If you like over the top huge sandwiches this is place. You get what you pay for.
Karen Beilman
Killer ravioli and sausages!
Marguerite Sobieszczanski
We love buying sausage, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, chicken parm, you name it here. It's great! We are from Brooklyn and it brought a smile to our face the first time we found them. Great service and food.
a hello
I hope we don’t get sick….The guy that made Our sandwich never washed his hands, put his filthy mitts on our sandwich but it was tasty
Jennie Formisano Cacace
We went back for lunch yesterday. this time I ordered the red hook, he said I would love it. I sure did! So delicious and filling, I will have the other half for lunch today. 😋 Highly recommend trying it.
Stephen Cacace
Awesome Heroes!!
This was our second visit for lunch to the store, they did not disappoint. The heroes are packed with meat. You can barely get your mouth around it to take a bite.
Impossible to eat the whole hero in one sitting!!
We wrap it up and eat it the next day for lunch!
Can’t wait to go and see what to order next!
I had the Bensonhurst and the Marine Park so far!!
Anthony Pugnacious D'Amico
The sandwiches are amazing 🤩 as well as the fresh mozzarella. The only place in town I’ve found Manhattan Special 👍🏼
Meat is always fresh and the pasta section is good too
Jennie Cacace cacace
We walked in and were told we would get the best sandwich. I must say, they were the best sandwiches! Thankyou from fellow brooklyners. We will definetly be back!
Ashley Miller
I had food from here last year and it was great, which is why I came back. Unfortunately, my recent experience was completely different. The customer service was the worst I’ve encountered at a business. I placed an order for a party, and the gentleman taking my order was extremely rude—almost as if I was inconveniencing him by giving him business.
When I politely asked if the tomatoes could be put on the side for a hoagie order, he responded with, “you’re going to cause problems, aren’t you.” At first I thought he was joking, but he was not. I then asked if he could cut the 3 foot hoagies into smaller pieces and he got annoyed and said they will be cut. That type of attitude is unacceptable and makes it very hard to want to support this business again.
Randy Paladino
Very disappointed on my recent visit. Have purchased there many times over the years. This time, Threw over $40.00 worth of food out. Cheese in eggplant was sour, sandwich tasted off too. After 3 days in the bathroom, I won't return.
We catered a party from the Brooklyn Pork Boy recently. The food was delicious! Especially the fried chicken cutlet hero! Everything was great; eggplant rollatini, penne alla vodka, roast pork with mushrooms and gravy, chicken franchise, orrechietti with sausage and broccoli rabe and meatballs. Matt was able to fulfill our every need and answered all questions. He had the food hot and ready for pickup as promised. We will be ordering from here again for any event in future! Thanks Matt, for a job well done!👍
Jennifer Morrissey
Hubby and I were craving an Italian sub after hiking so we drove into Milford and found this gem. Hubby ended up ordering the Bergen Beach while I ordered the Italian knowing we would share each other's. They did not disappoint! The sandwiches are huge. The amount of meat stuffed inside is incomparable to any other deli and you can tell everything is so fresh. The guy behind the counter was super nice and I loved that they had some pre-made dinners to go for a quick meal. We will definitely be back for more!!
Linda Ditta
Brooklyn Boy has a nice selection of Italian foods and pastries. If you need a homemade meal you will not be disappointed.
James Gardner
Excellent Italian sub.. reminiscent of the NY corner deli.. Give them a try you won’t be disappointed
If you like over the top huge sandwiches this is place. You get what you pay for.
Killer ravioli and sausages!
We love buying sausage, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, chicken parm, you name it here. It's great! We are from Brooklyn and it brought a smile to our face the first time we found them. Great service and food.
I hope we don’t get sick….The guy that made Our sandwich never washed his hands, put his filthy mitts on our sandwich but it was tasty
We went back for lunch yesterday. this time I ordered the red hook, he said I would love it. I sure did! So delicious and filling, I will have the other half for lunch today. 😋 Highly recommend trying it.
Awesome Heroes!! This was our second visit for lunch to the store, they did not disappoint. The heroes are packed with meat. You can barely get your mouth around it to take a bite. Impossible to eat the whole hero in one sitting!! We wrap it up and eat it the next day for lunch! Can’t wait to go and see what to order next! I had the Bensonhurst and the Marine Park so far!!
The sandwiches are amazing 🤩 as well as the fresh mozzarella. The only place in town I’ve found Manhattan Special 👍🏼 Meat is always fresh and the pasta section is good too
We walked in and were told we would get the best sandwich. I must say, they were the best sandwiches! Thankyou from fellow brooklyners. We will definetly be back!
I had food from here last year and it was great, which is why I came back. Unfortunately, my recent experience was completely different. The customer service was the worst I’ve encountered at a business. I placed an order for a party, and the gentleman taking my order was extremely rude—almost as if I was inconveniencing him by giving him business.
When I politely asked if the tomatoes could be put on the side for a hoagie order, he responded with, “you’re going to cause problems, aren’t you.” At first I thought he was joking, but he was not. I then asked if he could cut the 3 foot hoagies into smaller pieces and he got annoyed and said they will be cut. That type of attitude is unacceptable and makes it very hard to want to support this business again.
Very disappointed on my recent visit. Have purchased there many times over the years. This time, Threw over $40.00 worth of food out. Cheese in eggplant was sour, sandwich tasted off too. After 3 days in the bathroom, I won't return.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great sandwiches
We catered a party from the Brooklyn Pork Boy recently. The food was delicious! Especially the fried chicken cutlet hero! Everything was great; eggplant rollatini, penne alla vodka, roast pork with mushrooms and gravy, chicken franchise, orrechietti with sausage and broccoli rabe and meatballs. Matt was able to fulfill our every need and answered all questions. He had the food hot and ready for pickup as promised. We will be ordering from here again for any event in future! Thanks Matt, for a job well done!👍
Hubby and I were craving an Italian sub after hiking so we drove into Milford and found this gem. Hubby ended up ordering the Bergen Beach while I ordered the Italian knowing we would share each other's. They did not disappoint! The sandwiches are huge. The amount of meat stuffed inside is incomparable to any other deli and you can tell everything is so fresh. The guy behind the counter was super nice and I loved that they had some pre-made dinners to go for a quick meal. We will definitely be back for more!!
Brooklyn Boy has a nice selection of Italian foods and pastries. If you need a homemade meal you will not be disappointed.
Excellent Italian sub.. reminiscent of the NY corner deli.. Give them a try you won’t be disappointed
Loading...