James Buchanan Restaurant
CLOSED$$ •
About James Buchanan Restaurant
James Buchanan Restaurant Reviews
James Buchanan Pub was the perfect venue for a small, intimate wedding. The patio was stunning for the ceremony — it had the most beautiful natural lighting and was the perfect size. The dining room was cozy, elegant, and the ideal space to celebrate the newly married couple. The accommodation rooms were absolutely perfect for getting ready and made the whole day run smoothly. And the food? Simply divine. Truly one of Mercersburg’s best hidden treasures.
Language barrier - made a reservation for the special menu. Waitress advised that she tried to call regarding my reservation. I asked, did you leave a message at which she replied”no”. You see this was our 19th wedding anniversary and I selected this restaurant based on the special menu, if I knew we wouldn’t have had the reservation for the special menu we wouldn’t have gone. Ordered a cup of soup received the bowl (room temperature) asked if this was the “cup” and...read full review
Chef John and Taylor were amazing. Ole fashins were great!! Food was top notch. Crab meat just like Southern Md. Fish and chips just like Ireland. Give these guys a chance, you won't regret it. Can't wait to come back.
Menu
People in Mercersburg Also Viewed
The James Buchanan Restaurant offers a unique dining experience with a cozy and historical atmosphere. The restaurant has a gas fireplace, making it an ideal spot for a date night. The menu presents a variety of appealing dishes, and the potato sides, salmon, and certain pasta dishes have received positive feedback.
Recent reviews praise the outstanding food and service, with the ribeye, haddock stuffed with crab, and homemade strawberry shortcake receiving high praise. The head chef has also been known to personally check on customer satisfaction, demonstrating a commitment to the dining experience. Customers have highlighted the fresh and well-prepared crab cakes, chicken Marsala, and the excellent Marsala sauce. The food is consistently praised as excellent, and the service is commendable.