Just ate a chicken cutlet hero from Brooklyn Boys with a side of macaroni salad. Everything was fresh and delicious. Great sandwich!
Christopher John Molnar
Hidden Gem !! Was in there Saturday and picked up food for my Birthday . Everything was Great from the Chicken Cutlets , Fried Eggplant, manicotti and Wild Mushroom Alfredo dinner. Everything was Great ! No need to drive all the way to Uncle Giuseppe’s!!
Dingmans Ferry Roadside Service
Great food. Great service. Great people.
Shawn Meiser
The Bay Ridge was the best eggplant sandwich I've ever had.
Chuck Thompson
If you want a quality Italian hero/sub this is the place. Sure you might spend a few more dollars but your getting perfection.I am actually having 4 meals out of one sandwich and the ingredients are fresh not like going to an average deli in Pike or Orange counties.I also order Holiday platters every year and everyone enjoys it.
C.D. Scale Models
I’m from NYC & I’m Italian American & I’ve gone in here several times & I don’t care for the new owner. He is a bit obnoxious & he tries to correct me on certain meats I’m referring to in the meat case. I’m Italian American & he knows I’m from NYC because we spoke about it……I’ve been in Italian delis since I was a young boy. Perhaps he thinks most people may not realize or care he’s overcharging for Italian food most people can’t get in Milford PA, but not me anymore. I asked him for fresh ricotta that comes in the small tin bucket & he tells me he has it in the back. He filled up a pint container & when I got home I realized it was not the fresh ricotta…..it was the one the supermarket carries & I’m sure he overcharged me for it too. That’s underhanded as far as I’m concerned…… I will go back to the previous store owner who recently opened a store up again & they carry fresh ricotta in the tin bucket & they are far nicer & not intimidating…….you’re finished Brooklyn Boy!!!!!
Justin Posyton
Good ingredients, poor execution and shady practices. Charge whatever for whatever, no hand washing between register and dunking hands into the roasted peppers (that have wayyyy too much garlic that made its way on to my sandwich)
Sandwich was stacked with meat, sliced a bit too thick for my liking, and skimped with a few thin slices of fior di latte.
This place wouldn’t last in Brooklyn, so good thing it’s in ritzy Milford with all the money bags.
Olivia Conaty
I found this place today by chance. I cannot say enough about them. They were welcoming and helpful. The food is amazing. I’m currently eating a spinach pinwheel and kicking myself for not getting more to freeze. I’m so excited to try everything I got. I’ll be back over and over and over again.
Deirdre Barca
Fresh mozzarella was delicious, semolina bread so good!! Definitely a must try!!
kate fernald
I called at 10am for 7 sandwiches on the 4th of July. They were ready fast. They were delicious and piled high. In fact I saw how big the sandwiches were even when wrapped up that I decided to take some of their grab and go dinners as well. How convenient for me, as a mom of three to not have to do any of the cooking on this holiday. Highly recommend.
Meat display case was empty only 3 pork chops . The attendant was very cocky & rude . I would not recommend this place to a dog . It was a Saturday 6/8/24 afternoon 3:00 .
chris ammons
Would be 5 stars. Or at least it used to be. I ordered my usual. Canarsi. Loved how much meat came on it. It was worth $17. But the past two times there is no less and less meat on it. And it's almost all lettuce. The bread also was not fresh like is always has been. Get it together.. I will not be ordering from there any time soon.
Shannon Rewoldt
Went onto the website to view menu called placed order said 1 sandwich was gonna be 20mins ok thats fine i get there a sandwich that was listed on THEIR ACTUAL WEBSITE that was 14.99$ the guy says $18.00 i picked up the paper menu right by the register and it opened it the same sandwich was listed as 14.99$ the guy said it says its subject to change and im not changing tbe menu until these run out with the updated prices. His attitude was awful needless to say n i will never be back for. Make sure you ask about prices because they will just make up anything i also got a reciept and it listed manual item * 1 $8.00Manual item * 1 $10.00
Melissa Lambert
Rude! Make sure you know exactly what it is you want to order because if you ask any questions they’ll make you feel as though that you’re some thing that they scraped off the bottom of their shoe.
