Great pizza and calzones. Easy to order from and the food is always ready on time for pick up. Friendly service every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
stranger_thangs
Supremos is our go to delivery service. We are limited on our options for delivery and Supremos has excellent quality food. I’m grateful for your business, thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terri
Loyal customer disappointed this time. My husband and I ordered calzones for a change. We were not a fan. For the price can say we've had better elsewhere. Barely any filling especially cheese.We never had any issues with the pizza here they also nail that!
Food: 2
A.T. Merhaut, Inc.
This is most definitely our favorite pizza in the area. Last time out, I went for a steak hoagie. That was really good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas With
Crystal Cossell
We generally like Supremo's. But they didn't put ranch on the fries we ordered, like the Callery location does. Good thing we ordered an extra bottle of ranch.Also the bottle of ranch wasn't a squirt container like we're used to getting, it was more like a small bottle of Ken's salad dressing. I prefer the squirt bottles for ease of portion control.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Susan Lea Johnson, LPC
I ordered for the first time from Supremo’s and I was so very happy. I ordered. A large Pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, half of an Italian Hoagie and a Steak Salad. The pizza was fabulous, love the sauce and the cheese as well as the crust. I should have ordered a whole Italian because the half was only about 5 inches long. The steak salad was smaller than I expected, but I do know that everything is shrinking in size or becoming more expensive or both. The hoagie and salad were good, but the pizza was my favorite! Food arrived still warm and in a timely manner. I will order from them again for sure!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas With
Mike
Anytime I order pizza it has to be from Supremos. Everything is excellent from the pizzas to the salads and everything in between. Plus, their ranch dressing is the best!
Food: 5
Jessie Lynn
The food is always good. The people in the store are always very nice. The driver was a little rude.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
kez panel
A small pizza and sandwich shop nearby, carry-out only. Great pizza, lots of cheese. Pleasant service. This is my go-to place when I miss supper at home. May I suggest you order tonight.Parking: Plenty of parking, this is take-out only.Wheelchair accessibility: yes, wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizzas With
Daniel Mozer
Great food! We are very fortunate and thankful to have a locally run business that supports their community as much as they do!
This is a carry-out only restaurant. Pizza and subs are pretty good. Great salads. Excellent, prompt, friendly service.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pete Janusz
Just moved in the area. Very good place for pizza! Service is fast and friendly. We always stop by at least once a week for take out!!!
Carles Blanco
So far so good need to make burgers definitely I need BURGERS!!!!Ok I see your answer yes it’s a pizzeria but another places made burgers I don’t like Wendy’s or McDonald’s but is only a opinionThanks for your answer
Ulyan K
Just tried some Supremo's for the first time today for lunch. I am not too familiar with the pizza competition in Mars, or any restaurants in this area for that matter, so I can't say how it compares to other local spots. However, based on the other places I've eaten at near the Pittsburgh area, their pizza is just very average.Location is somewhat small and in a plaza. I decided to try out the classic cheese pizza (because if you can't nail a delicious cheese pie, you won't nail the more sophisticated pies). The prices are pretty awesome, I will say that. You can get a personal sized pie for just $6, and there is a way to order online from them directly. But, flavor-wise, the food is still pretty mediocre. They have a somewhat thick crust, cheese that's only average, and not enough tomato sauce in my opinion. Nothing stood out, but it wasn't bad. It did have a slightly stale flavor as well.There are a few interesting items I found on the menu, but didn't order this time. They have nice desserts like the Cookie Bash (tons of chocolate and Oreo) as well as a Mississippi Mudslide Pie (not offered at most pizza places). Plus, the portion for the cinnamon bites is great and it's a great deal!All in all, this is an alright option for a quick snack, cheap dinner, or event when you need tons of pizza. They are a solid choice for catering or fundraising in the area (if you want cheap pizza, that is). Really good option in terms of prices!*just saw a notification for the owner’s response - I did not mean the quality was cheap. I meant the prices were cheap, and I don’t think that’s a bad thing? Thanks for clarifying the quality…maybe I just let the pie sit out too long (although I personally don’t think so). Will give an extra star because they actually cared to read and respond.
