Alfred's Victorian

38 N Union St, Middletown
(717) 944-5373

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joyce Hetrick

Enjoyed Mother’s Day Tea with my daughters and granddaughter on Saturday. It was wonderful! The food was delicious! The decor was beautiful! Our server was attentive, polite, and very personable! What a delightful afternoon!

MrsHound

I don’t even know where to begin, my sister, her daughter, and myself took our mom there for a Mother’s Day afternoon tea. Oh my word it was beautiful and wonderful from beginning to end. Our server was outstanding, super friendly and easy to talk with. Every bite we took was outstanding, so hats off to the chef! The service was absolutely wonderful and we couldn’t have asked for anyone better to take care of us while we were there. The building inside is absolutely gorgeous and very Victorian, of course lol. Our server was right on cue with everything she brought us. I can’t wait to go back but this time bring my husband with so he can experience it!! I hope you do Christmas afternoon tea so that hopefully we can all come back and see how beautiful you decorated for Christmas 🎄 thank you so much for a beautiful experience!

Caitlyn Tatarski

A cool concept. However very cluttered and over priced. We got the table side steaks. Over sixty each. We asked for med rare and med. We got well done. We also were only served three baby potatoes and three pieces of broccoli with our meal. The price point doesn't match what we got. Very cool concept though.

Terri Tamecki

Worst Valentine meal ever. 3 courses first was 2 bugles stuffed with dip 2 pieces of celery and 4 pieces of pepperoni for 2 people, second course was 3 meatballs for my husband and a salad without dressing for me. Third course we both got beef tips and it came out looking like someone had vomited on the plate with three grapes on the plate why??? Ordered coffee which came out cold and peanut pie that was terrible. I came here excited for a dinner as we experienced in the past and just wanted to walk out. Place was so run down . Very disappointed ☹️

Ilyse Waine

The place has gone down hill. Dirty and the food was not good.

Sue Schonman

First time here and was so looking forward...but was sadly disappointed. Cute outside but then met with musty, moldy smell and felt like grandma's old stuff just randomly laying around. Limited menu which I should have realized for Valentine's Day. Portions were skimpy, steak and salmon overcooked. Upside, crab bisque was yummy. Served a half glass of wine so we decided to get a bottle, only to be substituted by the cheapest brand pinot noir on the market. No ambiance or music, so played some on my phone at our table. Wish we spent our $250+ somewhere else.

Chrylann Deck

We attended a tea this afternoon. The teas were lovely, and there was more food than I could eat. A wonderful variety. I will be back for another tea.

Edward Sendatch

We were there in early October and no pumpkin soup?? No harvest salad either? We’ve been coming here for over 20 years and looking forwards to these two and none. Food was good, no complaints. But you should bring these back.

Rodney Temple

I used to really love this place and really wanted to enjoy it last evening but, the curb appeal was the first disappointment.The staff was nice but the food was very sub par which was not the norm. I really hope they can turn things around because we do genuinely enjoy going there.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Harmony Santoro

Hands Down AMAZING!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak Dianne, Flaming Victorian Salad

Josephine Kiger

We celebrated my daughter’s Sweet Sixteen at Alfred’s Victorian for high noon tea and it was amazing! The staff was very attentive and extremely friendly, the food was very unique and absolutely delicious, and everything was perfectly aligned with my daughter’s vision of what she anticipated her birthday to be!
Everyone enjoyed themselves and were treated as if they were the most important. From scheduling the event with Robin to the end of the party, Alfred’s Victorian set the standards higher than I could have ever imagined!
If you are looking for a unique and memorable experience for any age, this should definitely be your number one choice!
Thank you Robin and staff for creating a beautiful experience for my daughter’s Sweet Sixteen, we will remember this always!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Scones for High Tea, High Tea Sandwiches

Mark Fey

The last time I ate at Alfred's was wonderful. It was truly worth ordering the beef wellington in advance. The most delicious wine and all else was perfect, including the alcove (small & round) for my wife and I. Truly something special.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef Wellington

Keith Jones

This place is definitely in need to shut down. It smells like a basement Humidifier at the front door, plates dirty. No AC..Crabcakes labeled lump.Not one piece of lump all filler. Do not take your date here.

Michelle Widders

Dinner was a huge disappointment. Quality was not there at all. Way overpriced. Crab cake was horrible. No lump crab meat like advertised. The building is very run down. Junk and trash laying al over out front, inside front door, clutter everywhere. Extremely disappointed.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Kristie Butler

Worst food I have eaten in years !

Loading...