If I were anyone else this would be a 4 & maybe even a 5 overall!!! So if you are reading this…. This place is good. Marinara great flavor, robust some spice & complexity. Mozzarella Sticks hot, buttery, cooked to perfection. This reviewer couldn’t decide the age old question. “To dip or not to dip?” The cheeseburger sub, hot fresh, SEASONED (hallelujah!!!) tasted great. Unfortunately, was light. Suggestion for owners: IMHO, Meat should be end to end, lettuce & filler should rise above the bread. This was a 1/2 patty & 1 pinch of lettuce from perfect. Mayo was sweet, which is not my fave, however because it was well seasoned I didn’t mind as much. If you are going to go sweet use Miracle Whip 🤢. Cheese was good. The outside & inside unassuming. A lot of taped signage, guest expectation postings which is 1 of many of my pet peeves. Give them a try, you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Erik Rowe
Stopped in to grab some lunch since it had over a 4 star rating. Pizza came out looking fine but did not have any flavor and the red pepper flakes were old and stale. Owner seemed nice but the quality of the food seemed off.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Mike Wilson
I'm always looking for good pizza and meatball sandwiches, and this shop hit the mark. The food was very good and service great. The restaurant itself is your typical mom and pop pizza shop, which is not necessarily a bad thing. Say hello to Candy for me if you go.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Meatball Sub with Cheese, Round Thin Crust
Ben C
Pricey slices IMHO. $3.50?
Elaine
Definitely not the Columbo's I remember. Used to be the best stromboli around, much less meat inside the boli. Pizza was overdone and cheese barely covered the sauce. Delivery person was great! Very friendly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Charnell
I’ve been a loyal customer for many years. Ever since new ownership took over, the quality of the food decline tremendously and the prices are higher.This is very disappointed. Unfortunately, I will no longer be a loyal customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Charnell NC
I’ve been a loyal customer for many years. Ever since new ownership took over, the quality of the food decline tremendously and the prices are higher.This is very disappointed. Unfortunately, I will no longer be a loyal customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
John Auer
Some say America runs on dunking. I say look where that's gotten us. Have you seen the price of eggs lately? Have you been to our big cities? How's that whole war in Afghanistan thing going? America needs to run on Ma and PA shops like Columbo's Pizza. These kind of places build this country. Cheap and delicious fast food that doesn't ever disappoint or change.
Parking: Easy peasy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Thin Crust
David Zeller
We love their Stromboli m it one of the best in Lancaster. Specially the Columbia. It's their signature Stromboli. Very good. Their other foods are great as well
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: XL Three Cheese Pizza, Cheesesteak, Columboli
Mandy Rice
Ordered a $16 small veggie pizza and the crust is still raw! It’s stuck to the box.I added a photo in the pictures part.
I had not eaten at Columbo's in over 10 years. Stopped in to grab one of their tuna salads. Although the price has gone up due to all this wonderful inflation we have to deal with, I found that the salad was just as delicious as it was years ago. It's the only restaurant where I trust getting the tuna. It is fresh and all the ingredients in the salad make it absolutely delicious. I had enough for two meals so it really was economical. Love that they have not changed. There's not too many things or places about which you can say that. 10 out of 10 plus!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna
Joe Pleva
We stopped coming to your restaurant. Can’t believe how much you raised your prices and no coupons. Too many good and cheaper places around.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
jason thomas
Nice little pizza place, no
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Molina
Wilkes Barre
Daniel Christian
I’ve lived in Lancaster for 3 1/2 months. Late coming back from visiting friends/family In Maryland, I stopped to get a quick slice or two for a late dinner. It was 15 minutes before closing, and I asked if two slices would be a hassle. He told me “no problem.” 10 minutes later he hands me a box and charges $6.50. Sounds fair. When I get home to eat, what’s in the box? Two slices of pizza, ZERO cheese with one swath of paste won the crust. Sausage was randomly strewn around. When I picked up the first slice, ALL the sausage fell off. Not even warm…I’m pretty sure I was taken advantage of. All he had to say was “sorry, but it’s too late. Please come back again.” It was really a terrible way to serve food. I was stunned.
