Haven't worked my way through the menu, yet, but so far what I've had has been on point. A comfortable pizza shop environment, never an issue with service. I look forward to many more next times, try it out!
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, White Supreme, Pizza, Italian Hoagie
Age
Tuesday, 12/26: Started calling at 915pm.. they never answered.. Drove by, saw they were open.. husband walked in at 940pm, young kids standing around.. kid #1 looked like a deer in headlights.. kid #2 said they "ran out of dough."If you're open until 10, why do you stop answering the phone so early?? Obviously, this happens on a frequent basis, usually on Tuesday nights. The kids stop answering the phone earlier & earlier each week (yes, we try to order weekly). It went from 930, to 920, now 915?? If you don't call before then, no one answers!!If the hoagies & pizza weren't some of the best around, we'd discontinue our patronage..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Italian
Loretta Danjou
Omg!!!! My husband n I got the spinach calzone and the pepperoni calzone. To die for!!! Simply amazing! Best ones we ever had. Generous amounts of cheeses, meats n spinach in the calzones filled. Bread for calzones fresh and delicious. We had there white pizza before (excellent) and there steak salad before and excellent as well. The calzones were so good we actually called them up and complimented them as well. I highly recommend this place. Service is speedy, food is fresh and the staff is nice. We will be going back! Garden of Eating excellent job! Loretta and jasonParking: Plenty of space - easy in and easy out access.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
Linda Gaworski
My favorite pizza anywhere! It's more of a take out sort of place but they do have a couple of tables. I have been a customer for over 30 years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
brandirkc
Not a Pittsburgh pizza fan but this is what I find to be the best around. We order it thin and it’s just like a NY/NJ pizza. Excellent!Great service too. Last night I called shortly before closing and they squeezed in an late Italian hoagie for me.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Stephanie Santoro
Had to wait almost two hours on a Tuesday night for cold food. Never again!
Food: 1
Zoey
I loved the pizza flavor! I havent been here in a couple of years. Just lost track and I live in another town. Not sure why the mozzarella cheese is so tough n hard to chew though? whether other people experience this as well I'm not sure. . Ive had this happen several of the times with different places throughout the years.. (I'm always on a quest for the best pizza since I come from NYC). juliano's Pizza was very impressive. a few nights back did not have tough rubbery mozzarella . In fact , I will be going back again for pizza in the near future.. want to give garden of eating some credit though for great flavor with the pizza. the cheese is not working out though?'m not sure what the situation is with their cheese could it be low quality mozzarella? Idk . my mother had to spit out a big amount of pizza due to choking hazard. Mozzarella cheese shouldn't have to be that diffucult to chew. My boyfriend and I also experienced the same problem ?
vegetas veng
food is, always was, great. But the owner on the other hand is another topic. First off, the own is in the pockets of the police and local judge. Having that said, he gets away with certain charges that would be pursued on a normal civilian. Sad owner of of this business, became physical with me and struck me in the face, outside his work establishment (outside his, possibly, privately owned area [in public area]). To top it off, the sissy of an owner called a man, PERSONALLY INVITE ME TO HIS BUSINESS. But because he is in the pockets of the police, and the local judge, he hit me in the face in front of his business, (public property) and i called 911 afterwards, the sad excuse of a public servant (Salinski, [North Fayette police] not the other officer) is that i was "trespassing and harassing" and the man that struck me would only get a charge of harassment. to sum it up, man INVITED me to his business and now im trespassing??? man strikes me in the face (no assault charges???? [what is assault if not that?]), and he would ONLY be charged with harassment, no assault charges. what a joke. "man" (woman) slaps like a cheerleader. dude couldnt hold his own against anyone in his weight class, couldnt even handle me (someone who weights 40+ pounds less than him)
Haven't worked my way through the menu, yet, but so far what I've had has been on point. A comfortable pizza shop environment, never an issue with service. I look forward to many more next times, try it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Meatball Calzone, Pepperoni Pizza
Yinz can't go wrong going to this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Fantastic food. Bread made from scratch on site.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, White Supreme, Pizza, Italian Hoagie
