Went here with friends for early dinner, ate in the restaurant.We were very disappointed with the place in general. Pizza took a while to be served and the dough was undercooked. My white pizza (loaded with veggies) was missing something in taste, maybe garlic?It was also fairly expensive and the atmosphere in side was mediocre - but I have to give them the benefit of the doubt due to COVID. Drink cooler was under-stocked.I might like to try other things on the menu to give Romeo's another chance. I did enjoy my appetizer salad and the staff was notably kind/respectful!
Audrey Kendall
Barley any sauce on my spaghetti had to add my own jar of sauce ! French fries were burnt coal black & nothing had flavor !!! Super disappointed & the piece for 2 cheesesteaks spaghetti & pizza was 60$ way overpriced !!!
Rick Norton
Romeo's used to make the best pizza but the last four NY style pizzas that I bought were not good. The dough was hard and seemed old. I called in and asked if they sold me old pizzas. The person that I talked to told me that the pizzas were made fresh but that the dough was old and fermented. They offered to make me two new ones for free. I appreciated the offer but didn't want to take the chance on getting two more pizzas using the same dough. I decided to throw away the bad pizza and ordered two more pizzas two weeks later and the pizzas were just as bad as the other two. I will change my rating if Romeo's show improvement in the future. Romeo's used to my favorite pizzeria.
Kat Thomas
This was the first time in a while that I’ve had Romeo’s. Let me just say it was PHENOMENAL!!! Our food was hot and ready to go within 25 minutes. I got the cheese steak sub and it was so cheesy with a roll that was so fresh! The meat didn’t stick together in clumps as it sometimes does in other restaurant experiences I’ve had. I also had an order of French fries which were amazing as well! Definitely definitely recommend this restaurant as I always do. Harry and his team work HARD to put out delicious meals to this community and let me just say their hard work was duly noted tonight! Can’t wait to go back!
Mindy Schooley Pine
when you have a problem they don't want to fix the problem..you shouldn't have to wait an hour and a half for food.. plus if your not a regular customer they don't care.
Jody Gordon
our pizza was burnt, tasted like cardboard and crust was hard. Just to let you know this was the second chance because this was not the first time. But will be the last.
6ocicats
Harry and his crew did a fantastic job for our family reunion dinner for 10 (and yes, we were all vaccinated) at the newly relocated Romeo's in the James Buchanan Hotel. We were in a large, private room. Service was prompt, attentive and friendly. The food was really good, and the atmosphere was just right for our first family get together in over a year. Thanks to Harry and the staff at Romeo's for taking such good care of us!
Dwaine Landis
Great food and reasonable price.
The Juggernauts
I haven’t been back in 27 years, but I went to Romeo’s at least 4 days a week. Mr. Romano called me McCaulay as in McCaulay Culkin, because I would always come in and play Home Alone in the VCR. Seeing the pictures of the menu brings back memories. I can taste the food. I always ordered a Pizza Steak no onions and Fries, or a Sausage Pizza and Pizza Fries, always with a Root Beer, and they referred to it as my “The Usual?”To this day it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had. I would move to this town just to go to Romeo’s pizza.Place is AMAZING!
Angela Biesecker
Always loved Romeo's, but last time we visited pizza crust was different .and outside junk was sitting around
A must try if you've haven't yet...if you have, well you already know the food is great! Looks like there might be some renovations in the works, but don't let that deter you! Can't wait to go back on our next visit to Cowans Gap state park!
Amanda Fallon
Romeo's Pizza has the BEST breadsticks. Their other stuff is great too, my kids love the pizza, but I get the breadsticks everytime I order. They are so good, so perfectly done every. Single. Time. Everyone there is very nice, great service, very fast and all that, but man...those breadsticks...I might order more today!
Michelle Shipp
Best place to get pizza
Dale Showe
Missed this place. It's been over 20 years. Pizza is still great along with the service.
