I eat here pretty often, mostly takeout but sometimes I dine in. I love their sauce; subtly sweet without being cloying. I had an eggplant parmesan hoagie today. Fresh baked bread, ample cheese, and that delicious sauce. The eggplant is always good and not gritty or bitter.
Their pizza is great, but I've never had anything I didn't enjoy. I particularly like their margarita pie, which is simple and tasty. Order for pickup (you must call, no online ordering here) or stop in on your lunch break for pizza by the slice. You can't go wrong at this Westmont staple.
Jessica Varga
We usually get take out 2-3 times a month from here. Always delicious, best pizza!
Bev Liggett
Food quality has gone WAY DOWN hill. Ordered a steak and cheese hoagie with mushrooms and onions and thank goodness I ordered the extra toppings because the meat almost covered the inside of the bread. Used to be my go-to place when I wanted my favorite steak and cheese but NO MORE!!! Cooks handling food prep with no gloves!!!!! Won't be back!
Elise
I recently visited pizza man and witnessed a customer leave with a pizza and returned within 15 minutes claiming his order was wrong..the pizza man staff took the returned pizza and placed it on the counter for resale..before it was placed back on the counter a staff member picked a couple pieces of pepperoni off of the said pizza with her bare hands...I think that is very wrong placing the pizza on counter for resale after it left the restaurant and was returned later.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
John Dietz
I placed an order for a steak hoagie, receive a hot sausage sandwich and you want me to pay to have the correct food delivered, which is ridiculous!!’l
Gene Bird
Great steak Stromboli at a reasonable price
Ralph Miller
Have ordered pizza here for a few years now. Quality is normally ok to good but at times it is inconsistent with uneven crust thickness and varying topping amounts from week to week. Having said that, tonight was a total disaster and likely a game ender for me. I called and ordered 2 X-Large pepperoni pizzas for pickup, gave my name and phone number, was given the price with tax, and was told 35-40 minutes they would be ready. That was at 4:48PM. My wife went to pick up the pizzas at 5:30PM and was told there was no order there under our name. She was told they had no record of the order. She came home and told me and I was livid. We were all hungry and tired and wanted supper. I called back to complain and was told the same thing, until the person then realized she misheard my name and wrote it wrong and our pizzas were there and I could come get them. I said no and wanted 2 fresh pizzas as it was already over a half an hour they must have been sitting there. After much arguing I was told they would make me 2 fresh pizzas and it would be 30-45 minutes and hung up on me. I called back immediately and said I would be over in 15 minutes for my FRESH pizzas. This was at 5:52PM per my call logs. I went over at 6:20 to pick them up. I was given two "fresh" pizzas that were on top of the HOT ovens. If these were two fresh pizzas, they must have gone from the ovens to the fridge and back as the grease and cheese was already congealing. Needless to say, I was in no position to refuse the pizzas right then as they were our supper for tonight. I reluctantly paid for them (wasn't comped or even offered a discount for their screwup) and went home to eat my cold "fresh" pizzas. Cripe, I had to nuke my slices to make them palatable. It is very unlikely we will be buying any pizza or other food from Pizza Man's Pizza for a very long time, if ever again. There are just too many other pizzerias in the neighboring area that offer quality product and superior customer service to spend my hard-earned money here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ralph Michael Miller
Have ordered pizza here for a few years now. Quality is normally ok to good but at times it is inconsistent with uneven crust thickness and varying topping amounts from week to week. Having said that, tonight was a total disaster and likely a game ender for me. I called and ordered 2 X-Large pepperoni pizzas for pickup, gave my name and phone number, was given the price with tax, and was told 35-40 minutes they would be ready. That was at 4:48PM. My wife went to pick up the pizzas at 5:30PM and was told there was no order there under our name. She was told they had no record of the order. She came home and told me and I was livid. We were all hungry and tired and wanted supper. I called back to complain and was told the same thing, until the person then realized she misheard my name and wrote it wrong and our pizzas were there and I could come get them. I said no and wanted 2 fresh pizzas as it was already over a half an hour they must have been sitting there. After much arguing I was told they would make me 2 fresh pizzas and it would be 30-45 minutes and hung up on me. I called back immediately and said I would be over in 15 minutes for my FRESH pizzas. This was at 5:52PM per my call logs. I went over at 6:20 to pick them up. I was given two "fresh" pizzas that were on top of the HOT ovens. If these were two fresh pizzas, they must have gone from the ovens to the fridge and back as the grease and cheese was already congealing. Needless to say, I was in no position to refuse the pizzas right then as they were our supper for tonight. I reluctantly paid for them (wasn't comped or even offered a discount for their screwup) and went home to eat my cold "fresh" pizzas. Cripe, I had to nuke my slices to make them palatable. It is very unlikely we will be buying any pizza or other food from Pizza Man's Pizza for a very long time, if ever again. There are just too many other pizzerias in the neighboring area that offer quality product and superior customer service to spend my hard-earned money here again.
