The Coxcomb

5060 William Penn Hwy, Monroeville
(724) 519-2788

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Al

Overall nice place, good service and food was OK. My problem was I got a pizza and the amount of toppings added to my pizza, which I paid for, was very limited. Some of the pieces had no toppings! In all fairness, the other couple I was with got a pizza, added pepperoni and they got plenty. I got Banana peppers and sausage and did not get much of either.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

2nd time 😞

Tried it when it first opened and thought the food was mediocre and everything was loaded with black pepper. Tried it again , hoping for better and it was overall disappointing. There was a wait to get in and they had plenty of open tables. People who arrived after us were seated before us. Once we sat, the server was very nice and took our orders. We waited almost a hour for 2 small pizzas and a cold sandwich. The server apologized for the delay several times, and you can’t shoot the messenger. The food was still mediocre and the kitchen and dining room management was even worse. Seems like they were understaffed, I get it , it’s hard finding people. It’s loud . The bar will keep it open, wouldn’t go for the food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

John Diggans

Their food is mediocre. We were told they wouldnt add anything to our food That didn't come on it(it was tomato). The service wasn't bad. They have a small outdoor seating area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Anthony DeRiso

We went there on a Monday about 6 ish. We didn't get out of there until about 8 or so.
The service was non-existent. The food was okay at best. I ordered a chicken sandwich, and the chicken was just 2 chicken strips on bread..
Overall, I'm just kinda disappointed with everything, from the food to the service. Prices were okay.

Wheelchair accessibility: It's all on 1 floor minus the booths, which are 1 step ( 8 inches or so) above the floor.
It is wheel chair accessible minus a few booths.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

andrew erickson

I was so excited to try this place.. the menu looked awesome, thought this was going to be my new spot! Ordered over $80 worth of food. Couple orders of chicken strips, couple chicken sandwiches couple apps. The chicken was not only burnt and dry, but it says it’s pickle brined and it was completely flavorless. The first bite was so awful. I just spit it out thinking that maybe that was just a bad piece but all the chicken and all the orders was burnt and disgusting. chicken on the chicken sandwiches was the same way. The Parmesan breadsticks were rock hard. The pierogies were actually good but I mean not really worth spending $80 for one out of six things to be good l. So so disappointed, but to be honest, I’m probably gonna try it again because if the food was actually cooked with any skill or care and if they actually nail down the brining process of the chicken, maybe it will be good so I’ll just assume that everyone in the kitchen just completely failed that night and I’ll try again, but I’ll just buy one item instead of wasting $80 my first warning sign was the guy that answered the phone didn’t know their hours of operation

Food: 1

RJ

Had my rehearsal dinner here and I have 0 negative things to say. Food came out great. Christian was our waiter and the man was fantastic. Helped with getting the.laptop hooked up for a slide show. Made sure everyone had drinks. I love this place. If you want a place for good times 10000% recommend this place. Even if you just want a quick meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen Izquierdo

My chicken tenders came out black! And it was a looooooong wait almost 1 hour to bring our food to the table. Very disappointed

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amy Bonzer

I went for simple hoagie.. thecmenu didn't really have alot of hoagie options. Tried the special smoked meatball garlic aolii hoagie. Very little sauce and the aoli was so overwhelming strong I couldn't taste smoked meatballs. The green sauce did not look appealing . I would rethink that hoagie recipe...for the price I paid it was not worth 14 dollars. Nice clean restaurant, girls in front were nice and working hard but to be honest menu not up to par...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

K Sutton

Food is good, but it's really noisy inside. They need some sort of acoustic control. It's all hard surfaces in there.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim S

Great neighborhood spot for pizza & beer

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmen Anthony

Food is dry yet greasy (somehow), consistently overcooked, incorrect items served up 7.5/10 times we have patronized, and management only has excuses.

Be better off with a taco bell here...

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lindsay Kunkle

5 star experience had by my family (2 adults and 2 7yos). Our server Christian was incredible! He toured the menu with us, made some recommendations, and was incredibly attentive. He was amazing with our two boys and gave my husband an I the royal treatment. The food was so fresh and delicious! The pizza, smash burger, chicken tenders, corn pizza, and honey balls were amazing. Thr pickle martini was outstanding. If you're on the fence- try it! If you go on a Friday evening ask for Christian! You won't be disappointed. Thank you Christian for a great meal and amazing service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patrick Johnston

Service was great pretzels were awesome rest of food was garbage

Michelle Ruff

Now I know why there was a Groupon. The worst pizza ever absolutely disgusting.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Matt Scott

Highly recommend! Went in for a Sunday brunch. Great food, great service, staff was friendly and went above and beyond. Big thanks to Lucca, Christian, Casey and Sam!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...