Lancaster Pie & Coffee
Customers' Favorites
Sour Cherry Pie with Homemade Ice Cream
Onion and Mushroom Quiche
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Sweet Hand Pies
Blueberry Pie
Oatmilk Latte
Liege Waffle
Pumpkin Pie
Apple Pie
Affogato
Menu
Photos
+10 photos
+9 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Words cannot express how wonderful Lancaster Pie and Coffee is. I also want to note that I have been a huge fan for a while. We wanted to have pie instead of cake for our wedding, and they made it beyond easy to help us. Micah is an actual angel who made the entire process seamless and enjoyable, all while being the sweetest person ever. The day of the wedding, he personally delivered the pies to our venue and put them away for us. We also needed a few pies for some people with...
Dude. What an absolute sensorial masterpiece. This freaking pie is so good. Best bite I have had in Lancaster?!?!? Cabalar who? Luca what? Why is it only 4.9 stars?? Must visit. I would know. I know some things. I have eaten some places. Trust me. Take my hand to a piegasm.
You May Also Like
Nahual Maya Restaurant - 126 N Prince St
![]()
Sushi Bar, Salvadoran
Passerine - 114 N Prince St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, New American, Cocktail Bar
Columbia Kettle Works 2nd Gear Taproom - 112 N Water St
![]()
Brewery, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly
Favorite flavors: blueberry, strawberry rhubard, and lemon custard.