A Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria

861 Village Rd, Lancaster
(717) 464-4004

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ashley

Usually this place is great. But we got wings from there tonight and all three orders were just not good. One order was a very weird brown color and tasted nothing like the sauce it was supposed to be. Just not good at all.

Sonny Ramos

In the area for training and per Google reviews found this spot. Once again, so disappointed with the pizza. I start to wonder if people know what good pizza is. The spot is tiny no place to actually sit and we ended up sitting out in the parking lot with our nasty slices. The crust seems premade almost cardboard like, the sauce taste like it's straight out the can and let's not get on to the cheese, 2 bites later, my slice was in the trash.

Ryan Swope

Good good.

Michael Rosen

Order a pizza for delivery, the pizza was made wrong missing toppings and the pizza really just tasted bad. Ask for refund because of the order was made wrong, was refunded $2 for the missing topping. What a joke

Paul Zook

Easy parking friendly staff. Pizza is good

Josiah Donaldson

Ordered a meatlovers pizza and was told it would take 15-25 minutes. I arrived around 25 minutes after I ordered and the pizza was not yet out of the oven. I assumed it was started late, and was glad in a way that it was not done yet so it would be hot. The boy at the counter called for his Mom to get the pizza out. She was on the phone talking to someone. Not sure who it was but clearly not a customer as the call was going on the entire time I was in the restaurant. She came and got it out and put it in the box and handed it to him to give to me so she could continue her phone conversation. I got the pizza home and it was slightly burnt to say the least. Crust was inedible. Pizza was on the crispy side. The place was dead as a door nail and couldn't do the one order they received without burning it. I try not to be picky but when the phone distracts you from pulling out the customers order before it burns its on you.

Mike Graney

Great food and great people!

Dereck Bauman

Want to try them and call in an order for pick. Was told that with coupon o had it was fine to change the wings to boneless. The order got pick up and was going though it to give everyone there food they got. We'll come to find out it was messed up. Call to ask what happened. Was then told the wings couldn't be changed to the boneless. Was not called to be let that I had to get the regular ones. And they did not hear all of what was being ordered when I called first. When got to pick up the other things that was messed on the one had an ear bud in his ear. Will NOT BE GOING BACK THERE EVER AND NOT HAPY WITH THE THINGS WHERE HANDLED

Bob Baxendell

Just a neighborhood pizza shop with so so quality. Not bad / not going back.

Rhonda Long

Pizza was very good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joe C

Charged us $10.79 (plus tax) for each of the Super Italiano subs that we ordered from them when it clearly says $9.75 (plus tax) on all of their menus on their site and online. The guy didn't even look at the menu when he rang me up - Just entered the inflated price right into the register. He knew what he was doing. I didn't say anything to him to avoid embarrassing him or getting him fired - But, this place has lost our business for life. And I'll tell everyone I know about this.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

terry callahan

Their pizza used to be good, had a slice of pepperoni pizza and it sucked, the sauce had all dried up, hardly any pepperoni and not much cheese either very dry pizza, go to Two Cousin's Pizza in Willow Street Pa.

Junior Paiz

This is a great place were u can come and eat with your family the people here are really nice and is a really crean place the food is really good and deliciousI really recommend this place is a really good place Were you can came and eat with your family

Parking: A really good parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chef Salad, Loaded Sidewinder Fries, Garlic Knots, Large Grandma Pizza, Gourmet White, Jalapeno Poppers, Cheese Fries, Mozzarella Sticks, Margherita Pizza, French Fries, Wings with Bone Deep-Fried Chicken Wings with Your Choice of Sauce, Onion Rings, Loaded Fries, BBQ Chicken Wrap, Italiano, 10 Personal Pizza, 16 Large

Luz De leon

Beautiful people, I love that food ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joelia Figueroa

I bought a slice of pizza and a cannoli, after I gave the pizza to my boyfriend I opened the cannoli and found mold all over it. THEY LEFT ALL THE DESSERTS IN THE CASE! They did not inspect nor throw away the remaining desserts after the discovery of the mold. I asked for a full refund due to the pizza I ordered not being freshly made, there is no way to tell how long that was sitting in the case either. Which they denied understandably. However they left the filthy expired desserts in the case for the next customer. Disgusting. As you can see in the attached picture it is not a spec, but an overgrowth of mold!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...