Fantastic place to eat. Great people and great food.
Kelly Blake
A bit disappointing. The cheese pizza was very bland and flavorless. The boneless wings were very dry and had next to no sauce. Not the worst but definitely not the best
Brian Klukososki
Good place for specialty pizza.
Joyce Fermaint
If you want great authentic Italian Brooklyn pizza...this is the place to go.
Ellen
The Cali cheesesteak is delicious. The roll it is served on was pillowy soft. The cheese pizza slices are delicious as well. For me, when it comes to pizza, if your sauce is crappy tasting, then your pizza is crap also. This is definitely NOT the case with Brooklyn Pizza. The sauce is tangy and well developed. It is one of 2 places I get pizza from. I highly recommend this place. Also, there is a nice cozy feel to the inside of this place. Usually , I'm a grab my pizza and go kinda girl, but this place because it is so cozy, I find myself eating there in the dining room. The staff here are also very friendly and very sweet and helpful.
Emily H
We live almost an hour away but make sure to get here as often as we can. Growing up in NJ we had great pizza places around every corner and had to adjust to that not being the case in PA. Thankfully, we found this place and felt like we were back home. The pizza is excellent and consistent and better than anything else we've tried in the area. We are big fans!
Daisy Peguero
They’re delicious!! This is our favorite spot and they know us by name. Flavor always hits the spot and is super delicious. Anything you get taste so good. The guys are really sweet too
Dayanese Rodriguez
I’d dare to say BEST PIZZA IN LANCASTER. They never miss the mark! Very consistent and fresh!
Abel Canales Zamora
Pizza is very good. Staff very friendly. 1st time here and it'll be definitely more. I recommend Del Mar pizza
Absolutely five stars. This place is everything you want in a pizza-by-the-slice joint and more. The quality of the ingredients is the first thing you notice—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Every bite hits right. But what really sets this place apart is the atmosphere. The younger staff talk to you like you’re one of their own—like you’re just a brother stopping by for a slice. And the owner? He treats you like family in the best way, like that grandfather you actually want to sit and talk with. It’s rare to find a spot that nails both the food and the feeling, but this one does. The prices are solid too, which makes it even better. Can’t recommend it enough.
Timothy Lankes
Don't get to Lancaster as often as I would like, but I do love Brooklyn Pizza Grill! Friendly service and delicious pizza. Very highly recommended.
Megan Salas
Don't deliver to local customers local community but deliver to hotels make this make sense
Dan Hallinan
Pizza was good. We got it to go
Stephanie Donmez
Pizza is fantastic! My one and only spot to have pizza.
Great food and pizza!
Fantastic place to eat. Great people and great food.
A bit disappointing. The cheese pizza was very bland and flavorless. The boneless wings were very dry and had next to no sauce. Not the worst but definitely not the best
Good place for specialty pizza.
If you want great authentic Italian Brooklyn pizza...this is the place to go.
The Cali cheesesteak is delicious. The roll it is served on was pillowy soft. The cheese pizza slices are delicious as well. For me, when it comes to pizza, if your sauce is crappy tasting, then your pizza is crap also. This is definitely NOT the case with Brooklyn Pizza. The sauce is tangy and well developed. It is one of 2 places I get pizza from. I highly recommend this place. Also, there is a nice cozy feel to the inside of this place. Usually , I'm a grab my pizza and go kinda girl, but this place because it is so cozy, I find myself eating there in the dining room. The staff here are also very friendly and very sweet and helpful.
We live almost an hour away but make sure to get here as often as we can. Growing up in NJ we had great pizza places around every corner and had to adjust to that not being the case in PA. Thankfully, we found this place and felt like we were back home. The pizza is excellent and consistent and better than anything else we've tried in the area. We are big fans!
They’re delicious!! This is our favorite spot and they know us by name. Flavor always hits the spot and is super delicious. Anything you get taste so good. The guys are really sweet too
I’d dare to say BEST PIZZA IN LANCASTER. They never miss the mark! Very consistent and fresh!
Pizza is very good. Staff very friendly. 1st time here and it'll be definitely more. I recommend Del Mar pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely five stars. This place is everything you want in a pizza-by-the-slice joint and more. The quality of the ingredients is the first thing you notice—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Every bite hits right. But what really sets this place apart is the atmosphere. The younger staff talk to you like you’re one of their own—like you’re just a brother stopping by for a slice. And the owner? He treats you like family in the best way, like that grandfather you actually want to sit and talk with. It’s rare to find a spot that nails both the food and the feeling, but this one does. The prices are solid too, which makes it even better. Can’t recommend it enough.
Don't get to Lancaster as often as I would like, but I do love Brooklyn Pizza Grill! Friendly service and delicious pizza. Very highly recommended.
Don't deliver to local customers local community but deliver to hotels make this make sense
Pizza was good. We got it to go
Pizza is fantastic! My one and only spot to have pizza.
Loading...