I love this place top to bottom. The menu is so amazing. Andrew is especially an incredible waiter. So attentive and kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine Kulp
My sister and I stumbled on this place accidentally and we were so happy we did! The atmosphere was warm and cozy, our server Zoey was so amazing and the food was phenomenal. We live in Maryland but I would make the drive again to go here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla Kolb
My boyfriend and I LOVE Plough! He made a reservation for us for Valentine’s Day. The lady he spoke to (Barbara) told us we’d have a booth that was by the kitchen. Which was perfect because that’s where we usually sit. We got to Plough 10 minutes before our 6:30pm reservation and the hostess was about to seat us in the booth we were promised. Barbara came up to the hostess and told her not to sit us there because it was double booked. The couple she did seat there came in AFTER us, so that was very frustrating since we arrived first and it was the booth we were promised. She then tried to sit us in the bar area by the door which was not what we wanted. My boyfriend went up to her and asked if she could sit us somewhere else, preferably a booth (what she promised us on the phone). Barbara rudely said “well, i could’ve fixed this 5 minutes ago if you would’ve said something” she then sat us at a very small table crammed behind the hostess stand. We still weren’t happy with how she handled the situation and were not happy with where she sat us, especially since she promised us a nicer table. Luckily, our server Jack was AMAZING and provided outstanding service! Best server we’ve had at Plough! As we were leaving Barbara looked at us and didn’t even say bye or thank us for coming in. Coming from someone that also works customer service. She was very rude and unprofessional and unfortunately that’s why I had to leave a bad review.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Nathaniel Youndt
Unfortunately two poor experiences here. The first time we tried to get dinner but the waiter forgot us many times. And then we were advised by another waiter to hurry up with our order because a large party was coming in, even though our waiter was no-showing. Second visit was at the bar where four of us paid far too much for very mediocre drinks. $20 for a boring old fashioned and a “specialty” drink made of 95% ice. Likely won’t be giving them a third try at this point…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Eric Rotenberry
This was our second attempt at Plough. After saying that we would never return because of our horrible experience the first time. The first time my wife found a very long hair wrapped around her food. The manager came by and apologized and we waited 20 minutes while they remade her entrée. No attempt to make it right, or offer to take it off the check. This time we had oyster Rockefeller and some were over cooked while some were still raw. The charcuterie tray had still frozen just barely thawed out prosciutto on it. It’s hard to believe that this is in a Marriott. Too pretentious. Too expensive. Over all very underwhelming Will never return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Michelle
Amazing bar tenders and servers! They accommodated a large cheer competition group effortlessly.
Aimee
What a gem! My husband and I had tickets for a show at the American music theater at 7:30pm. When looking for dinner to make a reservation at 9 o'clock, we were lucky enough to find Plough. Barb went out of her way to make sure that we were accommodated when we could make it. We ordered our dinner ahead of time and everything came out in a timely manner, not rushed, and the food was unbelievable! Outstanding service, above and beyond- whole experience was wonderful! We were so happy to be there and look forward to being back again soon! One of the best meals we've ever had! Thank you so much Barb and the staff at Plough! We appreciate you!
Maggie
Excellent food and easily accommodated our party of 8 with a baby for Saturday lunch. Stewart was an excellent server. Will definitely return!
Deana
As always, we had a great experience dining in ploughfor lunch! The food was absolutely delicious and our service was exceptional!
KEDines
Plough just keeps getter better and better! We had an excellent dinner last night, sampling several items that we hadn't seen before. The Squash/Kale pasta, Hamhocks with mac and cheese, and pear/kale salad were all excellent. We also enjoyed a tasty mocktail before the meal - there are now three on the bar menu. And our waitress was great. We'll be back!
We had the best lunch, with great company. I highly recommend, brussels sprouts, and the feta appetizer. The grilled cheese was amazing. I would love to come back and visit again someday. 
Dennis
Excellent food, drinks and service. One of our favorite spots in Lancaster. Always a great time!
Jerry
Great place and great food. We were there as a family of four and all of us enjoyed our appetizers and entrees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tanasha Hawkins
Wonderful service! Our waiter was incredibly kind, and the atmosphere was perfect. My only complaint was the limited food options. I had wanted the beef stroganoff, but they were sold out—which was understandable since it was New Year’s Eve. I ended up ordering a burger; it was decent, though I’ve had better burgers at Five Guys for less. However, the banana bread was amazing—honestly one of the best things I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jessica Butler
From start to finish this place was a gem! The hostess was kind and got us seated quickly, Daniel was so helpful in getting us situated and our server Andrew was like part of the family! The food was to die for and it's definitely an experience I'd recommend to anyone in the area!
