Lancaster Pie & Coffee
Customers' Favorites
Sour Cherry Pie with Homemade Ice Cream
Onion and Mushroom Quiche
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Sweet Hand Pies
Blueberry Pie
Oatmilk Latte
Liege Waffle
Pumpkin Pie
Apple Pie
Affogato
Menu
Photos
+10 photos
+9 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place has it all! To start, there is a great playlist that fits the beautiful marriage of bright and earnest dedication to detail. The pies were fantastic (our favorite being the pecan bourbon) and Micah went above and beyond to be accommodating to my allergy. We need this in Philly!
The service is incredibly friendly and helpful here, I cannot say that enough. The interior is a bit close, but this is fairly common in Lancaster, so I can't fault that- it works fine for takeout! The coffee/espresso options aren't bad, though I will say the oat milk is very forward and overpowers the coffee, so I might go with dairy next time. The pies are where they shine- they make so many flavors in different styles and sizes, and it's marvelous. I snagged...
Lancaster Pie and Coffee is truly one of Lancaster city’s hidden gems. All the food has that homemade touch and flavor to it. I am very much a savory pie person, the chicken and brisket pie NEVER disappoint. On the sweet pie end, the lemon crème and chocolate silk pies are heavenly. I also love that they serve hand-pies if the full portion is too big for you. The service is also phenomenal, Annie the barista is always very attentive. Highly recommend as a Lancaster local!
You May Also Like
Nahual Maya Restaurant - 126 N Prince St
![]()
Sushi Bar, Salvadoran
Passerine - 114 N Prince St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, New American, Cocktail Bar
Columbia Kettle Works 2nd Gear Taproom - 112 N Water St
![]()
Brewery, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly