Sal's OIP & Restaurant

31 Main St, McAlisterville
(717) 463-2133

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bre Bowersox

Watched 4 girls standing in the back talking while I was waiting to be waited on. Then proceeded to watch a girl peeling a cucumber drop it in the trash and then got it out and continued peeling it.

Kim Dressler

Ordered a dinner and two slices of sausage and pepperoni pizza. Dinner came out and 10 minutes later no slices. When asked about it apparently got pushed to the back. Came out 6 minutes later to hard pizza and burnt on bottom

Andrew Hartzell

The food was delicious but honestly perfect in my opinion. I highly recommend eating here if you’re local or just passing through. The kitchen staff are super awesome & we’re very kind to me.

Jamee J. Ungerecht Mays

We have order from them 3 different times over 6 months…everytime they mess up our order. When I call in the response is”everyone makes mistakes “ I need to call in sooner…they will credit my meal…how about make the order the way the paying customer requests it…if you can’t handle that…you need to find a new job…you are not cut out to follow directions…over priced and they mess up your order 75% of the time.

Emrald96 Jakub

Always pleasant staff, good food

Rachel Shearer Godbee

2nd time my sub was not made correctly, and not only could I not have it re-made, my options were to return the sub so they could fix (remove the incorrect and add the correct) toppings which had been paid for, or reimbursement for the toppings I paid for, but didn't receive. Never mind the fact of an allergy to the toppings that were put on the sub. Horrible customer service.

Stephanie Redmond

Food is great when the people who take your order get it correct. The order was all the way incorrect and didn't even get an apology for their mess up. I didn't have time to sit around and wait for the order to be remade.

Shawn Cutshall

food is good and the homemade pie was amazing

Kody Garman

Used to be better lately it's a gamble on if the food will be greasy but it's usually good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Stacey Heron

Great food ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Robin Schleich

Food was delicious. Friendly staff. First time there so I wasn't sure what to do. Server was helpful when free. Order at the counter then clear your own table. So great meal just slightly confusing set up

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Brad Zeigler

Great Service and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adam Supplee

Food is good, price is getting ridiculous.

Adam Castillo

Sals is a go to if you want local mom and pop pizza shop pizza. Subs are better then tyson hill however can't anyone make a real meatball anymore? Still, better then most for being where they are. Careful menu selection determines happiness.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Calzone

Maggie Beward

I placed an order for pick up. A medium Stromboli and Mozzarella Sticks. When she told me the price on the phone she told me 20 and some change and to my surprise is was 27$ and change when it was picked up. If I would’ve known it was going to be that much I would’ve told them to not even make it. And the food was not worth 27$ at all! Extremely disappointed!

Loading...