This was our first time trying Pie in Sky upon google reviews. I was skeptical and concerned since a number of the reviews on other platforms said that the food was not cooked fully and items were soggy. However, my boyfriend kept saying “it’s likely a spoof, one time thing. When I order, I’ll let them know to cook our pizza a little longer just in case.”We just picked up both pizzas, wings, and fries and I’m appalled by what we got. Our pizzas are not done and ,by not done, I mean there is soft dough in the middle that is not cooked at all!My boyfriend, who is a foodie and way more forgiving than I am, even went and said “I can’t eat this either. Let’s see if we can cook them further in the oven.”Currently, we are cooking both pizzas in the oven. If I wanted to cook my own food, I would have cooked at home.The fries are in the air fryer as they were also not cooked, not seasoned, and tasted like frozen cardboard.The wings we are debating throwing out as they are still pink/raw in the middle.I understand that sometimes things are a little “under done” but this is bad on all levels where nothing was cooked even remotely close to being done.I’m only eating 3 stars for atmosphere and service since my boyfriend relayed everyone was nice and it seemed like a fairly good establishment.I wish I could say we will try them again but this was incredibly disappointing on all fronts with the food that there is nothing redeeming to bring us back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Shamaica
My order of the shrimp basket was horrible my fries were still frozen and the shrimp was over cooked that I could barely bite it without thinking I was going to break a tooth I would of returned my food but by the time I got it home the place was closed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
ZAIDA TORRES
Food is very good and good
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Sicilian Pizza
dorkii
Their Strombolis are massive. Really good and shareable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Special Stromboli
Robin Welsh
Family favorite for years. Great food and the entire staff is always going above and beyond to make it a memorable experience for my kids!!!Kid-friendliness: Owner has a kid friendly attitude that makes this place a family favorite!
Great food. I mean… GREAT.Staff is very nice. Had our order done quickly and cooked perfectly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine Peterman
Order here for the very first time traveling around lancaster and was lucky to come upon this great Italian restaurant! We ordered pizza and a calzon it was amazing, so delicious it's a good distance away but so worth it❣️❣️Best Pizza I have had here in PA and I have been here since 1972❣️ Looking forward to trying many more delicious foods they prepare! Hoping they make a true antipasta salad have not had a good one since leaving New York other then making my own?❤️❣️Vegetarian options: Had Vegetable Pizza was Superb❣️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
YVETTE FLORES
The meat lovers deep dish is so good they never
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cary Ressler
What can I say that most others already know. We do order take out from time to time when we're in the area,delicious!! Thank you till next time take care.
This was our first time trying Pie in Sky upon google reviews. I was skeptical and concerned since a number of the reviews on other platforms said that the food was not cooked fully and items were soggy. However, my boyfriend kept saying “it’s likely a spoof, one time thing. When I order, I’ll let them know to cook our pizza a little longer just in case.”We just picked up both pizzas, wings, and fries and I’m appalled by what we got. Our pizzas are not done and ,by not done, I mean there is soft dough in the middle that is not cooked at all!My boyfriend, who is a foodie and way more forgiving than I am, even went and said “I can’t eat this either. Let’s see if we can cook them further in the oven.”Currently, we are cooking both pizzas in the oven. If I wanted to cook my own food, I would have cooked at home.The fries are in the air fryer as they were also not cooked, not seasoned, and tasted like frozen cardboard.The wings we are debating throwing out as they are still pink/raw in the middle.I understand that sometimes things are a little “under done” but this is bad on all levels where nothing was cooked even remotely close to being done.I’m only eating 3 stars for atmosphere and service since my boyfriend relayed everyone was nice and it seemed like a fairly good establishment.I wish I could say we will try them again but this was incredibly disappointing on all fronts with the food that there is nothing redeeming to bring us back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
My order of the shrimp basket was horrible my fries were still frozen and the shrimp was over cooked that I could barely bite it without thinking I was going to break a tooth I would of returned my food but by the time I got it home the place was closed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Food is very good and good
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Sicilian Pizza
Their Strombolis are massive. Really good and shareable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Special Stromboli
Family favorite for years. Great food and the entire staff is always going above and beyond to make it a memorable experience for my kids!!!Kid-friendliness: Owner has a kid friendly attitude that makes this place a family favorite!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Sticks, Meat Lovers, Cheese Fries, Cheeseburger Sub, Cheesesteak Sandwich, Pepperoni Pizza, Special Stromboli
Excellent find, wonderful food!!! Especially for takeout...? ?? ? ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
Great pizza and fries..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food best pizza in my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food great customer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garlic knots were delicious and the cheese square pizza is HUGE!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food. I mean… GREAT.Staff is very nice. Had our order done quickly and cooked perfectly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Order here for the very first time traveling around lancaster and was lucky to come upon this great Italian restaurant! We ordered pizza and a calzon it was amazing, so delicious it's a good distance away but so worth it❣️❣️Best Pizza I have had here in PA and I have been here since 1972❣️ Looking forward to trying many more delicious foods they prepare! Hoping they make a true antipasta salad have not had a good one since leaving New York other then making my own?❤️❣️Vegetarian options: Had Vegetable Pizza was Superb❣️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
The meat lovers deep dish is so good they never
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
What can I say that most others already know. We do order take out from time to time when we're in the area,delicious!! Thank you till next time take care.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Chef Salad, Buffalo Chicken, Sausage, Sicilian Pizza, Cheesesteak Sandwich, Pepperoni Pizza
We love their pizza especially with sausage which is SLICED!!!!! Sooo much better than ground pieces!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Sicilian Pizza