I love this place top to bottom. The menu is so amazing.
Andrew is especially an incredible waiter. So attentive and kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My sister and I stumbled on this place accidentally and we were so happy we did! The atmosphere was warm and cozy, our server Zoey was so amazing and the food was phenomenal. We live in Maryland but I would make the drive again to go here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My boyfriend and I LOVE Plough! He made a reservation for us for Valentine’s Day. The lady he spoke to (Barbara) told us we’d have a booth that was by the kitchen. Which was perfect because that’s where we usually sit. We got to Plough 10 minutes before our 6:30pm reservation and the hostess was about to seat us in the booth we were promised. Barbara came up to the hostess and told her not to sit us there because it was double booked. The couple she did seat there came in AFTER us, so that was very frustrating since we arrived first and it was the booth we were promised. She then tried to sit us in the bar area by the door which was not what we wanted. My boyfriend went up to her and asked if she could sit us somewhere else, preferably a booth (what she promised us on the phone). Barbara rudely said “well, i could’ve fixed this 5 minutes ago if you would’ve said something” she then sat us at a very small table crammed behind the hostess stand. We still weren’t happy with how she handled the situation and were not happy with where she sat us, especially since she promised us a nicer table. Luckily, our server Jack was AMAZING and provided outstanding service! Best server we’ve had at Plough! As we were leaving Barbara looked at us and didn’t even say bye or thank us for coming in. Coming from someone that also works customer service. She was very rude and unprofessional and unfortunately that’s why I had to leave a bad review.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Unfortunately two poor experiences here. The first time we tried to get dinner but the waiter forgot us many times. And then we were advised by another waiter to hurry up with our order because a large party was coming in, even though our waiter was no-showing. Second visit was at the bar where four of us paid far too much for very mediocre drinks. $20 for a boring old fashioned and a “specialty” drink made of 95% ice. Likely won’t be giving them a third try at this point…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
This was our second attempt at Plough. After saying that we would never return because of our horrible experience the first time.
The first time my wife found a very long hair wrapped around her food. The manager came by and apologized and we waited 20 minutes while they remade her entrée. No attempt to make it right, or offer to take it off the check.
This time we had oyster Rockefeller and some were over cooked while some were still raw. The charcuterie tray had still frozen just barely thawed out prosciutto on it.
It’s hard to believe that this is in a Marriott.
Too pretentious.
Too expensive.
Over all very underwhelming
Will never return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Amazing bar tenders and servers! They accommodated a large cheer competition group effortlessly.
What a gem! My husband and I had tickets for a show at the American music theater at 7:30pm. When looking for dinner to make a reservation at 9 o'clock, we were lucky enough to find Plough. Barb went out of her way to make sure that we were accommodated when we could make it. We ordered our dinner ahead of time and everything came out in a timely manner, not rushed, and the food was unbelievable! Outstanding service, above and beyond- whole experience was wonderful! We were so happy to be there and look forward to being back again soon! One of the best meals we've ever had! Thank you so much Barb and the staff at Plough! We appreciate you!
Excellent food and easily accommodated our party of 8 with a baby for Saturday lunch. Stewart was an excellent server. Will definitely return!
As always, we had a great experience dining in ploughfor lunch! The food was absolutely delicious and our service was exceptional!
Plough just keeps getter better and better! We had an excellent dinner last night, sampling several items that we hadn't seen before. The Squash/Kale pasta, Hamhocks with mac and cheese, and pear/kale salad were all excellent. We also enjoyed a tasty mocktail before the meal - there are now three on the bar menu. And our waitress was great. We'll be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
We had the best lunch, with great company. I highly recommend, brussels sprouts, and the feta appetizer. The grilled cheese was amazing. I would love to come back and visit again someday. 
Excellent food, drinks and service. One of our favorite spots in Lancaster. Always a great time!
Great place and great food. We were there as a family of four and all of us enjoyed our appetizers and entrees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful service! Our waiter was incredibly kind, and the atmosphere was perfect. My only complaint was the limited food options. I had wanted the beef stroganoff, but they were sold out—which was understandable since it was New Year’s Eve. I ended up ordering a burger; it was decent, though I’ve had better burgers at Five Guys for less. However, the banana bread was amazing—honestly one of the best things I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
From start to finish this place was a gem! The hostess was kind and got us seated quickly, Daniel was so helpful in getting us situated and our server Andrew was like part of the family! The food was to die for and it's definitely an experience I'd recommend to anyone in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...