Pizza was amazing. Loved everything I ordered from here. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Toot
The pizza is amazing! The fries are always great. 1.25 slices. Perfect lunch spot. I gave the atmosphere 3* bc it is a very limited seating availability but I've never had to wait for a table to open up either so maybe most folks get it to go
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Taylor
Really good pizza!! We got our pizza quick too. The staff was very friendly and the place was clean. Very glad we stopped by and tried them out today!
Hailey
I stopped in before work to grab a 3 slices because I’m pregnant and have to eat something before the shift. I figured slice pies are usually already made if you’re advertising pizza by the slice so it should be quick. I waited 25 mins for 3 slices just to be told it will take another 5 minutes. I had to cancel my order and leave being that I was already late for work from waiting for so long. I’m beyond disappointed and if you know Halloween is a busy day you should keep your slice pies actively going in the oven. Now I’m late to work and still hungry. 30 minutes for 3 slices of pizza?!!! Over 10 people picked up full orders of pies and to go pies and I didn’t even get my food. Very upsetting. The only helpful person was the girl on register who apologized and gave me my money back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tom P
29 of oct.picked up 10 cuts couldn't wait to enjoy it was absolutely horrible the crust was not cooked right it was white and hard as a brick overall taste was not right either new cooks or owners not sure if I will ever go back again sucked🤢
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ron T
Fantastic valley pizza, at solid prices. A full tray of 14 cuts is under $20. It's on the oilier side of fried, but not terribly so. Their cheese blend adds slightly more flavor than other places like this, which I find to be an excellent reason to try Sizzle Pie.
Seating is limited, but there are tables available. The dining area is very small, however. Like most small pizza joints in the valley, I'd imagine most customers simply pick up to take elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isaac Baklanov
This place was recommended to me by my ex girlfriends mom (she keeps texting late at night and its kinda weird). I was wary of her advice but JEEZ, as soon as I see the place pulling up in my car I got IMEDDIATE good vibes. Prices? SUPER CHEAP. Quality? THE BEST. Vibe? Like I was transported to an old school 90s mom and pop shop. Collin helped us and was a relaxed and super chill guy, we ended up getting the Philly cheese steak pizza and it was delivered to our booth in less than 10 minutes piping HOT and fresh.
I think this recommendation was a secret way of trying to seduce me and well, it might have worked 😉
I really don't know how the experience or food could have been better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kacy Jo Wega
Adorable little place with amazing pizza. Pizza is comparable to Pizza Perfect if you are familiar with the idea. Square trays of pizza with a super crispy bottom and yummy onion based sauce. Of course you can order the pizza without the onion sauce but why would you?!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Geraldine Michalesko
Best pork barbecue in the Valley. Period! Fried pizza is CRAZY GOOD. Bathrooms are outside the building which is annoying. But the staff are efficient and friendly. And the customers are always ready to chat up a storm.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natale Harth
First time there with some friends, I got a 7 cut specialty pizza which was the buffalo wing for 12.50. Which was absolutely delicious, I also got but I inhaled it so there’s no picture of the fish fillet which came with two pickles and a side of chips. For the quality of food and prices you can’t pass up this pizza joint. Highly recommend.
yes I do recommend Sizzle Pi that is one of the many pizza places that I grew up on due to the fact that I am from the valley I can introduce everybody to a lot of pizza places and they are very reasonable with their prices most of them are in Nanticoke Brickhouse Pizza Marty's Pizza Pizza Bella Joe's Pizza etc etc etc
Jason Lowe
The pizza and soda is good however we just got done eating from here and we got rushed out their time that they're supposed to close is 7:00 but their time says 8:00 they need to change it
Pizza was amazing. Loved everything I ordered from here. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is amazing! The fries are always great. 1.25 slices. Perfect lunch spot. I gave the atmosphere 3* bc it is a very limited seating availability but I've never had to wait for a table to open up either so maybe most folks get it to go
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good pizza!! We got our pizza quick too. The staff was very friendly and the place was clean. Very glad we stopped by and tried them out today!
I stopped in before work to grab a 3 slices because I’m pregnant and have to eat something before the shift. I figured slice pies are usually already made if you’re advertising pizza by the slice so it should be quick. I waited 25 mins for 3 slices just to be told it will take another 5 minutes. I had to cancel my order and leave being that I was already late for work from waiting for so long. I’m beyond disappointed and if you know Halloween is a busy day you should keep your slice pies actively going in the oven. Now I’m late to work and still hungry. 30 minutes for 3 slices of pizza?!!! Over 10 people picked up full orders of pies and to go pies and I didn’t even get my food. Very upsetting. The only helpful person was the girl on register who apologized and gave me my money back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
29 of oct.picked up 10 cuts couldn't wait to enjoy it was absolutely horrible the crust was not cooked right it was white and hard as a brick overall taste was not right either new cooks or owners not sure if I will ever go back again sucked🤢
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Fantastic valley pizza, at solid prices. A full tray of 14 cuts is under $20. It's on the oilier side of fried, but not terribly so. Their cheese blend adds slightly more flavor than other places like this, which I find to be an excellent reason to try Sizzle Pie.
Seating is limited, but there are tables available. The dining area is very small, however. Like most small pizza joints in the valley, I'd imagine most customers simply pick up to take elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was recommended to me by my ex girlfriends mom (she keeps texting late at night and its kinda weird). I was wary of her advice but JEEZ, as soon as I see the place pulling up in my car I got IMEDDIATE good vibes. Prices? SUPER CHEAP. Quality? THE BEST. Vibe? Like I was transported to an old school 90s mom and pop shop. Collin helped us and was a relaxed and super chill guy, we ended up getting the Philly cheese steak pizza and it was delivered to our booth in less than 10 minutes piping HOT and fresh.
I think this recommendation was a secret way of trying to seduce me and well, it might have worked 😉
I really don't know how the experience or food could have been better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adorable little place with amazing pizza. Pizza is comparable to Pizza Perfect if you are familiar with the idea. Square trays of pizza with a super crispy bottom and yummy onion based sauce. Of course you can order the pizza without the onion sauce but why would you?!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pork barbecue in the Valley. Period! Fried pizza is CRAZY GOOD.
Bathrooms are outside the building which is annoying. But the staff are efficient and friendly. And the customers are always ready to chat up a storm.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time there with some friends, I got a 7 cut specialty pizza which was the buffalo wing for 12.50. Which was absolutely delicious, I also got but I inhaled it so there’s no picture of the fish fillet which came with two pickles and a side of chips. For the quality of food and prices you can’t pass up this pizza joint. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in the area since the 70's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got Thurs Special 14 cuts for $13.99.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
yes I do recommend Sizzle Pi that is one of the many pizza places that I grew up on due to the fact that I am from the valley I can introduce everybody to a lot of pizza places and they are very reasonable with their prices most of them are in Nanticoke Brickhouse Pizza Marty's Pizza Pizza Bella Joe's Pizza etc etc etc
The pizza and soda is good however we just got done eating from here and we got rushed out their time that they're supposed to close is 7:00 but their time says 8:00 they need to change it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best square pizza!
Loading...