Byers Butterflake Bakery

44 W Main St, Leola
(717) 656-6803

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brian Schreckengast

Wonderful bakery! Cake, cookies, pies, doughnuts, tarts, elcairs, creme puffs...we've had them all for ourselves and family who visits from out of town. Everyone always says how delicious

Tara Cahill

Beautiful White Rhapsody Birthday cake! The colors and the glitter were so pretty! The raspberry mousse and raspberry marmalade are like clouds of heaven. First cake from here and would definitely order from them again. Prices are reasonable as well. Thank you!

Alex Muturi

Was looking for a cake on July 3rd for a graduation party on the 4th. Every other bakery shops had nothing to offer, called Byers and they were like 'come to the shop we'll fix you something'..... and they did! The cake was great at a very reasonable price. Their shop is clean and customer service is top notch. Byers is my new cake shop now!

A B

Top notch quality for a great price. Tried the competition and they just don't stack up to the quality of byers. The graphics and looks of the cakes I've gotten for my kids actually exceeded my expectations. You won't be disappointed.

Richard Peters

I made the mistake of buying a woopie pie and a vanilla cream filled doughnut from this bakery on Tuesday. The person behind the counter was very friendly but the woopie pie was dried out and way too sweet and the doughnut was a little dry and again way too sweet. I am from Lancaster and usually buy my sweets from another baker but decided to give this one a try. Big mistake and I will never buy from them again. I'll go back to Bird-in-Hand Bakery.

Reva H

This is an upscale Bakery. They have specialty cakes, including wedding cakes, that are so delicious, have unique flavors and fillings. And of course they have the usual bakery items such as cupcakes and muffins.

faith traylor

Amazing cakes! Great flavors, very delicious!

Phil Rebman

Best bakery by far. Incredable Orange Cake, Glazed, filled fresh Donuts. Great Pumpkin Pie,

Joy Camilari

Red velvet cake with cream cheese icing was beautiful and delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Curran

Amazing bakery, lovely staff!

Rohit Ranjan

I bought tonnes of cookies and eclairs from here for my family for Christmas . Good Bakery . I found the cookies too sweet though .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Michael Boll

It bring me so much joy to stick my teeth into their hot, sticky buns.

Food: 5

Joe Cardone

Out of this

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon Martin

I ordered a cake for a birthday party and was not disappointed! The 12" round cake was HUGE and could definitely serve 35-45 people as stated on their website.
I chose the Peanut Butter Symphony flavor and it was delicious. The combination of chocolate cake and peanut butter mousse was perfect. I can't wait to try some of the other flavors.
The staff were very friendly and even carried the cake out to my car to help me load it (so I wouldn't drop it opening the door).

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marie prinston

I had a sonic cake there for my son birthday. Not only it was delicious, but it was that pretty that I didn't want to cut it. My guests were wowed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...