P.J. Whelihan's Pub + Restaurant - Lancaster
1569 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster
(717) 205-4700
Recent Reviews
Sort by
My family and I had dinner on Mother’s Day and our sever was Bri. I did not like what I ordered and she was so sweet and understanding and allowed me to get something else without making me feel uncomfortable. She made some great drink recommendations and was very knowledgeable about the entire menu. Bill the manager came and checked in on us and was so kind and genuinely wanted our opinion. He was great!!! We sat outside and it was just an overall great experience.
Lori was a fabulous server! So kind and thoughtful. She even thought to bring out our 2 year old son’s food out first to keep him happy and the manager Bill was so friendly. Can’t wait to go back :)
It was very nice. Everything was great!!
Always pleasure
I get that it's a sports bar, but sometimes the TV's are overwhelmingly too loud to carry on a conversation at your table. Food is always outstanding and delicious.
This restaurant was TERRIBLE!!! The wings were dry, there was barely any sauce on them, and they tasted terrible. The burger was not edible. The fires (if you could even call them that) they were not salted, and they weren’t even cooked. The soda tasted like city water. And lastly the service was terrible and took forever to get me my food.
Cody was great. Beer list is solid, surprising finds for a chain. The GM Bill is an industry legend, truly cares about his staff and customer experience!
Major shout out for PJs providing our basketball team accommodations for 28 guests and made it feel seamless during the busy dinner rush.
To Brie and Kylie for setting this up initially and the front of house and management executing that day.
Will certainly do a team dinner here again
Gabby was amazing! We had a large party and she was perfect! We will be back!
Gabby was awesome!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Such an amazing experience the best I ever had Ashley treated me better than any bartender I ever had 😊
One of my favorite restaurants. They have a large menu with a lot of good choices, however, I typically go with shrimp tacos.
There's no black and bleu burger on the menu here like my gma was hoping for, but our waitress let her build her own and she said it was perfect. The strawberry salad I had was superb, and everything came out quickly. The candied pecans topping my salad made us buy some the next day because of how good they were haha.
25 dollar steak. Asked medium, was well done and who serves white rice. No flavor, waste of money.
Jillian was awesome!!
Loading...