Fink
The pizza is delicious and the waitress Reva is amazing. Very courteous kind and efficient. Relaxing and peaceful environment
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Mike Kenney
2nd time going there for pizza and they messed order up and they have terrible customer service. When you call they put you on hold long period of time. They don’t care about customer service. Photo shows me on at least 10 min hold time to get problem resolved and they left me on hold.
WE LOVE PIZZA MAN!!!!! Not this evening though, my order was lost, I waited an hour, and needed to get a refund because I had to get my son off of the soccer bus. They did not know how to refund my card, and there was no apology...man I really was excited for some delicious pizza from here.
Mary Ann Robinson
Their pizzas are great. My favorite is the Pizzaman White! For other foods, eating in is best as food doesn't get soggy. Limited burger options.
I usually love Pizza Man Pizza! The last pizza I got was not the same. It was undercooked, mushy it the middle, and crust had no color to it. It may be my mistake b/c I am not sure the crust I got? I usually order regular crust. I wonder if I did not specify, what would be delivered? Thank you Jack L
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Richard Cohran
Had the Steak Pizza and Pepperoni with extra cheese. Steak Pizza was OK. Pepperoni was under cooked and when ordered asked to have it where cheese on top would be a bit brown. Sat up front near the window and fought nats! We did tell the staff about this. The wait was at least 30 min and they were less than 40 percent full. Overall food is not worth the wait nor another trip back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Sue Wills
Waited 45 minutes to get my cold, overcooked, dry pizza. The salad and dressing had been sitting on top of lasagna. Three times I went to the counter to pay and no one would wait on me. So very disappointed as their food is normally a fan favorite. This is the third strike. Pizza Hut or Papa John’s from now on.
I eat here pretty often, mostly takeout but sometimes I dine in. I love their sauce; subtly sweet without being cloying. I had an eggplant parmesan hoagie today. Fresh baked bread, ample cheese, and that delicious sauce. The eggplant is always good and not gritty or bitter.
Their pizza is great, but I've never had anything I didn't enjoy. I particularly like their margarita pie, which is simple and tasty. Order for pickup (you must call, no online ordering here) or stop in on your lunch break for pizza by the slice. You can't go wrong at this Westmont staple.
We usually get take out 2-3 times a month from here. Always delicious, best pizza!
Food quality has gone WAY DOWN hill. Ordered a steak and cheese hoagie with mushrooms and onions and thank goodness I ordered the extra toppings because the meat almost covered the inside of the bread. Used to be my go-to place when I wanted my favorite steak and cheese but NO MORE!!! Cooks handling food prep with no gloves!!!!! Won't be back!
