I have tried a wide array of dishes here at the Conestoga since it has reopened. The service is spectacular, everyone being extremely polite and attentive, while the food is outstanding. No matter if what I am getting is something simple or a full entrée, the Conestoga has yet to disappoint, in all aspects. It also has a wonderful adult beverage selection with 14 beers on tap in the bar!
Enos Fisher
Just an all around great spot to eat, the deck by the water was awesome, the waitress Taylor was absolutely fantastic, she was friendly and very attentive!!! The new owner was out on the floor helping as he could and came to make sure we were satisfied, all in all great experience and highly recommend!!! I had the prime rib, it was fantastic!!!
Marcelle Murdock
Great food, at good large portions!! Dining experience made better by an enthusiastic, cheerful, and knowledgeable staff.
Nicole
The service was great! So much better than previous owners! The steak was cooked perfectly and the salmon was amazing! Definitely need to upgrade their outside tables and invest in bug zappers!!
Joni Bliler
Beautiful, very old stone building. Menu selections were good, food was great, outdoor deck next to the water was so nice and enjoyable. Waitress, Jillian, was so attentive, friendly, and pleasant. Definitely worthy of 5 stars and I will go back.
Francis Junto
Absolutely fantastic food for a reasonable price stopped again for lunch with family great service wonderful atmosphere and delicious food absolutely will go back again
Francis Melan
The food was great. I arrived very hot and exactly as expected. They were very busy, but the service was good. It's not a fancy restaurant, but I plan on going back in the.
Joe Davis (Chilly)
Nice tap selection and a tasty burger, but it's the bacon wrapped shrimp that is worth stopping for.
Amazing food and drinks! My husband had the blackened catfish that was seasoned perfectly and I had the marsala chicken that melted in your mouth. We definitely go again
Chris Rohrbaugh
We were there last night with my single meet up group. Food was good and staff was great
Michael Morse
I went for dinner last night and got a NY strip steak. I didn’t expect much because of the price, but it was fantastic. I’ve paid 2x-3x for steaks a la carte that weren’t as good. Our server was attentive and was very nice. I would definitely come back.
Carlynn Adams
Server was very sweet, but the food and drinks were really disappointing. Shrimp on the Conestoga salad was undercooked, the “pancetta” on the pizza smelled foul, and there was a table behind us that was not bussed the whole hour and a half we were there.
Mark Henry
About 3 months into new ownership, and they’re doing an absolutely wonderful job. First, our server Taylor was 3 weeks into her job and she was a rock star! So kind and gave us all the info we could need for a good dining experience. We sat outside because the sun was still up! We had the linguine bolognese and the linguini puttanesca - my wife wasn’t fond of the bolognese; it was made with shredded beef like a roast maybe? Instead of ground beef. I liked it but it was different than traditional American restaurant bolognese. The puttanesca was extremely good, highly recommend. It was a great first time experience and worth repeating visits as they get themselves settled with kitchen movement and staffing. Very impressive. Oh, full bar and cocktails were good.
Great food & service! Nice & clean as well.
Good grub. Pleasantly surprised.
I have tried a wide array of dishes here at the Conestoga since it has reopened. The service is spectacular, everyone being extremely polite and attentive, while the food is outstanding. No matter if what I am getting is something simple or a full entrée, the Conestoga has yet to disappoint, in all aspects. It also has a wonderful adult beverage selection with 14 beers on tap in the bar!
Just an all around great spot to eat, the deck by the water was awesome, the waitress Taylor was absolutely fantastic, she was friendly and very attentive!!! The new owner was out on the floor helping as he could and came to make sure we were satisfied, all in all great experience and highly recommend!!! I had the prime rib, it was fantastic!!!
Great food, at good large portions!! Dining experience made better by an enthusiastic, cheerful, and knowledgeable staff.
The service was great! So much better than previous owners!
The steak was cooked perfectly and the salmon was amazing!
Definitely need to upgrade their outside tables and invest in bug zappers!!
Beautiful, very old stone building. Menu selections were good, food was great, outdoor deck next to the water was so nice and enjoyable. Waitress, Jillian, was so attentive, friendly, and pleasant. Definitely worthy of 5 stars and I will go back.
Absolutely fantastic food for a reasonable price stopped again for lunch with family great service wonderful atmosphere and delicious food absolutely will go back again
The food was great. I arrived very hot and exactly as expected. They were very busy, but the service was good. It's not a fancy restaurant, but I plan on going back in the.
Nice tap selection and a tasty burger, but it's the bacon wrapped shrimp that is worth stopping for.
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing food and drinks! My husband had the blackened catfish that was seasoned perfectly and I had the marsala chicken that melted in your mouth. We definitely go again
We were there last night with my single meet up group. Food was good and staff was great
I went for dinner last night and got a NY strip steak. I didn’t expect much because of the price, but it was fantastic. I’ve paid 2x-3x for steaks a la carte that weren’t as good. Our server was attentive and was very nice. I would definitely come back.
Server was very sweet, but the food and drinks were really disappointing. Shrimp on the Conestoga salad was undercooked, the “pancetta” on the pizza smelled foul, and there was a table behind us that was not bussed the whole hour and a half we were there.
About 3 months into new ownership, and they’re doing an absolutely wonderful job. First, our server Taylor was 3 weeks into her job and she was a rock star! So kind and gave us all the info we could need for a good dining experience. We sat outside because the sun was still up! We had the linguine bolognese and the linguini puttanesca - my wife wasn’t fond of the bolognese; it was made with shredded beef like a roast maybe? Instead of ground beef. I liked it but it was different than traditional American restaurant bolognese. The puttanesca was extremely good, highly recommend. It was a great first time experience and worth repeating visits as they get themselves settled with kitchen movement and staffing. Very impressive. Oh, full bar and cocktails were good.
Loading...