best pizza in Pittsburgh! Everyone who works there is extremely friendly. Highly recommend