Old Mill Creamery, LLC
6542 Buffalo Creek Rd, Mifflinburg
(570) 966-4143
Customers' Favorites
Creamy Ice Cream in Homeade Waffle Cone
Chocolate Ice Cream
Hazelnut Latte
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We stopped in here after some hiking at the park up the road, and we loved it!! It was a great end to our day after a great hike! We are visiting from Tennessee, and we will be back.
We haven’t stopped talking about the ice cream from
Old Mill since our visit a couple weeks ago (and we’ve eaten a lot of ice cream on the PA ice cream trail)! We had a free summer day and drove a little over an hour to try it out. The ice cream was SO GOOD and the waffle cone is what dreams are made of. Eating ice cream by the cute stream was the cherry on top. We even had to go in after we ate our cones to get a half gallon to take home (it was worth the risk of...
Old Mill since our visit a couple weeks ago (and we’ve eaten a lot of ice cream on the PA ice cream trail)! We had a free summer day and drove a little over an hour to try it out. The ice cream was SO GOOD and the waffle cone is what dreams are made of. Eating ice cream by the cute stream was the cherry on top. We even had to go in after we ate our cones to get a half gallon to take home (it was worth the risk of...
You May Also Like
DC Coffee & Tea Co - 7 Cedar Green Center
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Cafe, Coffee, American
Green Ridge Country Market - 811 Forest Hill Rd
![]()
Grocery, Bakery
Eastside Diner - 349 E Chestnut St
![]()
Seafood, American, Family, Sandwich Shop
Flavor was wonderful and the benched out back by the creek was nice to set on and listen to the babbling brook going by.
I would stop again if in the area!