Benjamin's

458 Philadelphia St, Indiana
(724) 465-4446

Recent Reviews

Sort by
tristen kristoff

benjamin’s took me down to chocolate town. 5/5 stars

Orla Jennings

The restaurant atmosphere was wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paige Nicole

I used to take myself out to lunch all the time, but after two years of being with my partner, I’m so used to doing everything with them. Today was the first time I took myself to lunch and almost 2 1/2 years. It was really nerve-racking, but my waiter and new trainee were extremely welcoming! They made me feel that much more comfortable being there by myself. I’m so bad at remembering names, but I greatly appreciate them. The food was amazing. The service was wonderful, my family and I eat there all the time. I will definitely be back by myself again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Catherine Lohr

We had an amazing meal. The food was great, definitely recommend the fried brie. If you can sit outside, it's beautiful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eve Earley

Great food and atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Bennett

Arrived at 1130, now 1 o'clock. Still no food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

James Ferrington Sr

Very good food, went for our anniversary dinner. Not bad on price either.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emily \u0026 Brian Carnahan

We dined here at Benjamin’s last evening (Friday, August 1st) and were served by Joey. It was a pretty busy Friday night, but that did not affect our service one bit. I had the Maple Whiskey Salmon and it was divine. There were beautiful flowers around and the atmosphere was so welcoming and relaxing. We had conversation with Joey like we’ve been friends for years! It was a great experience. We will definitely be returning.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gaylene Fay

The atmosphere is nice and that is about the only thing it has going for it. It’s over priced bland food with small portions. The servers do not have tables close together to purposefully not get refills. Getting anyone’s attention is near impossible. We use to love this restaurant when my daughter started going to college in Indiana now that she has moved to the area and gone back several times is a no go. So many other places that are better food for the price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gary Whitaker

Good atmosphere, service was fine, but the menu is limited and the food is not good. The blue cheese dressing was watered down severely and the chicken tacos were dry. Every time we go it gets worse

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Christopher Nolte

Amazing fresh food, love the bruschetta and mimosas.

S

Food is so good, but the service leaves so much to be desired. Particularly if you sit at the back bar or order take out… Good luck getting the bartender to pay any attention to you if you aren’t one of her buddies. Every take out order I’ve ever placed takes 10-20 minutes longer than they say it will. Such a shame because the food is great.

Michael Bartosiewicz

Worst meal ever! Have been a fun of Benjamin's for a long time, not tonight! Service was average, waited 1 hour for a plate of mussels and linguine that had the worst mussels I've ever had. Would think someone would take a peek at the mussels if they intend to serve to the public.
Would question a return trip.
And was my birthday dinner. 😔

Jacqueline Ricketts

Great venue, service very friendly and accommodating, food great except bread offering, inside dining atmosphere is charming with early 1900’s decor and furnishings. Outside dining atmosphere with covered patio feature’s or open fresh air surroundings with tree coverage. A must go to visit and dine if you are in the area.

Marilyn K. Mignogna Billow

We had a delicious dinner (chicken parm) at Benjamin’s last evening. The atmosphere was so cozy and the hostess was so friendly. Our server was very busy but, attended to all her tables in a timely fashion. The food was delish!! Cannot wait to return in the warmer months to enjoy the outdoor seating.

Loading...