Rusty Rail Brewing Company

5 N 8th St Suite #1, Mifflinburg
(570) 966-7878

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Todd Enders

My wife and I ate dinner here a few nights ago. I won’t bother wasting words - this is likely to have been the best meal I’ve eaten in a restaurant in my life. My wife agrees, although we ordered two different steaks. Both steaks were perfectly cooked, my wife adored her risotto, and my mashed potatoes were ambrosial. And the server (Steph) was one of the best servers I’ve ever encountered. The place is fun, and spacious, and warm and cheerful. Definitely a new high score, and the place to beat. Will DEFINITELY be returning!!

Service: 5

Justin Webster

For us it was an hour and a half to get there but definitely worth it. The service was outstanding! The food was even better! The best food I’ve had in a long while. Major props to the owners, managers, cooks, and the waitstaff! Amazing drinks as well! Anyone around the area needs to give them a try!

Food and drinks: Absolutely amazing! You can tell it was made by someone who cares about what they make!

Service: 5

Gwynne

Super pretty restaurant! It’s always such a pleasure to go here.

Service: 5

Roy Leiby

Great food, great beer. I used to think that their beer was average, but they have definitely stepped up their brewing game.

Service: 4

Mandy Cordray

Roy is an Excellent Bartender with knowledge and expertise!

Service: 5

Tom Crawford

Food was great. Portion for cost not so much. We spent 15.00 for 8 wings! We got a brisket meal special for 27.00. We got four slabs of brisket and handful of mac & cheese. Not worth the money. We also got pushed out because our party was apparently loud. It is a Saturday night at a brewery! If you don't like noise please stay at Perkins! We will not be back to pay for overpriced food and told to be quiet when having a good time. Good luck.

Service: 2

Pete Morris

Wow! What a great place. Great draft selection, really good food and excellent service. Plus live music!
Edited to mention: So good we came back the next night. The pork ribeye special was amazing. Allison at the bar was wonderful.
Rusty Rail owners, please open a Rusty Rail East in Newtown, Bucks Co PA!

Service: 5

Kelsey Francisco

An awesome place, such a cool atmosphere. The beer and food was top notch!

Service: 5

Jeremy Patterson

Drove all the way down here after checking to see if they were open and found a sign on the door saying sorry. Come on guys, it takes like 5 minutes to update your closure on Google business.

Jared & Alyson Smigelski

I highly recommend Rusty Rail if you are looking for great beer and food. The atmosphere is amazing, the building is really cool, and the staff is super friendly! I also highly recommend them for your next wedding. I just had my wedding there this past Saturday and it was absolutely amazing. The event spaces are stunning as well as the on site suites. The staff working my wedding from start to finish were fantastic. They made us feel so special! The food was out of this world. Our guests couldn't stop raving about it! They handled everything for us so we could sit back and enjoy our day. We would get married here over and over again if we could!

Service: 5

Diane Knorr

Lauren was a lovely waitress. She brought a water dish for my dog and was quite attentive and friendly. Fool’s Gold was my favorite beer. Pumpkin Swirl was my husband’s favorite. We ended the meal with a dessert shooter flight. Yum!

Service: 5

Medium Denise Lee

We had three meals in two days and stayed in a suite. It’s amazing. The food is very good. The service was prompt and on point. I highly recommend it.the suites are amazing. The California king beds are fantastic and so comfy. I slept like a princess. Everyone is so kind and polite.

Rooms: So beautiful and spacious

Food & drinks: Excellent

Service: 5

Sam Thul

While the service was fine, the food was a crying shame. Ordered nachos with chicken for like 20 bucks and the nachos were inedible, soggy, stuck to the plate. The large bowl of chili we also got for 9 bucks was like 6 spoonfuls at best. Food was way overpriced for the quality. I think they are just taking advantage of the areas lack of food. If I had to choose between the Rusty Rail and a gas station id choose the gas station.

Service: 4

Sally Merriman

Nice atmosphere. Very spacious. The beer selection is good. Food was just okay. I wouldn't go there just to eat. I got the chicken bacon ranch wrap. There's not much flavor and very little bacon. Husband got the honey spiced chicken sandwich. He said the sauce was excellent, but the chicken was overdone. Also had the cheesesteak spring rolls. Name misleading. It's more like oversized egg rolls. The cheesesteak filling was ok. Too much cheese, though, and too hard. Friends also commented on food being overdone.

Service: 3

Paul Spencer

Good food. Very unique and cool restaurant.

Food & drinks: You will enjoy.

Service: 5

Loading...