If I were anyone else this would be a 4 & maybe even a 5 overall!!! So if you are reading this…. This place is good. Marinara great flavor, robust some spice & complexity. Mozzarella Sticks hot, buttery, cooked to perfection. This reviewer couldn’t decide the age old question. “To dip or not to dip?” The cheeseburger sub, hot fresh, SEASONED (hallelujah!!!) tasted great. Unfortunately, was light. Suggestion for owners: IMHO, Meat should be end to end, lettuce & filler should rise above the bread. This was a 1/2 patty & 1 pinch of lettuce from perfect. Mayo was sweet, which is not my fave, however because it was well seasoned I didn’t mind as much. If you are going to go sweet use Miracle Whip 🤢. Cheese was good. The outside & inside unassuming. A lot of taped signage, guest expectation postings which is 1 of many of my pet peeves. Give them a try, you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Stopped in to grab some lunch since it had over a 4 star rating. Pizza came out looking fine but did not have any flavor and the red pepper flakes were old and stale. Owner seemed nice but the quality of the food seemed off.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
I'm always looking for good pizza and meatball sandwiches, and this shop hit the mark. The food was very good and service great. The restaurant itself is your typical mom and pop pizza shop, which is not necessarily a bad thing. Say hello to Candy for me if you go.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Meatball Sub with Cheese, Round Thin Crust
Pricey slices IMHO. $3.50?
Definitely not the Columbo's I remember. Used to be the best stromboli around, much less meat inside the boli. Pizza was overdone and cheese barely covered the sauce. Delivery person was great! Very friendly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
I’ve been a loyal customer for many years. Ever since new ownership took over, the quality of the food decline tremendously and the prices are higher.This is very disappointed. Unfortunately, I will no longer be a loyal customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I’ve been a loyal customer for many years. Ever since new ownership took over, the quality of the food decline tremendously and the prices are higher.This is very disappointed. Unfortunately, I will no longer be a loyal customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Some say America runs on dunking. I say look where that's gotten us. Have you seen the price of eggs lately? Have you been to our big cities? How's that whole war in Afghanistan thing going? America needs to run on Ma and PA shops like Columbo's Pizza. These kind of places build this country. Cheap and delicious fast food that doesn't ever disappoint or change.
Parking: Easy peasy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Thin Crust
We love their Stromboli m it one of the best in Lancaster. Specially the Columbia. It's their signature Stromboli. Very good. Their other foods are great as well
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: XL Three Cheese Pizza, Cheesesteak, Columboli
Ordered a $16 small veggie pizza and the crust is still raw! It’s stuck to the box.I added a photo in the pictures part.
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I had not eaten at Columbo's in over 10 years. Stopped in to grab one of their tuna salads. Although the price has gone up due to all this wonderful inflation we have to deal with, I found that the salad was just as delicious as it was years ago. It's the only restaurant where I trust getting the tuna. It is fresh and all the ingredients in the salad make it absolutely delicious. I had enough for two meals so it really was economical. Love that they have not changed. There's not too many things or places about which you can say that. 10 out of 10 plus!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna
We stopped coming to your restaurant. Can’t believe how much you raised your prices and no coupons. Too many good and cheaper places around.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Nice little pizza place, no
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wilkes Barre
I’ve lived in Lancaster for 3 1/2 months. Late coming back from visiting friends/family In Maryland, I stopped to get a quick slice or two for a late dinner. It was 15 minutes before closing, and I asked if two slices would be a hassle. He told me “no problem.” 10 minutes later he hands me a box and charges $6.50. Sounds fair. When I get home to eat, what’s in the box? Two slices of pizza, ZERO cheese with one swath of paste won the crust. Sausage was randomly strewn around. When I picked up the first slice, ALL the sausage fell off. Not even warm…I’m pretty sure I was taken advantage of. All he had to say was “sorry, but it’s too late. Please come back again.” It was really a terrible way to serve food. I was stunned.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...