Old Coaly Pub and Grill House

101 E Main St, Middletown
(717) 388-1653

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shirley Burts

we picked up food to go, it was aweful!!! the 1/2 rack ribs were soo small, it was the small end and extremely dry, more like 1/3 rack! the fried zucchini was almost black, was unable to eat.the fish was also hard and dry. Thank you for such a bad dinning out experience.

Wander47127905233

we picked up food to go, it was aweful!!! the 1/2 rack ribs were soo small, it was the small end and extremely dry, more like 1/3 rack! the fried zucchini was almost black, was unable to eat. the fish was also hard and dry. Thank you for such a bad dinning out experience.

Mr. Scott K

Friendly staff, great food, awesome atmosphere!Had lunch, a few brews and played some pool.We will be back again!

Casey Murphy

Food sucks and pool tables are pay to play but beers

jen (maltieskitten)

Loved food, drinks, price, service, and pool tables. Only dislike is that they allow smoking cigarettes inside....and the place really smells like it! Other then that nice place to go to play pool, drink and have fun with friends. Also close to PSU Harrisburg, great place for students 21+ to go to after classes!

Dylan Sutton

Great food. Good prices.. Bartenders are very good at what they do & efficient.

Lukes auto Service

This is a awesome place cheap prices and good food wish I lived closer

Robert Conrad

Billiard tables is a plus. Food is okay. Smoking is allowed, so that was surprising.

AlexanderJolly MerkNowitzki

Very disappointed in the cashier and the business in as a whole. I came in from out of town to get a drink just to find a charge to my bill for a tip I didn't include. They basically took money from my account unauthorized. If you think I'm supposed to tip $5 off of a $5 drink you should just shut your whole business down

Alma Weaber

Was in the area and decided to get something to bring home to eat and everything was great. I had the BBQ pulled pork sub and it was delicious!!! Wish this place was closer to home cause I would definitely eat there more.

Captain Dunsel (Tracy Bitner)

Good food. Pizza-sub shop menu at the bar. Only thing didn't care for was the trivia night, it was to loud to have a conversation over.

Bonnie Balmer

Soup could have been a bit more flavorful.Chicken cheese steak could have used a bit more sauce. Wasn't unplayable, will give it another try.

Kellie Arnold

There is not a option for a negative star review, but I couldn’t post unless I gave at least a 1 star lol. This was the worst experience ever! No one cared I guess because we weren’t in our 20’s and a regular. I ordered a burger, wings with celery. The burger was from frozen and cold! The celery was limp, at least the hot wings were decent. I will NEVER go back!

Bethany Medina

Trivia Night was a blast! It was pretty busy and the food was good!

John Despines

Only place open sunday at 830pm had wings and a hearty chowder . Friendly

Loading...

Old Coaly Pub and Grill House

101 E Main St, Middletown, PA 17057
(717) 388-1653