Jethro's Restaurant & Bar

659 1st St, Lancaster
(717) 299-1700

Recent Reviews

Sue Miller

Food was special and making new friends at the bar was easy.

Kyle Conaty

I have never ate here however I’ve heard it’s very good. Every time I’ve stopped here it was for a Long Island iced tea with a couple friends. I can say those are delicious!

Logan Kreider

Great atmosphere! Lovely little hidden gem. Hope it never changes.

Lori Hauck Irvin

Enjoyed our dinner! Loved the whole vibe!

Melissa H.

Never again. Don't waste a dollar on food...drinks maybe, but too many quality restaurants in Lancaster to even consider this one. Save yourself the hassle. Certainly a hard no in the taste department.

Susan N.

Requested medium well steak, served medium rare. Shrimp in pasta scallops shrimp pomodoro was raw and the bay scallops were tiny and few. Dirty and sticky salt and pepper shakers and candle hurricanes at the tables. Waste of 105$ for 3 meals.

Elizabeth Harvey

Never lets me down. I've been visiting Jethro's for decades, literally, and have yet to be disappointed. On this visit, there were three of us celebrating a birthday. Our server was knowledgeable and helpful. Lots of personality. The meals were perfect. Fun flavors. Good, basic gourmet with some specials. Nice presentation. Tasty desserts. I highly recommend the tapenade. Mmm.

Nathaniel Zorach

Unambitious but tasty fare. Limited beer list but a respectable bar, good drinks, and good service.

Mary Gallagher Lumsden

Comradary along with meeting new and interesting people. Laid back with great food and music.

Kimberly Reddinger Weit

Five Stars! Such an exquisite menu and friendly and warm atmosphere! Always fabulous food and a great time- wonderful for everyday or special occasions!

Brett Stabley

Jethros is always a good idea. The atmosphere is always just right, the staff is inviting, and the food hits the mark! It's been one of my favorites for decades now!

AQP

Favorite local spot, hands down. One of my best buddies introduced me and now I can't get enough. Best bang for your buck for sure.

Vanessa P.

A neighbourhood upscale "dive" bar....but perhaps the quotes should be around upscale, instead. Ambitious menu features duck, filet, lamb, but they should probably stick to pizza and burgers. Sub par meat quality, mediocre drinks and salads DRENCHED in dressings. Unannounced menu changes.... if an item is different than the menu describes, this should be noted by server when that item is ordered. It was not. Bathrooms are nasty. A waste of $150. There are many wonderful restaurants in Lancaster....this is not one of them

Hadiyah Husam

Great service and amazing food. Thank you!

brielle pagan

Food and service was great. I can't wait to go back for more fillet. Even the vegetables were delicious!

Load More