Tried “the works” pizza and it’s absolutely horrible and soggy
Food: 1
vizio x
Just had your sweet sauce american cheese with onion well done. I wish you were still open as I tried to call back and tell you how awesome it was. It was worth the 116 calls I made to get through the busy signal. We will get another one tomorrow
fastede III52 (UE)
Great Pizza for a great price with great friendly service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dianne DeFrehn
wow the American cheese ..well done crust is legit ! very impressed
Josh Rieder
One of our favorite local options! The drive through is a big plus for pickup orders.
James Yozviak
By far one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, not only that but the customer service is just as amazing! Being in retail/customer service world myself, I really appreciate how much great service means, and these guys nailed it. Highly recommend, time and time again!
Jesicca Skoloda
Shelly’s Pizza is absolutely delicious and easily one of my favorites in the area! Their sweet sauce is amazing and really sets them apart—it keeps me coming back again and again. I also love how convenient their drive-thru process is. The system with the number boards at the rear of the property makes it so easy to know when your pizza is ready, which is such a nice touch. Great food, great service, and a super smooth pickup experience—highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phil Sass
So i was told to try Shelly's. I've had plenty of pizza in this area and from what everyone was saying, I was missing out by not coming here. The Good: The service was spot on. Phone order was easy and the lady at the counter was very friendly. They only do take out and only pizza so the place was busy. I figured i was going to be in for a treat. The Bad: The pizza was sub par. They cut it in like 12 slices, which was weird, but not a deal breaker. Got a large with pepperoni a nd onions. The pizza was cooked fine but it didn't taste good. The cheese tasted funny and even my 2 10 year olds were like we only at it because we were hungry. I'm sorry but for all the hype, it did not meet my expectations. I will not be going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Jonael Gallurdo
The pizza here is excellent, you can really tell the care and quality in every detail. I’ve tried pizza at many places in this area, and this one is a solid 10/10. What impressed me the most is the staff, always polite and friendly, no matter who they are or where they come from; it seems the place has a clear philosophy of training their people to provide an outstanding experience. This isn’t just a place you go to eat; you can feel that everything is done with intention and care. Definitely coming back.!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larrisa
My husband always orders from here never had a problem today we ordered for our kids and found a hair between the cheese called to let them know nothing was done
Pizza was really good but we ordered two pizza over the phone & the guy taking our order confirmed two pizzas. When we got there to pick the pizza up they just gave us one. We asked when the second one would be ready & she said “we’re not making the other one bc we’re closed”. We had to go somewhere else for another pizza & we asked what they would have done in the situation & they said “no question, make another pizza!”
Lsquare
Great pizza Sweet sauce with onions
Girls serving so polite and courteous
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Joshua Becker
Always friendly, love the pizza, tastes the closest to Jersey that we've had out here and prices are excellent. I also like the drive thru.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ronny Haze
MUST HAVE PIZZA if you're anywhere near by! We drive 9hrs once a year to enjoy the local pizza and Shelly's is always a must, especially their pepperoni pizza!! I've been eating here for over 25 yrs (back when they were in the shopping center) and it's been a favorite this whole time!! Never change!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathy M
Pizza is personal. So don't let this be your deciding factor. I ordered a Hawaiian pizza and got canned crushed pineapple on it. Lots, right in the middle. Some may love it, some may not. Easy to order,have only ordered twice and second was pepperoni. Large slices of pepperoni. Thin pizza, was ok but again may be someones thing.
Tried “the works” pizza and it’s absolutely horrible and soggy
Food: 1
Just had your sweet sauce american cheese with onion well done. I wish you were still open as I tried to call back and tell you how awesome it was. It was worth the 116 calls I made to get through the busy signal. We will get another one tomorrow
Great Pizza for a great price with great friendly service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
wow the American cheese ..well done crust is legit ! very impressed
One of our favorite local options! The drive through is a big plus for pickup orders.
By far one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, not only that but the customer service is just as amazing! Being in retail/customer service world myself, I really appreciate how much great service means, and these guys nailed it. Highly recommend, time and time again!
Shelly’s Pizza is absolutely delicious and easily one of my favorites in the area! Their sweet sauce is amazing and really sets them apart—it keeps me coming back again and again. I also love how convenient their drive-thru process is. The system with the number boards at the rear of the property makes it so easy to know when your pizza is ready, which is such a nice touch. Great food, great service, and a super smooth pickup experience—highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So i was told to try Shelly's. I've had plenty of pizza in this area and from what everyone was saying, I was missing out by not coming here.
The Good: The service was spot on. Phone order was easy and the lady at the counter was very friendly. They only do take out and only pizza so the place was busy. I figured i was going to be in for a treat.
The Bad: The pizza was sub par. They cut it in like 12 slices, which was weird, but not a deal breaker. Got a large with pepperoni a
nd onions. The pizza was cooked fine but it didn't taste good. The cheese tasted funny and even my 2 10 year olds were like we only at it because we were hungry.
I'm sorry but for all the hype, it did not meet my expectations.
I will not be going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
The pizza here is excellent, you can really tell the care and quality in every detail. I’ve tried pizza at many places in this area, and this one is a solid 10/10. What impressed me the most is the staff, always polite and friendly, no matter who they are or where they come from; it seems the place has a clear philosophy of training their people to provide an outstanding experience. This isn’t just a place you go to eat; you can feel that everything is done with intention and care. Definitely coming back.!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband always orders from here never had a problem today we ordered for our kids and found a hair between the cheese called to let them know nothing was done
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was really good but we ordered two pizza over the phone & the guy taking our order confirmed two pizzas. When we got there to pick the pizza up they just gave us one. We asked when the second one would be ready & she said “we’re not making the other one bc we’re closed”. We had to go somewhere else for another pizza & we asked what they would have done in the situation & they said “no question, make another pizza!”
Great pizza
Sweet sauce with onions
Girls serving so polite and courteous
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Always friendly, love the pizza, tastes the closest to Jersey that we've had out here and prices are excellent. I also like the drive thru.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MUST HAVE PIZZA if you're anywhere near by! We drive 9hrs once a year to enjoy the local pizza and Shelly's is always a must, especially their pepperoni pizza!! I've been eating here for over 25 yrs (back when they were in the shopping center) and it's been a favorite this whole time!! Never change!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is personal. So don't let this be your deciding factor. I ordered a Hawaiian pizza and got canned crushed pineapple on it. Lots, right in the middle. Some may love it, some may not. Easy to order,have only ordered twice and second was pepperoni. Large slices of pepperoni. Thin pizza, was ok but again may be someones thing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...