Sugarplums and Teas

403 Bank Barn Ln, Lancaster
(717) 394-9166

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Elaine Schatz

The place is beautiful It was very homey very comfortable, they were right there catering to us. The tea was excellent I don't know what else to say then I wish I had a little spot like this in my own little house.

Amanda Estabrook

We visited this shop yesterday and brought my two daughters and my oldest daughters (she is 12) three friends for her birthday. They ordered the kids high tea and my mother and I ordered an adult high tea. We enjoyed ours very much.. The kids had mixed reviews on the food but that’s to be expected. My complaint wasn’t with the food, but the woman who brought it out from the kitchen. She was callous and borderline rude towards the girls on multiple occasions. The waitress however was very kind. The mosquitos outside were like nothing I’ve ever seen and I’m from the country.. There is a pond of standing water (a decorative piece of sorts) and I think that’s where they are coming from but when we were outside there was an actual swarm of mosquitos around us all.. All the girls and myself got bit more than ten times each. We won’t be back.. We will continue to try other tea houses that have polite kitchen staff but that’s not to say it was all a wash.

Hannah Shannon

Had my bridal shower here. It was perfect and beautiful. Thank you to the staff for making it possible.

Sharon Powell

Went here with my sister and my niece and we had an amazing time the food was great. The tea was awesome. The little tea pots they give you are so adorable. Everything was great. Had a lot of fun. Thank you.

Evelyn Velez

Great atmosphere, teas and food. Loved this place. Hope to be back

Melissa O'Neil

Always great! Highly recommend high tea!

Kat St

I had the high tea. It ncluded a tasty non traditional black bean and corn soup. It wasn’t what I usually see in a black bean. It was clear soup with black bean, corn and a vegetable broth. Worth tasting . The sandwiches tomato ( was like a small piece of pizza - ok), a roll up turkey that was great, hummus sandwich- good, and chicken salad- delish. The scone came with the soup and it was savory& soft but good. I still missed my regular scone and cream. It also came with dessert lemon bar, choc cream candy. This place sits inside a quiet community. There are shops nearby -many of them. Took me a bit of time to get here but it was worth it. I got a scone and cream to go. Because if you go to tea, you get a scone.

Ida Gehman

Lovely place to go for high tea! Food was good and the setting was lovely!

Tanya Kitchen

Love it here, we have been going for the last 4 years for my daughters birthday. Special hidden gem, perfect to split or eat a meal. Choose your tea flavor and get ready for delicious food.

Cindy Nell Knaub

We hosted a bridal shower at Sugarplums and Tea, and had a wonderful experience! Delicious tea and food, great service, fun decor, easy to work with, and exceeded our expectations. Plan on going again for lunch sometime in the future.

Nancy Ludwick

Food and service excellent. Elegant experience.

Linda Flegal

Lovely spot for afternoon tea. We took my Mum for special Princess High Tea ☕️, it was charming. Delightful atmosphere, a pleasant array of nibbles, large selection of teas and at a decent price too! We enjoyed the afternoon. If you’re planning to go, make a reservation well in advance, they are popular !

J Sensenig

A unique tea experience! With 20 varieties of tea, you are sure to find something you like! We enjoyed the many options on the high tea menu. The children's menu had a child friendly high tea, too. My daughter's and granddaughters had an enjoyable experience!

Valerie Joz

It was nice. We took my Mom there for her Birthday. They gave her a bite sized dessert with a candle...was so nice and cute. We ordered 1 of the 3 tiered tea services. Was a bit disappointed. The top had about 3 or 4 spoonfuls of ice cold soup, the middle tier had a toothpick with a cube of cheese, an olive and a piece of salami, a sandwich bite, then the bottom tier had 3 tiny bites of a scone. It tasted ok but for $25, I expected a lot more. Or at least the plates not to look so empty upon serving. Not sure what $25 was for. The bacon chicken wrap was good. The teas were delicious.

Linda Fox

Got together with some friends from high school. Loved the beautiful setting with the spring blooms. Also enjoyed our lunch selections.

Loading...