Tuesday, 12/26: Started calling at 915pm.. they never answered.. Drove by, saw they were open.. husband walked in at 940pm, young kids standing around.. kid #1 looked like a deer in headlights.. kid #2 said they "ran out of dough."If you're open until 10, why do you stop answering the phone so early?? Obviously, this happens on a frequent basis, usually on Tuesday nights. The kids stop answering the phone earlier & earlier each week (yes, we try to order weekly). It went from 930, to 920, now 915?? If you don't call before then, no one answers!!If the hoagies & pizza weren't some of the best around, we'd discontinue our patronage..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Italian
Omg!!!! My husband n I got the spinach calzone and the pepperoni calzone. To die for!!! Simply amazing! Best ones we ever had. Generous amounts of cheeses, meats n spinach in the calzones filled. Bread for calzones fresh and delicious. We had there white pizza before (excellent) and there steak salad before and excellent as well. The calzones were so good we actually called them up and complimented them as well. I highly recommend this place. Service is speedy, food is fresh and the staff is nice. We will be going back! Garden of Eating excellent job! Loretta and jasonParking: Plenty of space - easy in and easy out access.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
My favorite pizza anywhere! It's more of a take out sort of place but they do have a couple of tables. I have been a customer for over 30 years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Not a Pittsburgh pizza fan but this is what I find to be the best around. We order it thin and it’s just like a NY/NJ pizza. Excellent!Great service too. Last night I called shortly before closing and they squeezed in an late Italian hoagie for me.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Had to wait almost two hours on a Tuesday night for cold food. Never again!
Food: 1
I loved the pizza flavor! I havent been here in a couple of years. Just lost track and I live in another town. Not sure why the mozzarella cheese is so tough n hard to chew though? whether other people experience this as well I'm not sure. . Ive had this happen several of the times with different places throughout the years.. (I'm always on a quest for the best pizza since I come from NYC). juliano's Pizza was very impressive. a few nights back did not have tough rubbery mozzarella . In fact , I will be going back again for pizza in the near future.. want to give garden of eating some credit though for great flavor with the pizza. the cheese is not working out though?'m not sure what the situation is with their cheese could it be low quality mozzarella? Idk . my mother had to spit out a big amount of pizza due to choking hazard. Mozzarella cheese shouldn't have to be that diffucult to chew. My boyfriend and I also experienced the same problem ?
food is, always was, great. But the owner on the other hand is another topic. First off, the own is in the pockets of the police and local judge. Having that said, he gets away with certain charges that would be pursued on a normal civilian. Sad owner of of this business, became physical with me and struck me in the face, outside his work establishment (outside his, possibly, privately owned area [in public area]). To top it off, the sissy of an owner called a man, PERSONALLY INVITE ME TO HIS BUSINESS. But because he is in the pockets of the police, and the local judge, he hit me in the face in front of his business, (public property) and i called 911 afterwards, the sad excuse of a public servant (Salinski, [North Fayette police] not the other officer) is that i was "trespassing and harassing" and the man that struck me would only get a charge of harassment. to sum it up, man INVITED me to his business and now im trespassing??? man strikes me in the face (no assault charges???? [what is assault if not that?]), and he would ONLY be charged with harassment, no assault charges. what a joke. "man" (woman) slaps like a cheerleader. dude couldnt hold his own against anyone in his weight class, couldnt even handle me (someone who weights 40+ pounds less than him)
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza. I love their subs . Their antipasto is fantastic. I always get a bigger pizza just so I have leftovers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
Gluten free pizza was good and reasonably priced compared to everywhere elseDietary restrictions: Had gluten free options available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Delicious pizza and hoagies. I have been coming here for years. I highly recommend.Kid-friendliness: Some video games.Parking: Ample parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Old school pizza shop. We always eat there for the classic pizza joint vibe. Best pizza in the west. Meatballs are amazing too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best wedgie ever! Perfectly baked crust, stuffed full of toppings, so tasty. You gotta try them.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything