Keatings Ice Cream

1642 Archbald Mountain Rd, Jefferson
(570) 937-4191

Recent Reviews

Eric Butler

Really good ice cream

Michael Eck

Great ice cream with some unusual flavors. I enjoyed the apple pie ice cream and the PB Oreo. My wife enjoyed her strawberry sundae. We will be going back again for more!

Susan Kaschak

Very friendly and many unusual flavors of ice cream. Made by the owners so no harmful additives ! Highly recommend.

William Sledzinski

Amazing homemade ice cream

Karley “NEPA Reviews and Ratings”

Amazing ice cream! This is the last season the will be open so visit while you can!!!

Tee

Nice staff but ice cream was icy. Not creamy.

Dacia Belknap

Best homemade ice cream I've ever had ??

Tina T

Nice staff but ice cream was icy. Not creamy.

Robert Bonavolta

Fresh ice cream from their own dairy cows and blueberry bushes. Only 5 stars but the Cajun cocoa with jalapeños had no spice at all, like zero jalapeño, and could not sample the lemon blueberry due to covid? No hand to hand transfer?

Amber Ulrich

Delicious ice cream everytime! We go at least once a year for the ice cream. Highly Recommend

Bob Eshleman

Along a country road... Delicious ice cream, nice and friendly service

Sonya S Z.

Family owned and farm fresh ice cream! So nice to know that places like this still exist.

Gibbzy 77

Great ice cream made right there in a ton of flavors.

Carly C.

Fabulous homemade ice cream with rural charm. Strawberry short cake and oatmeal cookie are my favorites!

Donna Gibbs

Great ice cream made right there in a ton of flavors.

Load More