Sugarplums and Teas

403 Bank Barn Ln, Lancaster
(717) 394-9166

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Emily Manns

Food and tea were exceptional!! Atmosphere was very cute.

Doreen Stickney

Quaint. Beautiful area & facility. Menu was a bit diverse, but delicious!

Dara B

Loved this shop! Can't wait to go back! So many different teas, great variety! Friendly staff!

Traecy Pierson

I'm starting this review with one of my favorite quotes: "If you have no expectations, you'll have no disappointments." The menu advertised the tea as "high tea." Historically, high tea is not a fancy affair, and there was indeed a twist to this experience. My server, Mya, was lovely and quite attentive, but I have to deduct one star due to the long wait for the tiered food presentation after receiving the tea. By the time the food arrived, I was more than halfway through my pot of tea. In fact, I had finished the pot before even starting on the sweets.While the food was decent overall, I must mention that the meatball marinara soup was overly salty. On the positive side, the environment was charming, the staff was friendly, and the food was enjoyable, albeit with some quirks.For those accustomed to traditional afternoon teas, be prepared for some surprises. For example, you might encounter mozzarella sticks, scones served without clotted cream or lemon curd, and open-faced sandwiches instead of the usual fare.  All in all, I would likely return.

Maggie Reinhart

One of Lancaster’s hidden gems. The tea and food is absolutely delicious. The atmosphere is quaint and very homey. I highly recommend the raspberry mint tea and the Turkey Brie sandwich. The staff is very friendly and attentive.

Yvonne Kozlowski

The tea selection is amazing. Did the high tea and the food was excellent.

Alexandra Nusawardhana

The pumpkin quiche was delicious! The tea was good too but wish we could get the tea flight to try a variety of different teas, not just the specific few on their list

Rae V

A darling little spot hidden away! If you enjoy cute environment, delicious food, and personal teapots, this is the place for you! Went with a girl friend of mine and enjoyed ourselves immensely!

Elizabeth P

Beautiful place to visit with friends and family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Three Tiered High Tea Includes

Elaine Ryan

I went to high tea with 2 other ladies today10/19/2024. We all thought the same thing, "WE WILL NOT BE BACK" The bread on our tea sandwiches we're dry, the toast on one of our sandwiches was very crispy almost burnt. Soup was salty. The scone choice wasn't pleasing, it sounded spicy.

Sharon Christ

Went for tea and lunch. Very reasonable prices. Wonderful experience and great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Rodriguez

What is sweet and quaint beautiful place in a lovely neighborhood. For a bridal shower, we had a beautiful room, the service was lovely, and the food was delicious. It's definitely a tea shop! Perfect for the occasion & wonderful for making memories.

Parking: There's a parking lot in plenty of parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Green Salad, Three Tiered High Tea Includes, Assorted Desserts, Tea Tower

Dennis Voulopos

Absolutely lovely place to have an afternoon tea party birthday. The tea is wonderful and the food was quite tasty

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vickie D T

1st time visiting and it was truly memorable.
Enjoyed the place very much. Food is good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Three Tiered High Tea Includes

Kamal Elliot

Had a lovely high tea in the library to celebrate a baby sprinkle. It was a great experience. Can't wait to go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...