Out of every bakery in Lancaster County, Wish You Well has: The best bagels and bialys; the best breakfast and lunch; the best baked goods and sweet treats; and the best vibes. So, basically, it's the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samantha Bare
Best bakery in Lancaster city, hands down. Incredible bagels and breakfast sandwiches along with inventive treats and desserts. Tons of solid standbys along with rotating new ideas which keeps it exciting to go back again and again.Everything is done with passion behind it. Cute little space to sit and eat, very kind owners and staff. Can’t recommend enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pablo
Delicious and well priced. Croque monsieur croissant was insanely delicious. So was the shakshuka bialy. No espresso machine but they must use a really nice roast for their drip coffee because it was also delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bialys, Brown Butter Snickerdoodles
Ed Kaminski
Loved everything! The exceptional details- Ruth Bagel Ginsberg - pickled red onions and dressed greens with just the right acid - delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Uzair A.
Absolute gem in Lancaster - what an exquisite find! Would give this more than 5 stars if I could. Excellent bakery items, fantastic variety of selection, and the staff was so helpful and friendly! We had a croissant with smoked salmon and cream cheese (utterly delightful), shakshuka bialy (creative take on the Mediterranean favorite), chocolate chip cookies (chewy and delicious) and drip coffee (which was strong). Thrilled to find this cute place, and we can't wait to be back!
rachel nelson
This bakery doesn’t get the hype it deserves!!!!!I am so in love with this place for so many reasons. Every item they make is delicious and full of love, and they offer things that stand out from the same bakery staples that you see everywhere. You can taste that they care about ingredients, quality, and flavor. I have my go-to’s of course, but there’s always something new to try!! I didn’t know what a Bialy was until I tried one here and they are so yummy! Today they were out, but there was one slice of French onion focaccia left (same dough as the bialy) and I got some tomato soup as well…they were such a good pair omgggg!! The most comforting bite on chilly day.Wish you well, don’t stop doing what you’re doing<3Kid-friendliness: Such a friendly environment! It’s not an overstimulation station lol. Not a lot for kiddos to run into, grab, knock over or reach for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Quart of Tomato Soup V, Hand Pies, Bialys
Michael Thompson
Food very tasty! Prices are decent. Nice & Clean. Customer service was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin S.
A lot of bakeries in Amish country.... However these were some of the best baked goods we have ever had in Lancaster. It's clear the owners take a lot of pride in what they are making and selling. Highly recommend the Shaksuka, and the maple French toast bread pudding, but only because that's all that we tried! Thanks for the amazing food Megan and partner!
Rocio Rodriguez
Fantastic place. I would eat there every day if they were open ?almond croissant was the best ❤️
Brett Vogel
Wow! Best breakfast bagel sandwich I have had in a long time. Maybe best one ever. So good!
I got the 4 pack of chocolate chip cookies and they were absolutely delicious. Looking forward to going back and trying more food
Olivia R
Amazing! I had the best quiche of my life from here. Definitely will be ordering from here again.
Chloe Keller
Our favorite place to get breakfast on a Saturday morning! Right by market and you can usually find parking if you’re early enough. I recommend the RBG on a Hannah Montana bagel.. it will NOT dissapoint!
Philip C.
We visited from out of town and my wife found this bakery. I had an egg and bacon sandwich on a Hannah Montana bagel. It was fantastic. My wife and daughter loved their sandwiches so much that we ended up buying an apple pie turnover, and churro pastry, and a bread pudding piece. They also had great vegetarian and vegan alternatives. i had bacon for the first time in over a year and it was worth it. It was all great and I will make it a mission to come back when in the area.
Morgan H.
Love the location of this bakery, love their creativity and level of quality ingredients, and holy cow does the stuff taste good. I'm gluten/sugar intolerant so I have suffered eating their food, and it was worth it. Would recommend to those that are able to enjoy such delectables.
Out of every bakery in Lancaster County, Wish You Well has: The best bagels and bialys; the best breakfast and lunch; the best baked goods and sweet treats; and the best vibes. So, basically, it's the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best bakery in Lancaster city, hands down. Incredible bagels and breakfast sandwiches along with inventive treats and desserts. Tons of solid standbys along with rotating new ideas which keeps it exciting to go back again and again.Everything is done with passion behind it. Cute little space to sit and eat, very kind owners and staff. Can’t recommend enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious and well priced. Croque monsieur croissant was insanely delicious. So was the shakshuka bialy. No espresso machine but they must use a really nice roast for their drip coffee because it was also delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bialys, Brown Butter Snickerdoodles
Loved everything! The exceptional details- Ruth Bagel Ginsberg - pickled red onions and dressed greens with just the right acid - delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolute gem in Lancaster - what an exquisite find! Would give this more than 5 stars if I could. Excellent bakery items, fantastic variety of selection, and the staff was so helpful and friendly! We had a croissant with smoked salmon and cream cheese (utterly delightful), shakshuka bialy (creative take on the Mediterranean favorite), chocolate chip cookies (chewy and delicious) and drip coffee (which was strong). Thrilled to find this cute place, and we can't wait to be back!
This bakery doesn’t get the hype it deserves!!!!!I am so in love with this place for so many reasons. Every item they make is delicious and full of love, and they offer things that stand out from the same bakery staples that you see everywhere. You can taste that they care about ingredients, quality, and flavor. I have my go-to’s of course, but there’s always something new to try!! I didn’t know what a Bialy was until I tried one here and they are so yummy! Today they were out, but there was one slice of French onion focaccia left (same dough as the bialy) and I got some tomato soup as well…they were such a good pair omgggg!! The most comforting bite on chilly day.Wish you well, don’t stop doing what you’re doing<3Kid-friendliness: Such a friendly environment! It’s not an overstimulation station lol. Not a lot for kiddos to run into, grab, knock over or reach for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Quart of Tomato Soup V, Hand Pies, Bialys
Food very tasty! Prices are decent. Nice & Clean. Customer service was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A lot of bakeries in Amish country.... However these were some of the best baked goods we have ever had in Lancaster. It's clear the owners take a lot of pride in what they are making and selling. Highly recommend the Shaksuka, and the maple French toast bread pudding, but only because that's all that we tried! Thanks for the amazing food Megan and partner!
Fantastic place. I would eat there every day if they were open ?almond croissant was the best ❤️
Wow! Best breakfast bagel sandwich I have had in a long time. Maybe best one ever. So good!
Restaurantji Recommends
I got the 4 pack of chocolate chip cookies and they were absolutely delicious. Looking forward to going back and trying more food
Amazing! I had the best quiche of my life from here. Definitely will be ordering from here again.
Our favorite place to get breakfast on a Saturday morning! Right by market and you can usually find parking if you’re early enough. I recommend the RBG on a Hannah Montana bagel.. it will NOT dissapoint!
We visited from out of town and my wife found this bakery. I had an egg and bacon sandwich on a Hannah Montana bagel. It was fantastic. My wife and daughter loved their sandwiches so much that we ended up buying an apple pie turnover, and churro pastry, and a bread pudding piece. They also had great vegetarian and vegan alternatives. i had bacon for the first time in over a year and it was worth it. It was all great and I will make it a mission to come back when in the area.
Love the location of this bakery, love their creativity and level of quality ingredients, and holy cow does the stuff taste good. I'm gluten/sugar intolerant so I have suffered eating their food, and it was worth it. Would recommend to those that are able to enjoy such delectables.