The Creme Stop

31016 PA-35, Mcalisterville
(717) 463-2982

Recent Reviews

Sort by
R H

They have Excellent fries and the ice cream was good too.

Rosa Ryan

Awesome food , down to earth atmosphere 😋

Alinn Reede

The food is great! The organization is a bit off. I was in line behind a couple who stepped aside after they ordered, and I stepped up to the window. I waited for quite a while. Several workers walked by the window, looked at me, and continued on. An elderly couple stepped up to the other window and were offered to have their order taken immediately. They were not ready and took a step back. I continued to wait at the other window. The elderly couple decided on their order, the cashier rang them out and proceeded to work on their order. I continued to wait another several minutes before someone asked if my order had been taken yet.

Mic Ear

Excellent food and ice cream

Kaden Hoffman

Nice food, good ice cream, great iced tea.

Michael Szostek

We've been living up the road for under a year now. I just decided to stop by for a quick dinner while out running around. I got a cheesesteak with extra meat because I know they don't really put that much on to begin with. I added a photo of the sandwich to show you that there still wasn't enough meat on it.

Also, having family who came from Philly, absolutely nobody out here in Juniata County knows how to even making an authentic cheesesteak. I wish I could teach them.

My wife also ordered a shrimp basket and got a popcorn chicken basket instead. We got charged for chicken, but the popcorn chicken is almost the size of my dogs kibble and it looked like someone threw a bunch of crumbs in the box with the fries.

I also wish, for them being around for so long, that they would make their own hard ice cream. It's really just a soft serve place. The ice cream is good, but it's nothing really special.

Peggy Maneval

The best black raspberry ice cream I've ever had

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone

Charles Baker

I'm 52 years old, and they still taste like I remember when I was a teen. So delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

frank zalar

Stopped in here and got two soft serve ice cream cones. They were huge for $3. And the ice cream was excellent. Best 6 bucks I've spent in a while. ??

desiree gertzen (Des)

Wonderful old fashioned ice cream stand experience...large menu with lots of delicious options. I really enjoy that the switch up flavors weekly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Blueberry, Strawberry, Ice Cream Cone

Jessyca Schlothauer

I had the blueberry sundae! Let me just say it was the best Sundae I've had in a long time. I have been to a lot of the ice cream shops around Pennsylvania but for some reason right here at the cream stop their ice cream is extra creamy and it just tastes very very good. And the food is pretty awesome as well. But if you like blueberry try the blueberry sundae you wouldn't want to eat anything else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Crab Cake Sandwich, Bacon Cheeseburger

desiree gertzen

Wonderful old fashioned ice cream stand experience...large menu with lots of delicious options. I really enjoy that the switch up flavors weekly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Blueberry, Strawberry, Ice Cream Cone

Stacey Heron

Their was more vegetables in my cheesesteak sub. Than meat. Where's the beef lol. Pineapple flavor really didn't taste like Pineapple not sure what it was

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Jessica S.

I had the blueberry sundae! Let me just say it was the best Sundae I've had in a long time. I have been to a lot of the ice cream shops around Pennsylvania but for some reason right here at the cream stop their ice cream is extra creamy and it just tastes very very good. And the food is pretty awesome as well. But if you like blueberry try the blueberry sundae you wouldn't want to eat anything else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Crab Cake Sandwich, Bacon Cheeseburger

Emily Smith

For a custard stand it's ideal, and it's in a area that's the ONLY one for miles so that's a huge advantage!!!
But I wasn't impressed by the food ? and the prices were not economical for the area.. Huge hot spot for people with dogs and I don't like that when I'm trying to eat my supper or enjoy an ice cream.. ? but otherwise I'll be there again not anytime soon but it was OK..

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Loading...