Mamma's Pizza

357 N Main St, Mercersburg
(717) 498-0395

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jeanette Marie

I see several negative reviews here but we started going around November of 2023 and our food has always been good. We've only tried the cheesesteaks and pizza but it's always cooked perfectly. On a side note, I only do pick up orders. If you order delivery from anywhere it's just not going to be as fresh

Junipa Suslu

Their food it’s pretty good with a generous portion. Even though they have a dine option it seems more of a carryout kind of business.

Josh Valentine

It's always been good food.

Joseph Hoover

This is the worst pizzeria ever. I gave him a chance the first time I got three cheesesteaks they were so soggy and nasty. the bread was disgusting. the food was halfway done today. I gave him a chance and figured I'll get a sicilian pizza. they gave me doughy pizza all the toppings not even close to being done by far disgusting worst pizza place ever. I wish they would leave this area. someone else needs to come to this area because they're the worst pizza place ever!!! do not go to this place. it is the worst they charge outrages. they literally gave me seven mushrooms breaded mushrooms for all about $7

Joe Hoover

This is the worst pizzeria ever. I gave him a chance the first time I got three cheesesteaks they were so soggy and nasty. the bread was disgusting. the food was halfway done today. I gave him a chance and figured I'll get a sicilian pizza. they gave me doughy pizza all the toppings not even close to being done by far disgusting worst pizza place ever. I wish they would leave this area. someone else needs to come to this area because they're the worst pizza place ever!!! do not go to this place. it is the worst they charge outrages. they literally gave me seven mushrooms breaded mushrooms for all about $7

Tiffany Atkins

We ordered a pizza for our youngest and me my bf and our other son had their steak and cheese.. they were terrible tonight to much mayo I couldn't eat mine without getting mayo all over my fingers. And my bfs was very greasy.. the pizza looked better than the sandwiches I wouldn't recommend going here..

Tamara Cantner

Pizza was delicious! Plenty of cheese too

Gary Hockenberry

called for a pick up order got a large pepperoni pizza. it was hard as rock and tasted like cardboard. idk how long that pizza was sitting there but it definitely wasn't freshly made. mind you I called while on my way there and after pick up drive straight home 30 min round trip

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

michael delamater

I got two Strombolis and a couple of subs , everything was good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Medium Pepperoni Pizza, Stromboli, French Fries, Cheesesteak

Jessy Parson

Pricey for the amount of food you get, and here lately the food hasn't been very enjoyable to eat. Stale rolls, very little meat on sandwiched,(Hot or cold). Usually with delivery hot food it cold by the time you get it. FYI I only live 6 minutes away.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Sherry Farm girl

I like it because it's simple relaxed atmosphere. Just local joking good food. I love the chicken taco salad

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Giancarlo Angelini

I've never been disappointed! Great food, great service and delivery. So miss them on Wednesdays!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Medium Pepperoni Pizza, Stromboli, French Fries, Chicken Parmigiana Sub, Cheesesteak, Small Stromboli, Ultimate Cheese Fries

codpro 06

They did not come out and give us menus

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

the werd 1

Ordered subs n pizza the sub was all frigging bread I ordered Xtra Lettuce n got no Lettuce the mushrooms on the pizza was so small u couldn't even see them horrible

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Hookie Affeldt

The pizza was great. It took forever even though they weren't very busy, but there is no denying that the pizza was awesome.

Loading...