Great pizza and calzones. Easy to order from and the food is always ready on time for pick up. Friendly service every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Supremos is our go to delivery service. We are limited on our options for delivery and Supremos has excellent quality food. I’m grateful for your business, thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loyal customer disappointed this time. My husband and I ordered calzones for a change. We were not a fan. For the price can say we've had better elsewhere. Barely any filling especially cheese.We never had any issues with the pizza here they also nail that!
Food: 2
This is most definitely our favorite pizza in the area. Last time out, I went for a steak hoagie. That was really good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas With
We generally like Supremo's. But they didn't put ranch on the fries we ordered, like the Callery location does. Good thing we ordered an extra bottle of ranch.Also the bottle of ranch wasn't a squirt container like we're used to getting, it was more like a small bottle of Ken's salad dressing. I prefer the squirt bottles for ease of portion control.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I ordered for the first time from Supremo’s and I was so very happy. I ordered. A large Pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, half of an Italian Hoagie and a Steak Salad. The pizza was fabulous, love the sauce and the cheese as well as the crust. I should have ordered a whole Italian because the half was only about 5 inches long. The steak salad was smaller than I expected, but I do know that everything is shrinking in size or becoming more expensive or both. The hoagie and salad were good, but the pizza was my favorite! Food arrived still warm and in a timely manner. I will order from them again for sure!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas With
Anytime I order pizza it has to be from Supremos. Everything is excellent from the pizzas to the salads and everything in between. Plus, their ranch dressing is the best!
Food: 5
The food is always good. The people in the store are always very nice. The driver was a little rude.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
A small pizza and sandwich shop nearby, carry-out only. Great pizza, lots of cheese. Pleasant service. This is my go-to place when I miss supper at home. May I suggest you order tonight.Parking: Plenty of parking, this is take-out only.Wheelchair accessibility: yes, wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizzas With
Great food! We are very fortunate and thankful to have a locally run business that supports their community as much as they do!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food..prices and awesome staff and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a carry-out only restaurant. Pizza and subs are pretty good. Great salads. Excellent, prompt, friendly service.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Just moved in the area. Very good place for pizza! Service is fast and friendly. We always stop by at least once a week for take out!!!
So far so good need to make burgers definitely I need BURGERS!!!!Ok I see your answer yes it’s a pizzeria but another places made burgers I don’t like Wendy’s or McDonald’s but is only a opinionThanks for your answer
Just tried some Supremo's for the first time today for lunch. I am not too familiar with the pizza competition in Mars, or any restaurants in this area for that matter, so I can't say how it compares to other local spots. However, based on the other places I've eaten at near the Pittsburgh area, their pizza is just very average.Location is somewhat small and in a plaza. I decided to try out the classic cheese pizza (because if you can't nail a delicious cheese pie, you won't nail the more sophisticated pies). The prices are pretty awesome, I will say that. You can get a personal sized pie for just $6, and there is a way to order online from them directly. But, flavor-wise, the food is still pretty mediocre. They have a somewhat thick crust, cheese that's only average, and not enough tomato sauce in my opinion. Nothing stood out, but it wasn't bad. It did have a slightly stale flavor as well.There are a few interesting items I found on the menu, but didn't order this time. They have nice desserts like the Cookie Bash (tons of chocolate and Oreo) as well as a Mississippi Mudslide Pie (not offered at most pizza places). Plus, the portion for the cinnamon bites is great and it's a great deal!All in all, this is an alright option for a quick snack, cheap dinner, or event when you need tons of pizza. They are a solid choice for catering or fundraising in the area (if you want cheap pizza, that is). Really good option in terms of prices!*just saw a notification for the owner’s response - I did not mean the quality was cheap. I meant the prices were cheap, and I don’t think that’s a bad thing? Thanks for clarifying the quality…maybe I just let the pie sit out too long (although I personally don’t think so). Will give an extra star because they actually cared to read and respond.