Just ate a chicken cutlet hero from Brooklyn Boys with a side of macaroni salad. Everything was fresh and delicious. Great sandwich!
Hidden Gem !! Was in there Saturday and picked up food for my Birthday . Everything was Great from the Chicken Cutlets , Fried Eggplant, manicotti and Wild Mushroom Alfredo dinner. Everything was Great ! No need to drive all the way to Uncle Giuseppe’s!!
Great food. Great service. Great people.
The Bay Ridge was the best eggplant sandwich I've ever had.
If you want a quality Italian hero/sub this is the place.
Sure you might spend a few more dollars but your getting perfection.I am actually having 4 meals out of one sandwich and the ingredients are fresh not like going to an average deli in Pike or Orange counties.I also order Holiday platters every year and everyone enjoys it.
I’m from NYC & I’m Italian American & I’ve gone in here several times & I don’t care for the new owner. He is a bit obnoxious & he tries to correct me on certain meats I’m referring to in the meat case. I’m Italian American & he knows I’m from NYC because we spoke about it……I’ve been in Italian delis since I was a young boy. Perhaps he thinks most people may not realize or care he’s overcharging for Italian food most people can’t get in Milford PA, but not me anymore. I asked him for fresh ricotta that comes in the small tin bucket & he tells me he has it in the back. He filled up a pint container & when I got home I realized it was not the fresh ricotta…..it was the one the supermarket carries & I’m sure he overcharged me for it too. That’s underhanded as far as I’m concerned…… I will go back to the previous store owner who recently opened a store up again & they carry fresh ricotta in the tin bucket & they are far nicer & not intimidating…….you’re finished Brooklyn Boy!!!!!
Good ingredients, poor execution and shady practices. Charge whatever for whatever, no hand washing between register and dunking hands into the roasted peppers (that have wayyyy too much garlic that made its way on to my sandwich)
Sandwich was stacked with meat, sliced a bit too thick for my liking, and skimped with a few thin slices of fior di latte.
This place wouldn’t last in Brooklyn, so good thing it’s in ritzy Milford with all the money bags.
I found this place today by chance. I cannot say enough about them. They were welcoming and helpful. The food is amazing. I’m currently eating a spinach pinwheel and kicking myself for not getting more to freeze. I’m so excited to try everything I got. I’ll be back over and over and over again.
Fresh mozzarella was delicious, semolina bread so good!! Definitely a must try!!
I called at 10am for 7 sandwiches on the 4th of July. They were ready fast. They were delicious and piled high. In fact I saw how big the sandwiches were even when wrapped up that I decided to take some of their grab and go dinners as well. How convenient for me, as a mom of three to not have to do any of the cooking on this holiday. Highly recommend.
Restaurantji Recommends
Outstanding! Everything is so good!
Meat display case was empty only 3 pork chops .
The attendant was very cocky & rude . I would not recommend this place to a dog . It was a Saturday 6/8/24 afternoon 3:00 .
Would be 5 stars. Or at least it used to be. I ordered my usual. Canarsi. Loved how much meat came on it. It was worth $17. But the past two times there is no less and less meat on it. And it's almost all lettuce. The bread also was not fresh like is always has been. Get it together.. I will not be ordering from there any time soon.
Went onto the website to view menu called placed order said 1 sandwich was gonna be 20mins ok thats fine i get there a sandwich that was listed on THEIR ACTUAL WEBSITE that was 14.99$ the guy says $18.00 i picked up the paper menu right by the register and it opened it the same sandwich was listed as 14.99$ the guy said it says its subject to change and im not changing tbe menu until these run out with the updated prices. His attitude was awful needless to say n i will never be back for. Make sure you ask about prices because they will just make up anything i also got a reciept and it listed manual item * 1 $8.00Manual item * 1 $10.00
Rude! Make sure you know exactly what it is you want to order because if you ask any questions they’ll make you feel as though that you’re some thing that they scraped off the bottom of their shoe.
Loading...