I recently visited pizza man and witnessed a customer leave with a pizza and returned within 15 minutes claiming his order was wrong..the pizza man staff took the returned pizza and placed it on the counter for resale..before it was placed back on the counter a staff member picked a couple pieces of pepperoni off of the said pizza with her bare hands...I think that is very wrong placing the pizza on counter for resale after it left the restaurant and was returned later.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
I placed an order for a steak hoagie, receive a hot sausage sandwich and you want me to pay to have the correct food delivered, which is ridiculous!!’l
Great steak Stromboli at a reasonable price
Have ordered pizza here for a few years now. Quality is normally ok to good but at times it is inconsistent with uneven crust thickness and varying topping amounts from week to week. Having said that, tonight was a total disaster and likely a game ender for me. I called and ordered 2 X-Large pepperoni pizzas for pickup, gave my name and phone number, was given the price with tax, and was told 35-40 minutes they would be ready. That was at 4:48PM. My wife went to pick up the pizzas at 5:30PM and was told there was no order there under our name. She was told they had no record of the order. She came home and told me and I was livid. We were all hungry and tired and wanted supper. I called back to complain and was told the same thing, until the person then realized she misheard my name and wrote it wrong and our pizzas were there and I could come get them. I said no and wanted 2 fresh pizzas as it was already over a half an hour they must have been sitting there. After much arguing I was told they would make me 2 fresh pizzas and it would be 30-45 minutes and hung up on me. I called back immediately and said I would be over in 15 minutes for my FRESH pizzas. This was at 5:52PM per my call logs. I went over at 6:20 to pick them up. I was given two "fresh" pizzas that were on top of the HOT ovens. If these were two fresh pizzas, they must have gone from the ovens to the fridge and back as the grease and cheese was already congealing. Needless to say, I was in no position to refuse the pizzas right then as they were our supper for tonight. I reluctantly paid for them (wasn't comped or even offered a discount for their screwup) and went home to eat my cold "fresh" pizzas. Cripe, I had to nuke my slices to make them palatable. It is very unlikely we will be buying any pizza or other food from Pizza Man's Pizza for a very long time, if ever again. There are just too many other pizzerias in the neighboring area that offer quality product and superior customer service to spend my hard-earned money here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Have ordered pizza here for a few years now. Quality is normally ok to good but at times it is inconsistent with uneven crust thickness and varying topping amounts from week to week. Having said that, tonight was a total disaster and likely a game ender for me. I called and ordered 2 X-Large pepperoni pizzas for pickup, gave my name and phone number, was given the price with tax, and was told 35-40 minutes they would be ready. That was at 4:48PM. My wife went to pick up the pizzas at 5:30PM and was told there was no order there under our name. She was told they had no record of the order. She came home and told me and I was livid. We were all hungry and tired and wanted supper. I called back to complain and was told the same thing, until the person then realized she misheard my name and wrote it wrong and our pizzas were there and I could come get them. I said no and wanted 2 fresh pizzas as it was already over a half an hour they must have been sitting there. After much arguing I was told they would make me 2 fresh pizzas and it would be 30-45 minutes and hung up on me. I called back immediately and said I would be over in 15 minutes for my FRESH pizzas. This was at 5:52PM per my call logs. I went over at 6:20 to pick them up. I was given two "fresh" pizzas that were on top of the HOT ovens. If these were two fresh pizzas, they must have gone from the ovens to the fridge and back as the grease and cheese was already congealing. Needless to say, I was in no position to refuse the pizzas right then as they were our supper for tonight. I reluctantly paid for them (wasn't comped or even offered a discount for their screwup) and went home to eat my cold "fresh" pizzas. Cripe, I had to nuke my slices to make them palatable. It is very unlikely we will be buying any pizza or other food from Pizza Man's Pizza for a very long time, if ever again. There are just too many other pizzerias in the neighboring area that offer quality product and superior customer service to spend my hard-earned money here again.
The pizza is delicious and the waitress Reva is amazing. Very courteous kind and efficient. Relaxing and peaceful environment
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
2nd time going there for pizza and they messed order up and they have terrible customer service. When you call they put you on hold long period of time. They don’t care about customer service.
Photo shows me on at least 10 min hold time to get problem resolved and they left me on hold.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
WE LOVE PIZZA MAN!!!!! Not this evening though, my order was lost, I waited an hour, and needed to get a refund because I had to get my son off of the soccer bus. They did not know how to refund my card, and there was no apology...man I really was excited for some delicious pizza from here.
Their pizzas are great. My favorite is the Pizzaman White! For other foods, eating in is best as food doesn't get soggy. Limited burger options.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pierogi Pizza & Broccoli Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Wings
I usually love Pizza Man Pizza! The last pizza I got was not the same. It was undercooked, mushy it the middle, and crust had no color to it. It may be my mistake b/c I am not sure the crust I got? I usually order regular crust. I wonder if I did not specify, what would be delivered?
Thank you
Jack L
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Had the Steak Pizza and Pepperoni with extra cheese. Steak Pizza was OK. Pepperoni was under cooked and when ordered asked to have it where cheese on top would be a bit brown. Sat up front near the window and fought nats! We did tell the staff about this. The wait was at least 30 min and they were less than 40 percent full. Overall food is not worth the wait nor another trip back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Waited 45 minutes to get my cold, overcooked, dry pizza. The salad and dressing had been sitting on top of lasagna. Three times I went to the counter to pay and no one would wait on me. So very disappointed as their food is normally a fan favorite. This is the third strike. Pizza Hut or Papa John’s from now on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 1
Loading...