We catered a party from the Brooklyn Pork Boy recently. The food was delicious! Especially the fried chicken cutlet hero! Everything was great; eggplant rollatini, penne alla vodka, roast pork with mushrooms and gravy, chicken franchise, orrechietti with sausage and broccoli rabe and meatballs. Matt was able to fulfill our every need and answered all questions. He had the food hot and ready for pickup as promised. We will be ordering from here again for any event in future! Thanks Matt, for a job well done!š
Jennifer Morrissey
Hubby and I were craving an Italian sub after hiking so we drove into Milford and found this gem. Hubby ended up ordering the Bergen Beach while I ordered the Italian knowing we would share each other's. They did not disappoint! The sandwiches are huge. The amount of meat stuffed inside is incomparable to any other deli and you can tell everything is so fresh. The guy behind the counter was super nice and I loved that they had some pre-made dinners to go for a quick meal. We will definitely be back for more!!
Linda Ditta
Brooklyn Boy has a nice selection of Italian foods and pastries. If you need a homemade meal you will not be disappointed.
James Gardner
Excellent Italian sub.. reminiscent of the NY corner deli.. Give them a try you wonāt be disappointed
Steve S (Steve in NEPA)
I want to like this place, but, having patronized the store in its previous iteration as Fretta's, there's just no comparison.
Where Fretta's had an abundance of well displayed delicacies, BBPS often appears a bit sloppy. Where Fretta's always had a helpful and friendly team, BBPS is often abrupt and dismissive. Where Fretta's had prices that were affordable and adjustable portion sizes, BBPS has high prices for what you get and are inflexible when it comes to wavering from sizes offered.
As I said, I want to like BBPS. It causes me joy when local places shine, but they just don't.
Joseph Dooley
Just ate a chicken cutlet hero from Brooklyn Boys with a side of macaroni salad. Everything was fresh and delicious. Great sandwich!
Chedrik Borja
Nice owner, great food, amazing pickles
Christopher John Molnar
Hidden Gem !! Was in there Saturday and picked up food for my Birthday . Everything was Great from the Chicken Cutlets , Fried Eggplant, manicotti and Wild Mushroom Alfredo dinner. Everything was Great ! No need to drive all the way to Uncle Giuseppeās!!
Laura Slotkoff
This place is amazing! The guys who work here were super sweet and helpful. Last thing I expected in a small town sandwich shop called āpork storeā was to find some of the BEST vegetarian food of my life!!! The balsamic eggplant roll is NOT to be missed! Also, coffee soda, who knew that was a thing?! Itās so good š
Terrible service! If I could give this place a zero I would!!! The man who waited on us was the worst person Iāve ever encountered in the service industry! He was obnoxious and insulted us on several occasions. I was charged over $18 for a ball of mozzarella- agree with others that they charge whatever they feel like on the spot. Heās an embarrassment to the Brooklyn community and the fine people of Milford. I would NEVER go back to that store and Iām sorry I made a purchase at all! Learn some manners and customer service skills, you need all the business you can get Brooklyn Boy! Finished! š
Shawn Meiser
The Bay Ridge was the best eggplant sandwich I've ever had.
Chuck Thompson
If you want a quality Italian hero/sub this is the place. Sure you might spend a few more dollars but your getting perfection.I am actually having 4 meals out of one sandwich and the ingredients are fresh not like going to an average deli in Pike or Orange counties.I also order Holiday platters every year and everyone enjoys it.
C.D. Scale Models
Iām from NYC & Iām Italian American & Iāve gone in here several times & I donāt care for the new owner. He is a bit obnoxious & he tries to correct me on certain meats Iām referring to in the meat case. Iām Italian American & he knows Iām from NYC because we spoke about itā¦ā¦Iāve been in Italian delis since I was a young boy. Perhaps he thinks most people may not realize or care heās overcharging for Italian food most people canāt get in Milford PA, but not me anymore. I asked him for fresh ricotta that comes in the small tin bucket & he tells me he has it in the back. He filled up a pint container & when I got home I realized it was not the fresh ricottaā¦..it was the one the supermarket carries & Iām sure he overcharged me for it too. Thatās underhanded as far as Iām concernedā¦ā¦ I will go back to the previous store owner who recently opened a store up again & they carry fresh ricotta in the tin bucket & they are far nicer & not intimidatingā¦ā¦.youāre finished Brooklyn Boy!!!!!
Justin Posyton
Good ingredients, poor execution and shady practices. Charge whatever for whatever, no hand washing between register and dunking hands into the roasted peppers (that have wayyyy too much garlic that made its way on to my sandwich)
Sandwich was stacked with meat, sliced a bit too thick for my liking, and skimped with a few thin slices of fior di latte.
