Dominion Pizza

938 Columbia Ave, Lancaster
(717) 481-5544

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Harp West

Called this place for an hour to place an order and nobody answered. I also believe the phone is connected to someone’s cellular phone which is unprofessional to me, due to the unprofessionalism they lost what could’ve been a loyal customer. Get it together dominions!

J Love

Whoever cooked my cheese steak and cheese cake roll last night 🤌💋

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandon Balmer

I have a strong personal connection to this pizza shop, having grown up on it. The pizza, 2 subs, and a 2 litter combo was a staple in our household. However, I stopped visiting for some time due to inconsistent food quality. Recently, I’ve returned five times, ordering pizza and a chicken cheesesteak each visit. Three of those experiences were excellent, while two were disappointing. It’s the same exact food but one time it is a sloppy greece pile the next it’s a great pie. This inconsistency is frustrating and difficult to understand

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Nathan Clouden

Their pizza has been solid, but that doesn't extend to their subs. Ordered an Italian sub that was a loaf of bread with lettuce and barely any meat or cheese and a chicken parm that was dry and had almost no marinara sauce on it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Tayleen Torres

We love dominion,definitely one of our favorite go to places for pizza,subs and even wings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tarup Mitra

The Columbia Avenue Dominions was well kept and the lady at the counter was very nice. The wings I got were cooked perfectly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marisia Burgos

I ordered a medium sausage pizza and a small cheese steak sub. Why when I get home my pizza is cold as crap and I first hold the sub it feels light asf also like it’s just bread !!! I look inside and it’s just meat and literally 1 piece of cheese we had to add more cheese at home and sauce !! But this is ridiculous!!! I’ve ordered from them before and this never happened before !! And I don’t live far from the place either so there’s no way it got freezing cold by the time I got home. The pizza literally looks it’s been reheated with extra cheese thrown on top!! And it couldn’t have been much because the pizza is also thin asf !!! And hard and just not it rlly !! Very disappointed wish I could get a refund or something!! Worst $28 spent could’ve gotten better at dominos or little Cesar’s!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kim Kendig

Great food, Superb service, always friendly and smiling, great atmosphere!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dmoski Boudadouski

Love the pizza and everyone is always cool and respectful love it! We eat here atleast twice a month

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Brendan Burgey

Me and my electric unicycle group host an event behind this place every other week. Every time I stop here and grab a slice of pizza and a good old beer. The atmosphere is great and the service is outstanding. food quality is Top Notch as well!💯🇺🇸🫡

Christopher Saylor

I love this pizza shop absolutely amazing location. Awesome staff 10/10

Phly Guy

Got a smashed cheeseburger sub it looked like the cook was mad mad at it and squeezed the life out of it, wouldn't recommend

Dylan Drennen

Here all summer, it’s great for the community!

Ageless Waterproofing

Excellent staff and great food!!!

DONALD PRICE

Always incredible!!!

Loading...