LeeAnn Simonson Gilbert
I highly recommend Romeos Pizza to anyone in the area. Im not real keen on posting reviews because, how could my opion matter. In the case of Romeos, I'll go out on a limb. Here is what I've observed:
Went here with friends for early dinner, ate in the restaurant.We were very disappointed with the place in general. Pizza took a while to be served and the dough was undercooked. My white pizza (loaded with veggies) was missing something in taste, maybe garlic?It was also fairly expensive and the atmosphere in side was mediocre - but I have to give them the benefit of the doubt due to COVID. Drink cooler was under-stocked.I might like to try other things on the menu to give Romeo's another chance. I did enjoy my appetizer salad and the staff was notably kind/respectful!
Barley any sauce on my spaghetti had to add my own jar of sauce ! French fries were burnt coal black & nothing had flavor !!! Super disappointed & the piece for 2 cheesesteaks spaghetti & pizza was 60$ way overpriced !!!
Romeo's used to make the best pizza but the last four NY style pizzas that I bought were not good. The dough was hard and seemed old. I called in and asked if they sold me old pizzas. The person that I talked to told me that the pizzas were made fresh but that the dough was old and fermented. They offered to make me two new ones for free. I appreciated the offer but didn't want to take the chance on getting two more pizzas using the same dough. I decided to throw away the bad pizza and ordered two more pizzas two weeks later and the pizzas were just as bad as the other two. I will change my rating if Romeo's show improvement in the future. Romeo's used to my favorite pizzeria.
This was the first time in a while that I’ve had Romeo’s. Let me just say it was PHENOMENAL!!! Our food was hot and ready to go within 25 minutes. I got the cheese steak sub and it was so cheesy with a roll that was so fresh! The meat didn’t stick together in clumps as it sometimes does in other restaurant experiences I’ve had. I also had an order of French fries which were amazing as well! Definitely definitely recommend this restaurant as I always do. Harry and his team work HARD to put out delicious meals to this community and let me just say their hard work was duly noted tonight! Can’t wait to go back!
when you have a problem they don't want to fix the problem..you shouldn't have to wait an hour and a half for food.. plus if your not a regular customer they don't care.
our pizza was burnt, tasted like cardboard and crust was hard. Just to let you know this was the second chance because this was not the first time. But will be the last.
Harry and his crew did a fantastic job for our family reunion dinner for 10 (and yes, we were all vaccinated) at the newly relocated Romeo's in the James Buchanan Hotel. We were in a large, private room. Service was prompt, attentive and friendly. The food was really good, and the atmosphere was just right for our first family get together in over a year. Thanks to Harry and the staff at Romeo's for taking such good care of us!
Great food and reasonable price.
I haven’t been back in 27 years, but I went to Romeo’s at least 4 days a week. Mr. Romano called me McCaulay as in McCaulay Culkin, because I would always come in and play Home Alone in the VCR. Seeing the pictures of the menu brings back memories. I can taste the food. I always ordered a Pizza Steak no onions and Fries, or a Sausage Pizza and Pizza Fries, always with a Root Beer, and they referred to it as my “The Usual?”To this day it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had. I would move to this town just to go to Romeo’s pizza.Place is AMAZING!
Always loved Romeo's, but last time we visited pizza crust was different .and outside junk was sitting around
Restaurantji Recommends
A must try if you've haven't yet...if you have, well you already know the food is great! Looks like there might be some renovations in the works, but don't let that deter you! Can't wait to go back on our next visit to Cowans Gap state park!
Romeo's Pizza has the BEST breadsticks. Their other stuff is great too, my kids love the pizza, but I get the breadsticks everytime I order. They are so good, so perfectly done every. Single. Time. Everyone there is very nice, great service, very fast and all that, but man...those breadsticks...I might order more today!
Best place to get pizza
Missed this place. It's been over 20 years. Pizza is still great along with the service.
I highly recommend Romeos Pizza to anyone in the area. Im not real keen on posting reviews because, how could my opion matter. In the case of Romeos, I'll go out on a limb. Here is what I've observed: