We couldn’t have asked for a more stunning or delicious wedding cake and cupcakes. Karen nailed every detail—from the dreamy design to the unforgettable flavors. Guests were raving, and we were swooning. Thank you for making our day even sweeter! 🍰💕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peyton Hoover
Karen just absolutely amazed my family with the cake she made for my Grandmothers 71st birthday. She was able to take my ideas and bring them to life. She was so nice to work with, and was able to get the cake order a week from the event. The chocolate cake was the family’s favorite. 10/10 recommend to anyone looking for a customized delicious cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremy Hoffman
Karen made and delivered the 3-tiered cake for our wedding; it was exactly what we imagined! Her work would have been right at home in a magazine or a professional photoshoot - and the cake was absolutely delicious! We opted for multiple different flavors for our cake and every one was absolutely wonderful. We cannot recommend her work enough.
Robyn Shifflett
I get all my cakes done by Karen Rodkey. The cakes are always what I ask for and taste delicious. She always amazes me.,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristen Palmer
Our wedding cake was truly a showstopper! It looked even better than we imagined, and both flavors were incredible. So many of our guests went out of their way to tell us how much they loved it and came back for seconds... not to mention it was all gluten free!!
While communication over email could’ve been a bit more responsive, and a small design detail (sparkle sugar) was missed, the overall result was fabulous and delicious. The quality and beauty of the cake far outweighed those minor issues, and we’d absolutely recommend her to any couple looking for a cake that wows!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Sarah Biser
I think this was the best cake I’ve ever tasted. Karen made an incredible cake for my mom’s birthday! We all raved over it and my sister is even considering ordering her wedding cake from her. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Dana Baird
I'm thrilled to share my exceptional experience with Karen Rodkey Cakes! Karen's creations are truly masterpieces - not only are they visually stunning, but they're also incredibly delicious. The attention to detail, the precision, and the love that goes into each and every cake is evident in every bite.
I had the pleasure of working with Karen for my wedding, and from the initial consultation to the final product, the experience was nothing short of exceptional. Karen's passion for her craft is contagious, and her enthusiasm is inspiring. She listened to my vision, offered expert guidance, and brought my dreams to life in the most spectacular way.
The cake itself was moist, flavorful, and utterly divine. The design was exquisite, with intricate details and flawless execution. It was truly a work of art that left my guests in awe. But what really sets Karen apart is her kindness, warmth, and dedication to her clients. She's more than just a talented baker - she's a true artist, a perfectionist, and a master of her craft.
If you're looking for a cake that will leave a lasting impression, look no further than Karen Rodkey Cakes. Karen's creations are truly unforgettable, and her exceptional service, attention to detail, and passion for her craft make her the ultimate choice for any occasion!
Hillary A
We love Karen’s cakes!! We get one every year for our anniversary
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
Tarana Rahimi
Karen makes the best cakes. I have ordered a Father's Day Cake for the last two years. I catered a wedding and Karen made one of the cakes. I had a piece of the Carrot Cake and it was the best I ever had (I am not even a fan of carrot cake). I had to track this baker. I looked up bakeries in PA and searched FB, hoping the baker posted the cake from that wedding. No luck. I was driving passed the house months later and decided to knock on the door. The mother of the bride answered. I told her I was with the catering company and if she give me the baker's info. She thought that me stopping by was great and loved my story. She gave me Karen's info and the funny thing is I did come across her page in my search. Karen is very talented and I swear you will dream about how delicious her cakes are. I love the inside of her bakery.
Betsy
I ordered a cake for my daughter’s 16th birthday. It was perfect. It was almost too pretty to eat. Cake was moist and delicious.
Very delicious cupcakes and great cake! Great pricing as well. We loved working with Karen and we recommend her to anyone needing yummy desserts :)
Katlin Thayer
Outstanding cakes! We originally weren’t going to have a wedding cake but ended up trying Karen’s cake at a bridal convention. It was so good we ended up purchasing a bridal shower cake, wedding cake and grooms cake! As delicious as they are beautiful!
Jason Shorb
We keep getting cakes from here and they are always perfect.
Tarana Rahimi
Karen makes the best cakes!
Mark Olson
Karen was fantastic to work with for our wedding reception! She was the only baker we ended up meeting with—after we sat down with her we felt we didn’t need to keep looking. She made everything very easy, letting us taste several samples and even sending a few cakes home with us, and providing delivery to our wedding reception venue.One of the stipulations was finding someone with gluten-free options as my wife is gluten-free. Karen let us sample some gluten-free flavors and they were delicious. We ended up going with a 2-tiered GF cake and “regular” cupcakes in various flavors. Everything was amazing. I have fairly high standards when it comes to baked goods and Karen met my expectations and then some. She also got rave reviews from a few friends I talked to who were at the reception and had the cake and cupcakes.I highly recommend Karen to provide a cake for your wedding reception or other event.
We couldn’t have asked for a more stunning or delicious wedding cake and cupcakes. Karen nailed every detail—from the dreamy design to the unforgettable flavors. Guests were raving, and we were swooning. Thank you for making our day even sweeter! 🍰💕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen just absolutely amazed my family with the cake she made for my Grandmothers 71st birthday. She was able to take my ideas and bring them to life. She was so nice to work with, and was able to get the cake order a week from the event. The chocolate cake was the family’s favorite. 10/10 recommend to anyone looking for a customized delicious cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen made and delivered the 3-tiered cake for our wedding; it was exactly what we imagined! Her work would have been right at home in a magazine or a professional photoshoot - and the cake was absolutely delicious! We opted for multiple different flavors for our cake and every one was absolutely wonderful. We cannot recommend her work enough.
I get all my cakes done by Karen Rodkey. The cakes are always what I ask for and taste delicious. She always amazes me.,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our wedding cake was truly a showstopper! It looked even better than we imagined, and both flavors were incredible. So many of our guests went out of their way to tell us how much they loved it and came back for seconds... not to mention it was all gluten free!!
While communication over email could’ve been a bit more responsive, and a small design detail (sparkle sugar) was missed, the overall result was fabulous and delicious. The quality and beauty of the cake far outweighed those minor issues, and we’d absolutely recommend her to any couple looking for a cake that wows!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
I think this was the best cake I’ve ever tasted. Karen made an incredible cake for my mom’s birthday! We all raved over it and my sister is even considering ordering her wedding cake from her. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
I'm thrilled to share my exceptional experience with Karen Rodkey Cakes! Karen's creations are truly masterpieces - not only are they visually stunning, but they're also incredibly delicious. The attention to detail, the precision, and the love that goes into each and every cake is evident in every bite.
I had the pleasure of working with Karen for my wedding, and from the initial consultation to the final product, the experience was nothing short of exceptional. Karen's passion for her craft is contagious, and her enthusiasm is inspiring. She listened to my vision, offered expert guidance, and brought my dreams to life in the most spectacular way.
The cake itself was moist, flavorful, and utterly divine. The design was exquisite, with intricate details and flawless execution. It was truly a work of art that left my guests in awe. But what really sets Karen apart is her kindness, warmth, and dedication to her clients. She's more than just a talented baker - she's a true artist, a perfectionist, and a master of her craft.
If you're looking for a cake that will leave a lasting impression, look no further than Karen Rodkey Cakes. Karen's creations are truly unforgettable, and her exceptional service, attention to detail, and passion for her craft make her the ultimate choice for any occasion!
We love Karen’s cakes!! We get one every year for our anniversary
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
Karen makes the best cakes. I have ordered a Father's Day Cake for the last two years. I catered a wedding and Karen made one of the cakes. I had a piece of the Carrot Cake and it was the best I ever had (I am not even a fan of carrot cake). I had to track this baker. I looked up bakeries in PA and searched FB, hoping the baker posted the cake from that wedding. No luck. I was driving passed the house months later and decided to knock on the door. The mother of the bride answered. I told her I was with the catering company and if she give me the baker's info. She thought that me stopping by was great and loved my story. She gave me Karen's info and the funny thing is I did come across her page in my search. Karen is very talented and I swear you will dream about how delicious her cakes are. I love the inside of her bakery.
I ordered a cake for my daughter’s 16th birthday. It was perfect. It was almost too pretty to eat. Cake was moist and delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very delicious cupcakes and great cake! Great pricing as well. We loved working with Karen and we recommend her to anyone needing yummy desserts :)
Outstanding cakes! We originally weren’t going to have a wedding cake but ended up trying Karen’s cake at a bridal convention. It was so good we ended up purchasing a bridal shower cake, wedding cake and grooms cake! As delicious as they are beautiful!
We keep getting cakes from here and they are always perfect.
Karen makes the best cakes!
Karen was fantastic to work with for our wedding reception! She was the only baker we ended up meeting with—after we sat down with her we felt we didn’t need to keep looking. She made everything very easy, letting us taste several samples and even sending a few cakes home with us, and providing delivery to our wedding reception venue.One of the stipulations was finding someone with gluten-free options as my wife is gluten-free. Karen let us sample some gluten-free flavors and they were delicious. We ended up going with a 2-tiered GF cake and “regular” cupcakes in various flavors. Everything was amazing. I have fairly high standards when it comes to baked goods and Karen met my expectations and then some. She also got rave reviews from a few friends I talked to who were at the reception and had the cake and cupcakes.I highly recommend Karen to provide a cake for your wedding reception or other event.
Loading...