My wife's favorite overall pizza, and my favorite local football pizza (don't know what football pizza is? Google one bite pizza reviews with El Prez).The thing about pizza is, that they are like snowflakes and all different. Folks are always trying to figure out who is the "best" but the reality is that pizza that you love is the "best for you". That's why there are so many out there. But you can't go wrong with Brooklyn's and I'm SOOO glad that they are back. We usually order the XL 3-topping with pepperoni and half mushroom half sausage because that magically appeases everyone in the house. The reason that I mention it is that I find sausage on pizza to be very hit or miss and Brooklyn's hits.Recently got a steak sub as well and I'll be ordering it again. Real steak, great roll...worth a try.Finally, the owners and the workers are super nice and friendly and always make you feel welcome when you stop to pick up. I mention this because, let's be honest, we've had places in PT that haven't always given us that and it's worth noting.Sorry that I forgot to take a pic, I'll update the next time that we order...which will be soon. Thanks Brooklyn's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bonnie Kent
This is the only the 3rd time I have ordered from Brooklyn's & I'm wondering why I don't order more often. Pizza is delicious, sauce is sweet (for those that don't prefer) & just the right amount. I did ask for no garlic butter on the crust (personal preference). Will definitely order again. Price was on point, I understand with supply costs rising, businesses are forced to do the same in order to stay in business.
Chuck Mcdonough
Always great food and counter service, I have only just do take out. I would also post pictures, but my family can't wait to get to it !..next time. Pictures of food BEFORE I bring it in the house!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza with Everything, Lobster Rolls
Jesse DiPietro
Good pizza, don't read Jeff's review unless you want a good laugh. Dude needs a hobby or something. Smells like beer?? Id have thrown a pizza at his front door if I was Brooklyns pizza!!!
LA C.
This pizza is pretty dang good The quality is far better than a lot of the options around Greensburg area. Pizzas are big with plenty of variety and quality toppings. I always ask them to make it thin crust and they do a great job.
Jenn Binkley
There is not one bad item on the menu! No matter what you get: pizza, fish sandwich, salad... It's all delicious! Jonathan runs a great place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danielle Samsa Pellegrino
we had the best food tonight from Brooklyn's. we got the cheese rav and chicken parm dinners, enough for three meals each. it was delicious! Jonathan is the best and even threw in a little treat for the kiddos!!
Braedy Mastine
I love the pizza but it takes FOREVER. I have to show up 20min later or I will be waiting forever to pick the pizza up. I just waited 30min to pick up a pizza(30min later then the time they told me to get there).
Flo Cole
Ate at Brooklyns Lobster Shack.Had the Connecticut Lobster Roll, was delicious! Very large portions, service was good.Parking: Parking is a little limited.
Stevie Davis
Best steak salad I had ever!!! Very friendly people
My wife's favorite overall pizza, and my favorite local football pizza (don't know what football pizza is? Google one bite pizza reviews with El Prez).The thing about pizza is, that they are like snowflakes and all different. Folks are always trying to figure out who is the "best" but the reality is that pizza that you love is the "best for you". That's why there are so many out there. But you can't go wrong with Brooklyn's and I'm SOOO glad that they are back. We usually order the XL 3-topping with pepperoni and half mushroom half sausage because that magically appeases everyone in the house. The reason that I mention it is that I find sausage on pizza to be very hit or miss and Brooklyn's hits.Recently got a steak sub as well and I'll be ordering it again. Real steak, great roll...worth a try.Finally, the owners and the workers are super nice and friendly and always make you feel welcome when you stop to pick up. I mention this because, let's be honest, we've had places in PT that haven't always given us that and it's worth noting.Sorry that I forgot to take a pic, I'll update the next time that we order...which will be soon. Thanks Brooklyn's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the only the 3rd time I have ordered from Brooklyn's & I'm wondering why I don't order more often. Pizza is delicious, sauce is sweet (for those that don't prefer) & just the right amount. I did ask for no garlic butter on the crust (personal preference). Will definitely order again. Price was on point, I understand with supply costs rising, businesses are forced to do the same in order to stay in business.
Always great food and counter service, I have only just do take out. I would also post pictures, but my family can't wait to get to it !..next time. Pictures of food BEFORE I bring it in the house!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza with Everything, Lobster Rolls
Good pizza, don't read Jeff's review unless you want a good laugh. Dude needs a hobby or something. Smells like beer?? Id have thrown a pizza at his front door if I was Brooklyns pizza!!!
This pizza is pretty dang good The quality is far better than a lot of the options around Greensburg area. Pizzas are big with plenty of variety and quality toppings. I always ask them to make it thin crust and they do a great job.
There is not one bad item on the menu! No matter what you get: pizza, fish sandwich, salad... It's all delicious! Jonathan runs a great place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
we had the best food tonight from Brooklyn's. we got the cheese rav and chicken parm dinners, enough for three meals each. it was delicious! Jonathan is the best and even threw in a little treat for the kiddos!!
I love the pizza but it takes FOREVER. I have to show up 20min later or I will be waiting forever to pick the pizza up. I just waited 30min to pick up a pizza(30min later then the time they told me to get there).
Ate at Brooklyns Lobster Shack.Had the Connecticut Lobster Roll, was delicious! Very large portions, service was good.Parking: Parking is a little limited.
Best steak salad I had ever!!! Very friendly people
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent pizza and pasta- and outstanding service
Best pizza around! I won’t order anywhere else
First time ordering, good food and quick delivery even with the weather. I would definitely recommend them.
Magnificent food! Great people!
We love the lobster shack! Amazing, fresh seafood , wonderful service! Can’t wait to go back and enjoy a lobster roll!