Papa Johns Pizza

1314 Lititz Pike, Lancaster
(717) 397-7200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maurice Johnson

Very bad experience, manager kept sweating and wiping his hands on his very dirty shirt

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sasha Richardson

Very clean store, prompt efficient service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Mr. Person

Got a Papa's Alfredo Bowl. It looked nothing like the picture and was nothing but grease. Literally swimming in grease.

Food: 1

J Rivera

Worst place to order pizza very unprofessional customer service sucks and they do not care about you or your food it’s all about money there you take it or leave it who wants to do business with this kind of company I hope they close them down for good to many complaints on this shop and the workers there CLOSE THEM DOWN! I wish I could post the video of this lady shaking my soda and messing with my food while walking to my doorstep caught it all on my camera and reported her to corporate she gets what she deserves if she gets fired and as for the manager he needs to do better next time before he’s next don’t trust them with your food order elsewhere it’s not worth your health or kids getting sick off careless workers

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cindi Jo Carl Musselman

Delicious thin crust veggie! Will definitely order again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donna Dodson

Ordered a pizza via their website for pickup and then waited for it to finish getting ready in my car ? out in the parking lot of the store.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Crust Pizza

Raiiyn Daiiys

I ordered the garlic cheese crust stuffed pizza with BBQ sauce. They put a overload of BBQ sauce which completely ruined the pizza. I hope they reap what they sow for wasting my last $25 😫

Johnise Warren

I ordered the garlic cheese crust stuffed pizza with BBQ sauce. They put a overload of BBQ sauce which completely ruined the pizza. I hope they reap what they sow for wasting my last $25 ?

Anya Madison

It’s just

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tyler Klingbeil

We ordered 2 large pizzas and got 10 garlic sauces with the order and we got 2 out of 10. Ordered from doordash. We called and said we did not get the sauces we payed extra for. They said its doordashs fault. Mind you it said on the box that we got 10 garlic sauces. So we went to this location which we ordered from and they refused to give us what we ordered. After arguing and one manager/employee raising their voice, I even offered to pay again for the sauces that we did not get the first time. The employees and manager(s) are extremely rude and petty. Not to mention that they can hardly function at a fast food chain. Its ridiculous. The manager even asked one of the employees to give us the sauces we ordered and he still refused to give us the sauce. Seems crazy all over some sauces but they took it to a level where it was not needed. Eventually we got the sauces for free after the manager came back out and told this kid to give us what she told him to. He was just really rude and unprofessional. Should be fired.

Service: 1

Rikki Danz

Papa John's hands down is the BEST pizza around town!! Thank

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Corinthian Taylor Mason

Whoever was working tonight did a great job.

Food: 5

Bob Minnich

We had a delivery done at our job and were busy when they delivered so they sat it on our desk and headed out. When we went to eat we found that they brought regular sodas instead of diet. We cannot have regular because of the sugar. Called and asked them to bring two of the right sodas down and the manager flat out refused. After a bit of a discussion he hung up on us. We called him back and again he refused to fix it and hung up on us again. There was no abusive yelling or anything but just frustration from us. He said his delivery guy was too busy even though we were less than a quarter mile from the store. He started giving us the corporate number and I asked him if he was really going to do this for something so little. He hung up again. This far from the first time we placed an order with this store but it sure may be the last.

Mike Culbert

The ladies there were so rude that I had to cancel my order which I paid 56 dollars for. I don't like dominos but I will be liking them tonight.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lucy Citro

Excellent pizza

Loading...