Steve & Irene's

1110 US-6, Mayfield
(570) 282-6868

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Terri Fazio

Love their hoagies and salads and that they change with the seasons!!

Bob Neve

Best for take out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Denise Cerra-Moczulski

It is the best place for Hoagies, fries and salads It’s always fresh and seasoned perfect . We recently moved out of town and we come back every 2 weeks to visit family, Steve and Irene’s is our first stop 🛑!!!

Jim Lipko

I have been ordering here for years and I have been happy with what I ordered. This week I ordered 1/2 of a cheesesteak w/o and xcheese. What I got was a big piece of bread with a bit of dried steak a bit of cheese, melted on top of the steak not mixed in terrible. 14 dollars I expect a bit more, try harder. I also don’t appreciate nasty comments politically from staff. Done!

Christina Marie

I cannot say enough wonderful things about Steve and Irene’s!! We had their cold hoagie platter, chicken tenders, and cranberry walnut salad for my boy’s birthday party yesterday. Ordering was very simple and I was guided on exactly how much food was needed. The food was ready exactly when I had scheduled for pick up and did not have to wait at all. Everyone at the party raved about all of the food. We will definitely be ordering from them again!! Thank you Steve & Irene’s!!

Anja Vie

I Absolutely love Steve And Irene’s Hoagies 🫶 the food is great , warm and welcoming atmosphere and such lovely staff Thank you

Judy Smith Tomisman

great staff! friendly and accurate with orders. The rolls are beyond fresh. I highly recommend grabbing a sandwich here! you will be happy you did. I will be going back...again and again....

Keto Shaun

I live in Erie, Pa now but grew up near Mayfield. I haven't had Steve & Irene's now since 2010 because of my move but when ever the discussion about fantastic food comes up, best subs etc I always mention Steve & Irene's because nothing I've had since comes even close. Glad you're still going strong and thanks for the wonderful memories.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Pregler

Fantastic food from fantastic people

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis McNaughton

Best hoagies on route 6 between Clark's Summit and Carbondale.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Logan Chabal

My favorite hoagie spot in all of NEPA and maybe all time, just great people and even better food all around.

Skye Hamilton

We tried the Triple Cheese Philly and the Rodeo Philly. I customized my Rodeo with fried onions and green peppers—so good! I got full from just half the sandwich, and the flavor was absolutely delicious. The cashier was super understanding when I wanted to change my order, which I really appreciated. 10/10 would definitely recommend, and I’ll be going back soon!

B Forte

Just up from The Eynon is a place that's our go-to most weekends. Today, The Jerk Chicken Salad and Western CheeseSteak wrap with an order of mini potato pancakes hit the spot once again. Any CheeseSteak can be made on a wrap and I believe you can request your kind of CheeseSteak. Steve & Irene's is a must-try for all.

Claire Berry

Easy parking, great food and the owner is super nice 🙂.

Alexis Gilmore

Vegetarian options: The hot veggie sub is delicious. (It's also available as a wrap.)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak

Loading...