This place wouldnāt last in Brooklyn, so good thing itās in ritzy Milford with all the money bags.
We catered a party from the Brooklyn Pork Boy recently. The food was delicious! Especially the fried chicken cutlet hero! Everything was great; eggplant rollatini, penne alla vodka, roast pork with mushrooms and gravy, chicken franchise, orrechietti with sausage and broccoli rabe and meatballs. Matt was able to fulfill our every need and answered all questions. He had the food hot and ready for pickup as promised. We will be ordering from here again for any event in future! Thanks Matt, for a job well done!š
Hubby and I were craving an Italian sub after hiking so we drove into Milford and found this gem. Hubby ended up ordering the Bergen Beach while I ordered the Italian knowing we would share each other's. They did not disappoint! The sandwiches are huge. The amount of meat stuffed inside is incomparable to any other deli and you can tell everything is so fresh. The guy behind the counter was super nice and I loved that they had some pre-made dinners to go for a quick meal. We will definitely be back for more!!
Brooklyn Boy has a nice selection of Italian foods and pastries. If you need a homemade meal you will not be disappointed.
Excellent Italian sub.. reminiscent of the NY corner deli.. Give them a try you wonāt be disappointed
I want to like this place, but, having patronized the store in its previous iteration as Fretta's, there's just no comparison.
Where Fretta's had an abundance of well displayed delicacies, BBPS often appears a bit sloppy. Where Fretta's always had a helpful and friendly team, BBPS is often abrupt and dismissive. Where Fretta's had prices that were affordable and adjustable portion sizes, BBPS has high prices for what you get and are inflexible when it comes to wavering from sizes offered.
As I said, I want to like BBPS. It causes me joy when local places shine, but they just don't.
Just ate a chicken cutlet hero from Brooklyn Boys with a side of macaroni salad. Everything was fresh and delicious. Great sandwich!
Nice owner, great food, amazing pickles
Hidden Gem !! Was in there Saturday and picked up food for my Birthday . Everything was Great from the Chicken Cutlets , Fried Eggplant, manicotti and Wild Mushroom Alfredo dinner. Everything was Great ! No need to drive all the way to Uncle Giuseppeās!!
This place is amazing! The guys who work here were super sweet and helpful. Last thing I expected in a small town sandwich shop called āpork storeā was to find some of the BEST vegetarian food of my life!!! The balsamic eggplant roll is NOT to be missed! Also, coffee soda, who knew that was a thing?! Itās so good š
Great food. Great service. Great people.
Restaurantji Recommends
Terrible service! If I could give this place a zero I would!!! The man who waited on us was the worst person Iāve ever encountered in the service industry! He was obnoxious and insulted us on several occasions. I was charged over $18 for a ball of mozzarella- agree with others that they charge whatever they feel like on the spot.
Heās an embarrassment to the Brooklyn community and the fine people of Milford. I would NEVER go back to that store and Iām sorry I made a purchase at all! Learn some manners and customer service skills, you need all the business you can get Brooklyn Boy! Finished! š
The Bay Ridge was the best eggplant sandwich I've ever had.
If you want a quality Italian hero/sub this is the place.
Sure you might spend a few more dollars but your getting perfection.I am actually having 4 meals out of one sandwich and the ingredients are fresh not like going to an average deli in Pike or Orange counties.I also order Holiday platters every year and everyone enjoys it.
Iām from NYC & Iām Italian American & Iāve gone in here several times & I donāt care for the new owner. He is a bit obnoxious & he tries to correct me on certain meats Iām referring to in the meat case. Iām Italian American & he knows Iām from NYC because we spoke about itā¦ā¦Iāve been in Italian delis since I was a young boy. Perhaps he thinks most people may not realize or care heās overcharging for Italian food most people canāt get in Milford PA, but not me anymore. I asked him for fresh ricotta that comes in the small tin bucket & he tells me he has it in the back. He filled up a pint container & when I got home I realized it was not the fresh ricottaā¦..it was the one the supermarket carries & Iām sure he overcharged me for it too. Thatās underhanded as far as Iām concernedā¦ā¦ I will go back to the previous store owner who recently opened a store up again & they carry fresh ricotta in the tin bucket & they are far nicer & not intimidatingā¦ā¦.youāre finished Brooklyn Boy!!!!!
Good ingredients, poor execution and shady practices. Charge whatever for whatever, no hand washing between register and dunking hands into the roasted peppers (that have wayyyy too much garlic that made its way on to my sandwich)
Sandwich was stacked with meat, sliced a bit too thick for my liking, and skimped with a few thin slices of fior di latte.
This place wouldnāt last in Brooklyn, so good thing itās in ritzy Milford with all the money bags.
Loading...